Duff v. Fisher
Citations
- 15 Cal. 375
Syllabus
<p>The findings of the jury on issues submitted to them in an equity case, if not objected to by motion for new trial, or if not set aside by the Court on its own motion, become established facts in the ease, and cannot be questioned in the Supreme Court for the first time.</p> <p>The Practice Act applies as well to legal as equitable actions, so far as its provisions are consistent with the rights and remedies administered in Courts of Equity. And the only way in which the verdict of a jury on issues submitted can be reviewed, is by motion for new trial—except, probably, that the Court, whether sitting in equity or on the trial of a common law action, may, of its own motion, set aside the verdict of a jury when clearly and palpably against the evidence.</p> <p>The old chancery rule on this subject stated.</p> <p>Though, on questions of practice, previous decisions are entitled to very great weight, still a single decision, made without notice of a statute, and in fact, setting aside the statute, cannot be invoked as authority on the principle of stare decisis.</p> <p>In suit by a vendee for specific performance of a contract of sale, the averment of tender of payment was in general terms—as that the tender had been repeatedly made, and that the plaintiff has been at all times, and still is ready and willing to pay; Held, that the tender should have been stated with greater particularity as to time, but that the objection, in this respect, cannot be taken for the first time in the Supreme Court.</p>
Judges: Field
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
19 cases in this archive cite this case.
- De Vall v. De VallOregon Supreme Court· 1911-11-14· cited 35×
- Hutton v. ReedCalifornia Supreme Court· 1864-07-01· cited 29×
- Hihn v. PeckCalifornia Supreme Court· 1866-07-15· cited 26×
- Senter v. DavisCalifornia Supreme Court· 1869-07-01· cited 26×
- Whitmore v. ShiverickNevada Supreme Court· 1867-07-01· cited 21×
- Environmental Defense Fund, Inc. v. East Bay Municipal Utility DistrictCalifornia Supreme Court· 1977-12-20· cited 18×
- Moinet v. Burnham, Stoepel & Co.Michigan Supreme Court· 1906-03-27· cited 15×
- Hubbard v. Bibb Brokerage Co.Court of Appeals of Georgia· 1931-05-15· cited 13×
- Hubbell v. City of Des MoinesSupreme Court of Iowa· 1915-10-02· cited 11×
- Doe v. VallejoCalifornia Supreme Court· 1866-07-01· cited 10×
- Carpentier v. AthertonCalifornia Supreme Court· 1864-07-01· cited 9×
- California Bank v. SchlesingerCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1958-03-26· cited 8×
- Silva v. PickardUtah Supreme Court· 1896-10-27· cited 8×
- Gagliardo v. HoberlinCalifornia Supreme Court· 1861-07-01· cited 6×
- Allen v. FennonCalifornia Supreme Court· 1864-07-01· cited 4×
- Smith v. RichardsonUtah Supreme Court· 1880-06-15· cited 3×
- Wehen v. LundgaardCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1940-11-22· cited 2×
- Carpenter v. AthertonCalifornia Supreme Court· 1864-08-16
- California Bank v. SchlesingerAppellate Division of the Superior Court of California· 1958-03-26
Cites
3 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.