Foltz v. Public Service Commission
Citations
- 73 Pa. Super. 24
- 1919 Pa. Super. LEXIS 167
Syllabus
<p>Constitutional law — Public service corporations — Street railways —Contracts with municipalities — Bates.</p> <p>The enactment of the Public Service Company Law (Act of July 26, 1913, P. L. 1374), is a proper exercise of the police power of the Commonwealth delegating to the Public Service Commission absolute and exclusive authority to declare the policy of the State, in matters of public concern relating to public service companies, and this power includes the right to declare that any element of a contract, especially a continuing obligation, such as the agreement not to charge more than a given rate of fare, entered into in consideration of the consent of the municipality to the use of its streets by a street railway company, can be declared void, either temporarily or for all time, if, in the opinion of the commission, it would operate to the detriment of the public in interfering with the efficiency of the service of such public service company, or if it amounts to a confiscatory rate. This power to declare what is public policy, under any given state of facts, is .an exclusive delegation to the Public Service Commission.</p> <p>Constitutional law — Constitution of Pennsylvania — Police power —Constitution of the United States — Impairment of contracts.</p> <p>Section 9 of Article XVII of the Constitution of Pennsylvania which provides that “No street passenger railway shall be constructed within the limits of any city, borough or township without the consent of the local authorities” construed in connection with Section 3 of Article XVI of the same Constitution providing that “The exercise of the police power of the State shall never be abridged,” etc., does not deprive the State of authority to regulate the rates of public service corporations for the general welfare of its inhabitants. This delegation of the police power is proper, in so far as the right to declare conditions in such contracts relating to rates contrary to public policy, when entered int
Judges: Orlady, Porter, Trexler, Williams
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
7 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Suburban Water Co. v. Oakmont BoroughSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1920-06-26· cited 40×
- York Telephone & Telegraph Co. v. Pennsylvania Public Utility CommissionSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1956-03-26· cited 9×
- City of Scranton v. Public Service CommissionSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1919-12-08· cited 7×
- Slate Belt Electric Street Railway Co. v. Public Service CommissionSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1920-02-28· cited 4×
- Metal Products Co. v. Beaver Co. Light Co.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1920-02-28· cited 1×
- Durante's PetitionJefferson County Court of Quarter Sessions· 1923-01-29
- Miller v. West Penn Power Co.Fayette County Court· 1927-09-12
Cites
15 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Leiper v. Baltimore & Philadelphia RailroadSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1918-10-07· cited 59×
- St. Clair Borough v. Tamaqua & Pottsville Elec. Ry. Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1918-01-07· cited 50×
- Relief Electric Light, Heat & Power Company's PetitionSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1916-03-01· cited 35×
- Bellevue Borough v. Ohio Valley Water Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1914-04-20· cited 29×
- Ben Avon Boro. v. Ohio Valley Water Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1918-02-25· cited 28×
- V. & S. Bottle Co. v. Mountain Gas Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1918-06-03· cited 19×
- Pottsville Union Traction Co. v. Public Service CommissionSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1917-07-13· cited 15×
- Klein-Logan Co. v. Duquesne Light Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1918-06-03· cited 14×
- Rochester Building & Loan Ass'n v. Beaver Valley Water Co.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1917-07-13· cited 13×
- Turtle Creek Borough v. Penna. Water Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1914-01-05· cited 8×
- Borough of Mount Union v. Mount Union Water Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1917-02-19· cited 6×
- West Virginia Pulp & Paper Co. v. Public Service CommissionSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1916-10-09· cited 4×
- Allied Associations v. Public Service CommissionSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1918-07-10· cited 4×
- Pennsylvania Power Co. v. Public Service CommissionSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1917-05-07· cited 3×
- Perry County Telephone & Telegraph Co. v. Public Service CommissionSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1918-07-10· cited 3×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.