Elizabeth Eberbach v. Christopher Eberbach
Citations
- 535 S.W.3d 467
Syllabus
We granted this appeal to determine whether the Court of Appeals may exercise discretion and decline to award appellate attorney's fees when the marital dissolution agreement at issue contains a provision entitling the prevailing party to an award of such fees. In this case, Husband and Wife were parties to a marital dissolution agreement that was incorporated into their final divorce decree (\the Parties' MDA\). The Parties' MDA contained a provision for the award of attorney's fees to the prevailing party in any subsequent legal proceedings. Following a post-divorce proceeding that resulted in the trial court granting relief and awarding attorney's fees to Wife, Husband appealed. Wife also prevailed on appeal and sought an award of appellate attorney's fees from the Court of Appeals under a statutory provision and under the Parties' MDA. Exercising its discretion, the Court of Appeals declined to award the requested fees under the statute. The Court of Appeals erroneously failed to separately consider an award of the requested fees under the Parties' MDA. Accordingly, we reverse the Court of Appeals' judgment and remand this matter for further proceedings consistent with this Opinion.
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that “our courts do not have discretion to deny an award of fees mandated by a valid and enforceable agreement between the parties”
- concluding that on issues other than child support during minority and alimony, the MDA retains its contractual nature
- recognizing that a contractual provision “contain[ing] only permissive language, such as ‘may award,’” is discretionary in nature
- holding that appellate courts lack discretion to deny an award of attorney’s fees mandated by a valid marital dissolution agreement
- recognizing that a contractual provision “contain[ing] only permissive language, such as ‘may award,’” is discretionary in nature
- holding that “former wife was prevailing party at trial and appellate levels, and thus was entitled to attorney’s fees award under mandatory fee provision in parties’ marital dissolution agreement.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Chief Justice Jeffrey S. Bivins
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
162 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Kathryn A. Duke v. Harold W. Duke, IIICourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2018-06-27· cited 19×
- US Framing Int'l LLC v. Continental Building Co.Sixth Circuit· 2025-04-07· cited 7×
- Vlach v. VlachCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2017-10-27· cited 4×
- Mark Karsonovich v. Linda Lee KempeCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2018-02-27
- In Re: Estate of John J. BurnetteCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2018-03-21
- Marilyn (Reso) Ramsey v. Warren A. Reso, Jr.Court of Appeals of Tennessee· 2018-04-11
- Kathlene Denise Roberts v. Willie Dino Roberts, Jr.Court of Appeals of Tennessee· 2018-04-16
- Thomas Nathan Loftis, Sr. v. Randy RayburnCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2018-04-20
- Mariel Bentz Rich v. David Tate Rich, Jr.Court of Appeals of Tennessee· 2018-04-27
- DL Rummage v. Kimberly RummageCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2018-05-09
- James Edgar Yarbrough v. Cheryl Ann Pinegar YarbroughCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2018-05-11
- Desiree Daniels Disterdick v. John DisterdickCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2018-06-18
- In Re: Kylea K.Court of Appeals of Tennessee· 2018-06-21
- Richard Darrell Trigg v. Joseph ChurchCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2018-07-02
- Shay Ryan Doming v. Kelly Deann DomingCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2018-07-05
- April Doris Schmidt v. Aaron Errol AnkromCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2018-08-29
- Misty Oliver Allen v. Mario Pryor AllenCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2018-09-28
- William James Jekot v. Pennie Christine JekotCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2018-09-28
- Nancy Maureen Jarman v. Franklin N. JarmanCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2018-10-31
- Kerry Douglas Friesen v. Beverley Joy Friesen - concurringCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2018-11-05
Cites
22 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Bob Pearsall Motors, Inc. v. Regal Chrysler-Plymouth, Inc.Tennessee Supreme Court· 1975-03-03· cited 322×
- Taylor v. FezellTennessee Supreme Court· 2005-01-14· cited 309×
- State v. Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp.Tennessee Supreme Court· 2000-04-19· cited 291×
- Johnson v. JohnsonTennessee Supreme Court· 2001-02-23· cited 251×
- Archer v. ArcherCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 1995-04-21· cited 249×
- Chiozza v. ChiozzaCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2009-11-20· cited 242×
- Cracker Barrel Old Country Store, Inc. v. EppersonTennessee Supreme Court· 2009-05-01· cited 228×
- Barnes v. BarnesTennessee Supreme Court· 2006-05-17· cited 207×
- Keyt v. KeytTennessee Supreme Court· 2007-12-19· cited 183×
- Airline Construction, Inc. v. BarrCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 1990-12-11· cited 159×
- Whalum v. MarshallCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2006-05-09· cited 137×
- Christenberry v. TiptonTennessee Supreme Court· 2005-03-17· cited 102×
- U.S. Bank, N.A. v. Tennessee Farmers Mutual Insurance Co.Tennessee Supreme Court· 2009-01-29· cited 92×
- Towner v. TownerTennessee Supreme Court· 1993-07-06· cited 83×
- Deas v. DeasTennessee Supreme Court· 1989-07-10· cited 82×
- Elliott v. ElliottCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2004-04-08· cited 66×
- House v. Estate of EdmondsonTennessee Supreme Court· 2008-01-25· cited 65×
- Bob Fannon, Individually and as a City Councilman for the City of LaFollette v. City of LaFollotteTennessee Supreme Court· 2010-12-21· cited 56×
- Honeycutt v. HoneycuttCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2003-12-12· cited 49×
- Blackburn v. BlackburnTennessee Supreme Court· 1975-08-18· cited 49×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.