Donna Porcaro v. Director, Division of Taxation

Syllabus

Tax Court: , Docket No. 012296-2020 opinion by Bedrin Murray, J.T.C., decided May 31, 2024. For plaintiffs – Donna Porcaro (Self-Represented) for defendant – Linzhi Wang (Matthew Platkin, Attorney General of New Jersey, attorney). Held: Plaintiff's challenge to defendant's denial of her claim for a refund of New Jersey gross income tax (GIT) for tax year 2016 is dismissed as untimely, depriving this court of subject matter jurisdiction. Based on the totality of credible testimonial and documentary evidence presented, the court finds that plaintiff received defendant's December 21, 2017 final determination denying plaintiff's refund claim in December 2017, and not in May 2020 as plaintiff alleges. Therefore, plaintiff was unable to overcome the presumption of receipt that attaches to defendant's final determination under N.J.S.A. 54:50-6(a). As such, plaintiff's complaint is dismissed with prejudice. (18 Pages)