Skip to main content

Fleischer v. Fleischer

Syllabus

The defendant, whose marriage to the plaintiff previously had been dis- solved, appealed to this court from the judgment of the trial court dismissing his motions to modify alimony and for contempt. Although the motions were scheduled to be argued in June, 2015, no activity on the motions occurred until December, 2016, when the court scheduled a status conference, after which a full hearing was scheduled for the motions in April, 2017, when the plaintiff argued that the motions should be dismissed due to the defendant's failure to prosecute the motions with reasonable diligence. Subsequently, the plaintiff filed a motion to dismiss, which the trial court granted for the defendant's failure to prosecute the motions with reasonable diligence. Held that the trial court improperly dismissed the defendant's motions for modification of alimony and for contempt: even though a trial court has wide discretion in determining whether to dismiss an action for failure to prosecute it with due diligence, there are limits to that discretion, and the sanction imposed must be proportional to the violation or misconduct, which did not occur here, as the sanction of dismissal was imposed for a onetime, one and one-half year delay that occurred after the defendant's counsel had been diagnosed with a serious illness, there was no evidence showing that during that period of delay, the defendant was ever ordered to prosecute the motions more expeditiously, the first time that the defendant was confronted with potential dismissal was at the hearing on the merits of the motion to dismiss, the court made no findings in its memorandum of decision that it considered and found inadequate lesser sanctions before dismissing the motions for failure to prosecute them with due diligence, and the delay in prosecuting the motions was due to the illness of the defendant's attorney, which tended not to justify the severe sanction of dismissal; moreover, the defendant provided a compelling reason for the

Judges: Prescott; Bright; Eveleigh

Read full opinion on CourtListener

Cites

7 cases in this archive are cited by this case.

Other cases with this name

Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).

This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.