Estate of Maged Abdelmaguid v. Dimensions Insurance Group LLC

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• finding that control, provision of tools, and significant length of time on the platform were insufficient to apply the doctrine as a matter of law
• noting that while Kerr-McGee could dismiss West from the platform, it could not fire him from his position with the supplying firm, and ultimately finding that there was too much conflicting evidence to grant summary judgment
• “The deposition testimony indicates that although West was not always under direct supervision, he was answerable to Kerr-McGee supervisory personnel.”
• “When . . . a statute contains ‘latent ambiguities’ despite its superficial clarity, we turn to the statute’s legislative history for guidance.”
• “neither control nor any other single answer to the inquiries ‘is decisive, and no fixed test is used to determine the existence of a borrowed-servant relationship.’”
• “neither control nor any other single answer to the inquiries ‘is decisive, and no fixed test is used to determine the existence of a borrowed-servant relationship.’”

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).