Duel v. Hollins
Citations
- 241 U.S. 523
- 36 S. Ct. 615
- 60 L. Ed. 1143
- 1916 U.S. LEXIS 1732
Syllabus
<p>A bankrupt firm of brokers having, prior to bankruptcy carried on marginal transactions for several different customers in shares of stock of the same corporation amounting in the aggregate to more than the number of shares of that stock in their possession at the time of. the bankruptcy, and none of such shares being-identified as the particular shares carried for any of the respective customers, but all of whom demanded their full quota of shares and offered to pay the amount due thereon, held that:</p> <p>Brokers and their customers stand in the relation of pledgee and pledgor.</p> <p>In dealings between brokers and customers stock certificates issued by the same corporation lack individuality; they are, like receipts for coin, to be treated as indistinguishable tokens of actual values.</p> <p>As between themselves, after paying the amount due the broker on a marginal transaction, the customer has a right to demand from the broker delivery of stock purchased for his account and such a delivery may be made during insolvency without creating a preference.</p> <p>Thé fact that the bankrupt broker in this case did not have sufficient shares of stock of a corporation on hand at the time of his bankruptcy to satisfy the demands of all of his customers entitled to shares of that particular stock held not to prevent such customers from obtaining any of such shares, and require that all of such shares go into the general estate, but held that all of such customers were entitled to such shares .and on demanding the same and paying the amounts respectively due thereon, should participate pro rata in a division of the shares actually on hand;</p>
Judges: McReynolds, Pitney, Hughes
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
44 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Helvering v. RankinSupreme Court· 1935-04-29· cited 264×
- Provost v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1926-01-11· cited 97×
- Commonwealth v. HullMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1937-01-02· cited 42×
- In re BolognesiSecond Circuit· 1918-11-13· cited 31×
- Henkels v. SutherlandSupreme Court· 1926-05-24· cited 30×
- Calvin H. East and Joyce E. East v. William W. Crowdus, Receiver of All Assets and Property of Arthur C. Costello and Investment Services, Inc.Eighth Circuit· 1962-04-24· cited 16×
- Somerville National Bank v. HornblowerMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1936-01-31· cited 15×
- China Fire Ins. Co. v. DavisSecond Circuit· 1931-06-08· cited 13×
- Miller v. CommissionerSecond Circuit· 1935-12-09· cited 12×
- Equitable Trust Co. of New York v. Connecticut Brass & Mfg. Corp.Second Circuit· 1926-03-01· cited 11×
- Ream v. McCreaNinth Circuit· 1923-11-05· cited 11×
- Zenor v. McFarlinEighth Circuit· 1916-12-04· cited 10×
- In re P. J. Sullivan Co.N.D. New York· 1918-01-04· cited 9×
- In re SolomonSecond Circuit· 1920-07-03· cited 9×
- Lavien v. NormanFirst Circuit· 1932-01-20· cited 8×
- Crowell v. CommissionerBoard of Tax Appeals· 1930-12-22· cited 8×
- Putnam v. FordSupreme Court of Virginia· 1930-11-13· cited 8×
- Israel v. WoodruffSecond Circuit· 1924-05-15· cited 8×
- Leonard v. HuntFirst Circuit· 1929-11-19· cited 7×
- Sexton v. American Trust Co.Eighth Circuit· 1930-11-29· cited 7×
Cites
4 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.