Texas Supreme Court· 6/27/2002
Excel Corp. v. Apodaca
Citations
- 81 S.W.3d 817
- 45 Tex. Sup. Ct. J. 962
- 2002 Tex. LEXIS 106
- 2002 WL 1379009
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that plaintiff’s doctors’ testimony that plaintiff’s injury was caused by his work was insufficient to establish legal causation because the evidence “fail[ed] to establish that [plaintiff] would not have been injured but for any negligent conduct by [the defendant].”
- holding that plaintiff failed to present legally sufficient evidence to support jury finding that defendant’s negligence was cause-in-fact of his injuries because he failed to establish that “had [defendant] employed . . . other practices, [plaintiff] would not have been injured”
- holding cause in fact may not be supported by conjecture, guess or speculation, but can be based on either direct or circumstantial evidence
- holding evidence legally insufficient to prove that injury was caused by unsafe work practices where it failed to show that the injury would not have occurred if different practices had been followed
- “Because Excel is a nonsubscriber under the Workers’ Compensation Act, Apodaca sued Excel alleging common-law claims of negligence and gross negligence in failing to provide a safe workplace.”
- “The test for cause in fact, or ‘but for cause,’ is whether the act or omission was a substantial factor in causing the injury ‘without which the harm would not have occurred.’” (quoting Boys Clubs, 907 S.W.2d. at 477)
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Hankinson
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
65 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Columbia Medical Center of Las Colinas v. Bush Ex Rel. BushCourt of Appeals of Texas· 2003-11-20· cited 184×
- Cortez Ex Rel. Estate of Puentes v. HCCI-San Antonio, Inc.Texas Supreme Court· 2005-03-11· cited 122×
- WISE REGIONAL HEALTH SYSTEMS v. BrittainCourt of Appeals of Texas· 2008-09-25· cited 66×
- Town of Flower Mound v. TeagueCourt of Appeals of Texas· 2003-06-26· cited 57×
- Patino v. Complete Tire, Inc.Tex. App. Ct., 5th Dist. (Dallas)· 2005-03-10· cited 45×
- City of Sugarland v. BallardTex. App. Ct., 1st Dist. (Houston)· 2005-01-27· cited 35×
- Batto v. GaffordTex. App. Ct., 10th Dist. (Waco)· 2003-08-20· cited 23×
- Dodge v. DurdinTex. App. Ct., 1st Dist. (Houston)· 2005-12-01· cited 22×
- Reinicke v. Aeroground, Inc.Tex. App. Ct., 14th Dist. (Houston)· 2005-08-04· cited 20×
- PPC Transportation v. MetcalfTex. App. Ct., 12th Dist. (Tyler)· 2008-06-16· cited 18×
- Lakeside Vill. Homeowners Ass'n, Inc. v. BelangerCourt of Appeals of Texas· 2017-06-14· cited 18×
- Hanson v. Greystar Development & Construction, LPCourt of Appeals of Texas· 2010-07-15· cited 17×
- Crown Derrick Erectors, Inc. v. DewTex. App. Ct., 9th Dist. (Beaumont)· 2003-09-25· cited 12×
- E-Z Mart Stores, Inc. v. Ronald Holland's A-Plus Transmission & Automotive, Inc.Tex. App. Ct., 4th Dist. (San Antonio)· 2011-10-11· cited 12×
- McLaurin v. Waffle House, Inc.S.D. Texas· 2016-04-13· cited 10×
- Goss v. Kellogg Brown & Root Inc.Tex. App. Ct., 14th Dist. (Houston)· 2007-08-16· cited 6×
- Sergio Fraire v. Budget Rent-A-Car of El Paso, Inc.Tex. App. Ct., 8th Dist. (El Paso)· 2014-03-28· cited 3×
- Austin v. Kroger Texas L.P.N.D. Texas· 2016-04-25· cited 2×
- Lakomy v. United StatesFifth Circuit· 2003-07-11· cited 2×
- Wald-Tinkle Packaging & Distribution, Inc. v. Eugenio PinokTex. App. Ct., 1st Dist. (Houston)· 2004-12-23
Cites
6 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Doe v. Boys Clubs of Greater Dallas, Inc.Texas Supreme Court· 1995-06-08· cited 1,206×
- Bradford v. VentoTexas Supreme Court· 2001-08-02· cited 994×
- El Chico Corp. v. PooleTexas Supreme Court· 1987-06-03· cited 844×
- Havner v. E-Z Mart Stores, Inc.Texas Supreme Court· 1992-02-26· cited 331×
- Werner v. ColwellTexas Supreme Court· 1995-10-05· cited 240×
- Excel Corp. v. ApodacaTex. App. Ct., 7th Dist. (Amarillo)· 2001-03-16· cited 14×
Other cases named Excel Corp. v. Apodaca
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.