First National Bank v. McCarthy
Citations
- 18 S.D. 218
- 100 N.W. 14
- 1904 S.D. LEXIS 44
Syllabus
<p>1. On appeal in equity, where the court submitted certain issues to the jury, the conduct of counsel, the charge of the court, and the conduct of the jury are not subject to review, the findings being merely advisory.</p> <p>2. Though findings of the trial court on disputed questions of fact in an equitable action are always presumptively right, it is nevertheless the duty of the court on appeal, in cases tried by court, to review the evidence whenever the question of its sufficiency is properly presented, to ascertain whether or not there is a clear preponderance against the ■ finding’.</p> <p>3. In an action on a note and to foreclose a mortgage securing the same, evidence considered, and held insufficient to support a finding that the ■ note was not a renewal of a former note, which was tainted with usury.</p> <p>4. A note executed as a renewal of a note providing for usurious interest is itself tainted with usury.</p> <p>5. In an action in a state court on a usurious note given to a natianal bank the amount of recovery depends on the law of congress relating to usurious contracts of national banks, as interpreted by the United States Supreme Gourt.</p> <p>6. The only penalty necessarily attached to the exaction of illegal interest by a national bank is the forfeiture of all interest to be paid under the contract.</p> <p>7. In an action by a national bank upon a usurious contract the statute of limitations applies to a counterclaim for the usurious interest.</p> <p>8. Where the mortgagee has merely a lien on the mortgaged property, he cannot, so long as the relation of mortgagor and mortgagee exists, acquire, as against the mortgagor, title to the property by means of a tax sale, where, under the terms of the mortgage, he is permitted to pay the taxes assessed against the laud, and add the amount so paid to his claim.</p> <p>9. In an action to foreclose a mortgage, which provided that, if the mortgagor did not pay the taxes the mortgagee might do so, and add t
Judges: Corson, Haney
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
9 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Black v. GardnerSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1982-06-02· cited 51×
- Gladwin State Bank v. DowMichigan Supreme Court· 1920-12-21· cited 29×
- Lounsberry v. KellySouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1913-06-24· cited 24×
- Bates v. SmithSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1925-10-28· cited 17×
- McCarthy v. First National Bank of Rapid CitySouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1909-05-21· cited 8×
- Gingles v. Savings BankSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1914-03-21· cited 7×
- Vangsness v. BovillSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1931-03-23· cited 5×
- Pfutzenreuter v. PfutzenreuterSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1956-06-19· cited 3×
- South Dakota Wheat Growers Ass'n v. SielerSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1930-05-10· cited 3×
Cites
20 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Randall v. Burk TownshipSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1893-11-24· cited 70×
- Brown v. Marion National BankSupreme Court· 1898-02-21· cited 63×
- Walsh v. MayerSupreme Court· 1884-03-17· cited 42×
- Bridge v.HubbardMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1818-03-15· cited 29×
- Williams v. WilliamsSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1894-04-26· cited 28×
- Finlayson v. PetersonNorth Dakota Supreme Court· 1902-01-03· cited 16×
- First National Bank of Milwaukee v. PlankintonWisconsin Supreme Court· 1870-06-15· cited 15×
- Harrell v. BlountSupreme Court of Georgia· 1901-01-29· cited 14×
- Davis v. ConverseSupreme Court of Vermont· 1863-01-15· cited 12×
- First National Bank v. McCarthySouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1900-07-11· cited 10×
- First National Bank v. TurnerCourt of Appeals of Kansas· 1895-12-07· cited 10×
- Farmers' & Mechanics' Bank of Mercer v. HoaglandU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Western Pennsylvania· 1881-05-10· cited 7×
- Brown v. Second National BankSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1872-11-04· cited 5×
- Safe Deposit & Trust Co. v. WickhemSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1896-11-20· cited 5×
- Farwell v. Sturgis Water Co.South Dakota Supreme Court· 1898-01-22· cited 5×
- Apland v. PottSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1902-03-17· cited 5×
- First National Bank v. McInturffCourt of Appeals of Kansas· 1896-02-06· cited 4×
- Sydner v. Mt. Sterling National BankCourt of Appeals of Kentucky· 1893-03-30· cited 4×
- Safe Deposit & Trust Co. v. WickhemSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1897-03-24· cited 2×
- Mathews' Adm'r v. Traders' BankSupreme Court of Virginia· 1897-03-18· cited 1×
Other cases named First National Bank v. McCarthy
2 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.