First Circuit· 5/27/1999
Fitzgerald v. Expressway Sewerage Constraction, Inc.
Citations
- 177 F.3d 71
- 1999 U.S. App. LEXIS 10929
- 1999 WL 330166
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- reaching the same conclusion with respect to Massachusetts’s collateral source rule
- allowing collateral source evidence if the plaintiff opens the door, its relevance is plain, its probative value not outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice and an immediate prophylactic instruction is given as to the limited use for which it was admitted
- \Implementation of the [collateral source rule] gives rise to an evidentiary analogue. This analogue customarily bars the introduction of proof of collateral source payments made to a plaintiff\
- state law, including regarding availability of damages, provides the substantive rules of decision in diversity cases
- “[A] jury, informed, say, that a plaintiff has recourse to first-party insurance proceeds, may be unduly inclined to return either a defendant’s verdict or an artificially low damage award.”
- “Evidence that a third party (the health-care insurer) defrayed most of those costs cast doubt upon (and, thus, tended to undermine) the claim, that the burgeoning medical bills produced financial strain.” (Emphasis added.)
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Selya, Kraviteh, Lipez
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
39 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Faigin v. Kelly & CarucciFirst Circuit· 1999-07-19· cited 164×
- Iacobucci v. Town of PembrokeFirst Circuit· 1999-10-04· cited 156×
- Downey v. Bob's Discount Furniture Holdings, Inc.First Circuit· 2011-01-14· cited 125×
- Correa v. Cruisers, a Division of KCS International, Inc.First Circuit· 2002-07-23· cited 98×
- ML Healthcare Services, LLC v. Publix Super Markets, Inc.Eleventh Circuit· 2018-02-07· cited 74×
- Lund v. San Joaquin Valley RailroadCalifornia Supreme Court· 2003-09-24· cited 65×
- Shervin v. Partners Healthcare System, Inc.First Circuit· 2015-10-09· cited 64×
- United States v. SymonevichFirst Circuit· 2012-07-31· cited 60×
- Gray v. Genlyte Group, Inc.First Circuit· 2002-04-18· cited 39×
- Aumand v. Dartmouth Hitchcock Medical CenterD. New Hampshire· 2009-05-01· cited 29×
- England v. Reinauer Transportation Companies, L.P.First Circuit· 1999-10-25· cited 27×
- Rangel v. AndersonS.D. Georgia· 2016-08-23· cited 23×
- State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance v. SchatkenWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2012-11-16· cited 20×
- Litif v. United StatesFirst Circuit· 2012-01-20· cited 18×
- Short v. Marinas USA Ltd. PartnershipMassachusetts Appeals Court· 2011-03-01· cited 16×
- Corey Lanuza v. Medic Emergency Specialties, Inc.D. Puerto Rico· 2002-10-18· cited 12×
- Adams v. J. Meyers Builders, Inc.D. New Hampshire· 2009-12-02· cited 10×
- Downeast Ventures, Ltd. v. Washington CountyD. Maine· 2006-09-07· cited 10×
- Crowther v. Consolidated Rail Corp.First Circuit· 2012-05-18· cited 8×
- Hill v. Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corp.E.D. California· 2013-05-10· cited 8×
Cites
14 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Erie Railroad v. TompkinsSupreme Court· 1938-04-25· cited 18,491×
- United States v. SaccocciaFirst Circuit· 1995-06-28· cited 281×
- Blinzler v. Marriott International, Inc.First Circuit· 1996-04-12· cited 206×
- Daigle v. Maine Medical Center, Inc.First Circuit· 1994-01-31· cited 140×
- Corsetti v. Stone Co.Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1985-09-19· cited 139×
- Patricia J. McInnis v. A.M.F., Inc., Patricia J. McInnis v. A.M.F., Inc.First Circuit· 1985-07-23· cited 125×
- United States v. Gary LaddFirst Circuit· 1989-09-13· cited 110×
- United States v. Robert F. TierneyFirst Circuit· 1985-05-03· cited 104×
- Goldstein v. GontarzMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1974-03-20· cited 93×
- Jones v. Town of WaylandMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1978-01-18· cited 75×
- Williams v. DrakeFirst Circuit· 1998-07-16· cited 69×
- United States v. Arthur SuttonFirst Circuit· 1992-08-03· cited 63×
- Cameron v. Otto Bock Orthopedic Industry, Inc.First Circuit· 1994-12-30· cited 36×
- Joao Demedeiros v. Koehring Co. v. Parker Brothers Co., Third-Party Joao Demedeiros v. Koehring Co. v. Parker Brothers Co., Third-PartyFirst Circuit· 1983-06-01· cited 28×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.