Downes v. Bidwell
Citations
- 182 U.S. 244
- 21 S. Ct. 770
- 45 L. Ed. 1088
- 1901 U.S. LEXIS 286
Syllabus
<p>By Mr. Justice Brown, in announcing the conclusion and judgment of the court.</p> <p>The Circuit Courts have jurisdiction, regardless of amount, of actions against a collector of customs for duties exacted and paid under protest upon merchandise alleged not to have been imported.</p> <p>The island of Porto Rico is not a part of the United States within that provision of the Constitution which declares that “ all duties, imposts, and excises shall be uniform throughout the United States.”</p> <p>There is a clear distinction between such prohibitions of the Constitution' as go to the very root of the power of Congress to act at all, irrespective of time or place, and such as are operative only throughout the United States, or among the several States.</p> <p>A long continued and uniform interpretation, put by the executive and legislative departments of the government, upon a clause in the Constitution should be followed b.y the judicial department, unless such interpretation be manifestly contrary to its letter or spirit.</p> <p>By Mr. Justice White, with whom Mr. Jdstice Shibas and Mr. Justice McKenna concurred.</p> <p>The government of the United States was born of the Constitution, and all powers which it enjoys or may exercise must be either derived expressly or by implication from that instrument. Ever then, when an act of any department is challenged, because not warranted by the Constitution, the existence of the authority is to be ascertained by determining whether the power has been conferred by the Constitution, either in express terms or by lawful implication, to be drawn from the express authority conferred or deduced as an attribute which legitimately inheres in the nature of the powers given, and which flows from the character of the government established by the Constitution. In other words, whilst confined to its constitutional orbit, the government of the United States is supreme within its lawful sphere.</p> <p>Every function of the government be
About this case
Downes v. Bidwell
Downes v. Bidwell, 182 U.S. 244 (1901), was a case in which the US Supreme Court decided whether US territories were subject to the provisions and protections of the US Constitution . The issue is sometimes stated as whether the Constitution follows the flag. The decision narrowly held that the Constitution does not necessarily apply to territories. Instead, the US Congress has jurisdiction to create law within territories in certain circumstances, particularly those dealing with revenue, which would not be allowed by the Constitution for US states. It has become known as one of the "Insular Cases ".
Contents
Background
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Downes_v._Bidwell&action=edit§ion=1 "Edit section: Background")
The case specifically concerned a merchant, Samuel Downes, who owned S. B. Downes & Company. His company had imported oranges into the Port of New York from the newly-acquired territory of Puerto Rico and had been forced to pay import duties on them. He sued George R. Bidwell, the US customs inspector for the port of New York.
The Supreme Court in _DeLima v. Bidwell _ had decided that ever since Puerto Rico had been acquired by the United States from Spain in the Treaty of Paris (1898) , normal customs levied on imports from foreign countries did not apply to imports from Puerto Rico since it had ceased to be a foreign country.[1]
However, the Foraker Act now levied customs specifically on imports from Puerto Rico. Downes disputed its constitutionality on the grounds that such duties were under the jurisdiction of Article I, Section 8, of the US Constitution , which provides that "all duties, imposts, and excises shall be uniform throughout the United States." Since the duty on oranges did not exist for other parts of the United States, he argued that it should not exist for Puerto Rico.
Decision
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Downes_v._Bidwell&action=edit§ion=2 "Edit section: Decision")
The Supreme Court decided 5–4 that the newly-annexed territories were not properly part of the United States for purposes of the Constitution in the matter of revenues, administrative matters, and the like. However, the court was careful to note that the constitutional guarantees of a citizen's rights of liberty and property were applicable to all and "cannot be under any circumstances transcended", according to Justice Edward Douglass White 's concurring opinion .[2]
Territories were due the full protections of the Constitution only when Congress had incorporated them as an "integral part" of the United States. The court's doctrinal statement distinguished the District of Columbia from all other territories by observing that it had been derived from land that was within state boundaries. The court said that, once Congress extended the Constitution's full reach to that land, Congress lacked the power to withdraw it by any means.
One of two dissenting opinions was written by Justice John Marshall Harlan , who would have held that Congress was always bound to enact laws within the jurisdiction of the Constitution: "This nation is under the control of a written constitution, the supreme law of the land and the only source of the powers which our government, or any branch or officer of it, may exert at any time or at any place." He held that the Congress had no existence and thus had no authority outside the Constitution. He continued:
The idea prevails with some, indeed it has expression in arguments at the bar, that we have in this country substantially two national governments; one to be maintained under the Constitution, with all its restrictions; the other to be maintained by Congress outside and independently of that instrument, by exercising such powers as other nations of the earth are accustomed to. ... I take leave to say that, if the principles thus announced should ever receive the sanction of a majority of this court, a radical and mischievous change in our system will result. We will, in that event, pass from the era of constitutional liberty guarded and protected by a written constitution into an era of legislative absolutism. ... It will be an evil day for American Liberty if the theory of a government outside the Supreme Law of the Land finds lodgment in our Constitutional Jurisprudence. No higher duty rests upon this court than to exert its full authority to prevent all violation of the principles of the Constitution.[3]
Aftermath
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Downes_v._Bidwell&action=edit§ion=3 "Edit section: Aftermath")
The idea of territorial incorporation is generally agreed to have arisen from Justice White's concurring decision noted above.[_dubious
– discuss
_] "Incorporation", in this sense, does not refer to the legal process whereby a company takes on certain of the characteristics of a person (see incorporation
). The concept of "territorial incorporation" is that the United States can be proprietor of a territory without having actually incorporated that territory into the United States.
Unincorporated territories are not due the full benefits of the US Constitution, as noted from Justice White's decision above.
The idea has been used in court cases ever since to affirm that the citizens of certain territories can be subject to laws and regulations that are not constitutionally applicable to other citizens of the United States. Many citizens of territories that have been designated unincorporated have seen the principle of territorial incorporation as a form of oppression.[4]
References
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Downes_v._Bidwell&action=edit§ion=4 "Edit section: References")
- ↑ _DeLima v. Bidwell _, 182 U.S. 1 (1901).
- ↑ Downes, 182 U.S. at 294–95 (White, J., concurring).
- ↑ Downes, 182 U.S. at 380–382 (Harlan, J., dissenting).
- ↑ See, e.g., Ediberto Román, The Alien-Citizen Paradox and Other Consequences of U.S. Colonialism , 26 Florida State University Law Review 1 (1998; original location ).
External links
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Downes_v._Bidwell&action=edit§ion=5 "Edit section: External links")
Works related to Downes v. Bidwell at Wikisource
Text of Downes v. Bidwell, 182 U.S. 244 (1901) is available from: Findlaw Google Scholar Justia Library of Congress
"The Insular Cases" . Dan MacMeekin, Island Law. Retrieved February 17, 2005.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Downes_v._Bidwell&oldid=1362243872 "
Editorial context from Wikipedia (CC-BY-SA 4.0).
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that Puerto Rico did not become a part of the United States within the meaning of Article I, section 8 of the Constitution
- holding the revenue clauses of the Constitution did not “extend of their own force to our newly acquired territories”
- people of Philippines protected in their personal rights from arbitrary control of Congress in part because of due process and equal protection guarantees of Constitution
- ”[T]he Island of Porto Rico is a territory appurtenanl and belonging to the United States, but not a part of the United States” for revenue purposes
- La CC-2009-1091 21 Constitución de Estados Unidos no se extiende a los territorios no incorporados
- racial differences are among the difficulties Congress must face in annexing distant territories
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Brown, Gray, White, Shiras, McKenna, Fuller, Harlan, Brewer, Peokham
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
322 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Baker v. CarrSupreme Court· 1962-03-26· cited 6,173×
- Green v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1957-12-16· cited 3,075×
- Poe v. UllmanSupreme Court· 1961-10-09· cited 1,202×
- Boumediene v. BushSupreme Court· 2008-06-12· cited 1,000×
- United States v. Curtiss-Wright Export Corp.Supreme Court· 1936-12-21· cited 830×
- Reid v. CovertSupreme Court· 1957-06-10· cited 828×
- United States v. Verdugo-UrquidezSupreme Court· 1990-02-28· cited 810×
- Glidden Co. v. ZdanokSupreme Court· 1962-06-25· cited 689×
- Johnson v. EisentragerSupreme Court· 1950-06-05· cited 516×
- Palmore v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1973-04-24· cited 502×
- Examining Bd. of Engineers, Architects and Surveyors v. Flores De OteroSupreme Court· 1976-06-17· cited 441×
- Krim M. Ballentine v. United StatesThird Circuit· 2007-05-10· cited 388×
- Balzac v. Porto RicoSupreme Court· 1922-04-10· cited 387×
- National Mutual Insurance v. Tidewater Transfer Co.Supreme Court· 1949-10-10· cited 328×
- Dorr v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1904-05-31· cited 258×
- O'Donoghue v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1933-05-29· cited 248×
- Parker v. District of ColumbiaD.C. Circuit· 2007-03-09· cited 230×
- Torres v. Puerto RicoSupreme Court· 1979-06-18· cited 223×
- Pacific Steamship Co. v. PetersonSupreme Court· 1928-11-26· cited 204×
- Hooven & Allison Co. v. EvattSupreme Court· 1945-04-23· cited 189×
Cites
44 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Yick Wo v. HopkinsSupreme Court· 1886-05-10· cited 3,789×
- Gibbons v. OgdenSupreme Court· 1824-03-18· cited 2,543×
- Cohens v. VirginiaSupreme Court· 1821-03-18· cited 2,076×
- Reynolds v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1879-01-18· cited 1,827×
- Knowlton v. MooreSupreme Court· 1900-05-14· cited 739×
- United States v. KagamaSupreme Court· 1886-05-10· cited 738×
- Shively v. BowlbySupreme Court· 1894-03-05· cited 734×
- Fong Yue Ting v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1893-05-15· cited 692×
- Monongahela Navigation Co. v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1893-03-27· cited 665×
- Wong Wing v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1896-05-18· cited 526×
- Edye v. RobertsonSupreme Court· 1884-12-22· cited 500×
- Thompson v. UtahSupreme Court· 1898-04-25· cited 472×
- Bauman v. RossSupreme Court· 1897-05-24· cited 467×
- Interstate Commerce Commission v. BrimsonSupreme Court· 1894-05-26· cited 366×
- Brown v. HoustonSupreme Court· 1885-05-04· cited 286×
- United States v. PerchemanSupreme Court· 1833-02-14· cited 249×
- United States v. Joint Traffic Assn.Supreme Court· 1898-10-24· cited 248×
- License Tax CasesSupreme Court· 1867-01-28· cited 219×
- Barney v. Baltimore CitySupreme Court· 1868-02-10· cited 216×
- Lem Moon Sing v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1895-05-27· cited 210×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.