Dorr's Adm'r v. Rohr
Citations
- 82 Va. 359
- 1886 Va. LEXIS 44
Syllabus
<p>1. Judgments—Jurisdiction—Notice—Proceedings inrem.—Notice and opportunity to be heard are essential to the jurisdiction of all courts, even in proceedings in rem, and judgment without jurisdiction is a nullity.</p> <p>2. Order of Publication—Notice— War.—During the war between the Confederate States and the United States, an order of publication, executed in Virginia, was without legal effect, and no notice, actual or constructive, upon a resident of New York.</p> <p>3. Foreign Attachments—Notice to garnishee.-—Nor could jurisdiction be acquired of the fund attached by service of process on the garnishee, at such period, no legal service of notice being had on the non-resident defendant. Code 1873, ch. 148, sec. 20.</p> <p>4. Idem— Garnishee—Non-resident.—A garnishee in a foreign attachment is not the agent and representative of his creditor, the principal defendant; hence a seizure of the res, or attached fund, is not notice to the non-resident defendant, and cannot give jurisdiction.</p> <p>5. Idem—Statute of liynitations—Case at bar.-—In such case of attachment in equity instituted in July, 1861, upon service of process on resident garnishee and execution of order of publication against non-resident debtor in New York, the proceedings subsequent to the attachment having been set aside and an amended bill filed, and the non-resident debtor brought for the first time before the court the running of the statute of limitations was not suspended by those proceedings, and the plaintiff’s claim being an account for work and labor done, was barred before the filing of said amended bill.</p> <p>6. Idem—Saving clause—Appellate court.—Nor is plaintiff’s claim saved by Code 1873, ch. 146, sec. 20, which applies to a debtor “ who had before resided in this State,” and not to one who, like the debtor in this ease, had never resided here. Moreover, such defense, not having been raised by replication in court below, canhot, for the first time, be made in this court.</p> <p>7
Judges: Lewis
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
15 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Mendenhall v. Douglas L. Cooper, Inc.Supreme Court of Virginia· 1990-01-12· cited 64×
- D'Autremont v. Anderson Iron Co.Supreme Court of Minnesota· 1908-05-01· cited 26×
- Moore v. SmithSupreme Court of Virginia· 1941-06-09· cited 22×
- Shenandoah V. R. R. v. Ashby's TrusteesSupreme Court of Virginia· 1889-06-27· cited 21×
- O'Hara v. Pittston Co.Supreme Court of Virginia· 1947-04-21· cited 16×
- Webb v. United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co.Supreme Court of Virginia· 1935-11-14· cited 14×
- McClanahan's Administrator v. Norfolk & Western Railway Co.Supreme Court of Virginia· 1916-01-13· cited 9×
- In re the Accounting of Security Trust Co.New York Surrogate's Court· 1947-04-30· cited 8×
- International Coins & Currency, Inc. v. Andrasko (In Re International Coins & Currency, Inc.)D. Vermont· 1982-06-09· cited 3×
- Ginda & Wax, Inc. v. LundquistChesterfield County Circuit Court· 1990-02-16· cited 1×
- Phippen v. DurhamSupreme Court of Virginia· 1852-01-15
- Cropper v. CommonwealthGeneral Court of Virginia· 1843-12-15
- Hatfield v. Elco Elevator Corp.Alexandria County Circuit Court· 1981-11-06
- Mason v. Board of Zoning AppealsFairfax County Circuit Court· 1991-10-02
- Kelly v. MeierFairfax County Circuit Court· 1991-10-17
Cites
9 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- St. Clair v. CoxSupreme Court· 1882-12-18· cited 402×
- The MARY, Stafford, MastfSupreme Court· 1815-02-25· cited 152×
- Henry Miller's Heirs & Devisees v. M'IntyreSupreme Court· 1832-01-21· cited 75×
- Diggs v. WolcottSupreme Court· 1807-02-28· cited 72×
- Haines v. CarpenterSupreme Court· 1876-01-17· cited 57×
- Dewing v. PerdicariesSupreme Court· 1878-01-28· cited 38×
- M'kim v. VoorhiesSupreme Court· 1812-03-14· cited 32×
- Fultz v. BrightwellSupreme Court of Virginia· 1883-09-27· cited 10×
- Dorr v. GibboneyU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Western Virginia· 1878-06-02· cited 4×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.