Davis v. Pennsylvania Railroad
Citations
- 215 Pa. 581
- 64 A. 774
- 1906 Pa. LEXIS 854
Syllabus
<p>Railroads — Condemnation proceedings — Witness—Expert—Cross-examination — Evidence.</p> <p>On the trial of a proceeding to assess damages for land condemned by a railroad company, it is error to refuse to permit the counsel for the railroad to cross-examine the landowner’s witnesses as to their competency before they testify in chief as to the value of the land and the damages sustained.</p> <p>In such a case, as the competency of the witnesses is a primary question for the court, it should be made to appear and be passed upon by the court before the witnesses are permitted to express any opinion. It is not sufficient that if, after the witnesses have testified in chief as to the damages in the case, it should appear on cross-examination that they did not have the requisite knowledge to make them competent, their testimony could then be struck out. The harm done by the submission of their opinions to the jury cannot be cured.</p> <p>In a railroad condemnation case it is error to deny to the counsel of the railroad the right to interrogate the landowner’s witnesses on cross-examinafion as to the value of a part of the plaintiff’s land after it had been cut by the railroad. Although such questions cannot be asked the witnesses in their examination-in-chief, they are entirely proper on cross-examination.</p> <p>In a railroad condemnation case counsel for the railroad company cannot be permitted to show the price at which the plaintiff purchased the land seventeen years prior to the time when the railroad company entered upon it.</p>
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that the trial court properly excluded evidence as to a seventeen-year-old purchase price, the court stating that such evidence would have given the jury no proper estimate of its value “immediately before the taking.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Bbown, Elkin, Fell, Mestbezat, Mestrezat, Pobteb
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
14 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Rea v. Pittsburg & Connellsville RailroadSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1910-07-01· cited 35×
- Bern-Shaw Ltd. Partnership v. Mayor of BaltimoreCourt of Appeals of Maryland· 2003-10-08· cited 29×
- White v. Western Allegheny RailroadSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1909-01-04· cited 23×
- Gulf Refining Co. v. DavisMississippi Supreme Court· 1955-05-23· cited 17×
- Klick v. CommonwealthCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania· 1975-08-04· cited 17×
- Spiwak v. Allegheny CountySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1950-11-21· cited 16×
- Stone v. Delaware, Lackawanna & Western RailroadSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1917-04-16· cited 12×
- Lavan v. MenakerSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1924-05-19· cited 10×
- Kittanning Borough v. Garretts Run Gas Co.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1908-02-28· cited 6×
- Tiffany v. Delaware, Lackawanna & Western RailroadSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1918-10-07· cited 5×
- Garella v. Redevelopment AuthoritySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1964-01-08· cited 2×
- Hughes v. StateArizona Supreme Court· 1927-12-19· cited 1×
- Greider v. Elizabethtown & Florin Street Railway Co.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1913-02-27
- Knickerbocker Lime Co. v. PhiladelphiaPhiladelphia County Court of Common Pleas· 1930-10-16
Cites
2 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
Other cases named Davis v. Pennsylvania Railroad
4 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.