Estate of Sedley Alley v. State of Tennessee

Syllabus

The Appellant, the Estate of Sedley Alley (\the Estate\), appeals from the Shelby County Criminal Court's dismissal of its petition for post-conviction DNA analysis. The 2019 petition sought DNA testing of items from the Defendant's trial despite the fact that the Defendant, who had received the death penalty, was executed in 2006. The Estate argued that the Post-Conviction DNA Analysis Act (\the DNA Act\) permitted the Estate to petition for DNA testing because the civil right of survivorship statute applied. The Estate additionally argued that United States and Tennessee Constitutions require that the Estate be allowed to petition for DNA testing under the DNA Act, citing to principles of due process and a \reputational guarantee.\ Following our review of the applicable authorities, we hold that the Estate is not a \person\ within the purview of the DNA Act and that neither due process nor any reputational guarantee require a remedy under these facts. Accordingly, we affirm the judgment of the post-conviction court.