Eighth Circuit· 8/17/1998
Costner v. URS Consultants, Inc.
Citations
- 153 F.3d 667
- 1998 WL 477084
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- indicating that a lawsuit is not a \challenge\ under § 113(h) if it \would not involve altering the terms of [a] cleanup order\ and \would result only in financial penalties\ (citation omitted)
- discussing analogue administrative proceedings bar in the Federal False Claims Act and describing it as a “jurisdictional bar”
- considering potential applicability of bar where relators filed qui tam action following 25 “previous suits and administrative proceedings in which the government has participated”
- distinguishing between claims made against government funds and claims made against private funds
- “Regarding the ‘same claims or causes of action’ element of claim preclusion, we have stated that whether a second lawsuit is precluded turns on whether its claims arise out of the ‘same nucleus of operative facts as the prior claim.’ ”
- “[W]hether a second lawsuit is precluded turns on whether its claims arise out of the ‘same nucleus of operative facts as the prior claim.’”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Wollman, Murphy, Doty
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
76 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- APWU v. PotterSecond Circuit· 2003-09-15· cited 412×
- Yapp v. Excel CorporationTenth Circuit· 1999-08-03· cited 292×
- Unnamed caseThird Circuit· 2001-08-16· cited 151×
- United States of America, Ex Rel. A+ Homecare, Inc. v. Medshares Management Group, Inc. Trevecca Home Health Services, Inc., Stephen H. WintersSixth Circuit· 2005-03-10· cited 122×
- United States ex rel. Costner v. United StatesEighth Circuit· 2003-01-28· cited 105×
- Tracey Daley, and Other Similarly Situated Persons v. Marriott International, Inc., Tracey Daley v. Marriott Health Plan Empire Blue Cross/blue ShieldEighth Circuit· 2005-07-25· cited 80×
- Wisconsin Bell, Inc. v. United States ex rel. HeathSupreme Court· 2025-02-21· cited 80×
- Yankton Sioux Tribe v. United States Department of Health & Human ServicesEighth Circuit· 2008-07-07· cited 71×
- United States Ex Rel. Absher v. Momence Meadows Nursing Center, Inc.Seventh Circuit· 2014-08-20· cited 70×
- United States v. Southland Management Corp.Fifth Circuit· 2002-05-22· cited 65×
- United States v. United StatesEighth Circuit· 2003-01-28· cited 56×
- United States v. Hercules, Inc.Eighth Circuit· 2001-04-10· cited 52×
- United States v. Planned Parenthood of the HeartlandEighth Circuit· 2014-08-29· cited 45×
- Paul Allen Olson v. Fairview Health Services of MNEighth Circuit· 2016-08-08· cited 44×
- Laurie Simpson v. Bayer HealthcareEighth Circuit· 2013-10-15· cited 41×
- Regions Bank v. J.R. Oil Co.Eighth Circuit· 2004-10-14· cited 39×
- United States v. Southland ManagementFifth Circuit· 2003-04-01· cited 36×
- Broward Gardens Tenants Ass'n v. United States Environmental Protection AgencyEleventh Circuit· 2002-11-05· cited 36×
- Regions Bank v. J.R. Oil CompanyEighth Circuit· 2004-10-14· cited 36×
- M.M. Silta, Inc. v. Cleveland Cliffs, Inc.Eighth Circuit· 2010-08-17· cited 32×
Cites
37 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Montana v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1979-02-22· cited 3,633×
- United States v. Neifert-White Co.Supreme Court· 1968-03-05· cited 282×
- Rainwater v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1958-05-26· cited 226×
- United States ex rel. Hopper v. AntonNinth Circuit· 1996-07-31· cited 224×
- United States of America, Ex Rel. Kevin G. Kelly v. The Boeing CompanyNinth Circuit· 1993-11-05· cited 219×
- United States of America, Ex Rel. Stinson, Lyons, Gerlin & Bustamante, P.A. v. The Prudential Insurance CompanyThird Circuit· 1991-10-10· cited 217×
- United States v. McNinchSupreme Court· 1958-05-26· cited 207×
- Stanley D. Rabushka, Ex Rel. United States of America Stanley D. Rabushka v. Crane CompanyEighth Circuit· 1997-09-16· cited 199×
- UNITED STATES of America, Ex Rel. Charles H. GLASS, Appellant, v. MEDTRONIC, INC., AppelleeEighth Circuit· 1992-02-26· cited 185×
- Martha POE, Appellant, v. JOHN DEERE COMPANY, AppelleeEighth Circuit· 1982-12-17· cited 166×
- United States v. Alemany RiveraFirst Circuit· 1995-06-06· cited 119×
- United States v. GurleyEighth Circuit· 1994-12-28· cited 102×
- AmeriSource Corp. v. HJB, Inc.Supreme Court· 1998-03-23· cited 95×
- Boarhead Corporation v. Edwin B. Erickson, Region Administrator, United States Environmental Protection Agency, Region IIIThird Circuit· 1991-01-16· cited 80×
- Robert P. McCarney and Elizabeth H. McCarney v. Ford Motor CompanyEighth Circuit· 1981-09-22· cited 77×
- McClellan Ecological Seepage Situation v. PerryNinth Circuit· 1995-01-30· cited 68×
- United States v. John A. O'connell, Jr., Appeal of St. Augustine Trawler, Inc.First Circuit· 1989-12-06· cited 64×
- In Re United States of America, Ex Rel. S. Prawer and Company v. Fleet Bank of MaineFirst Circuit· 1994-05-05· cited 59×
- William Thomas Roach v. Teamsters Local Union No. 688, a Labor Organization, Alfred D. Russom v. Teamsters Local Union No. 688, a Labor OrganizationEighth Circuit· 1979-04-26· cited 58×
- United States of America, Ex Rel. Stanley D. Rabushka Stanley D. Rabushka, Individually v. Crane Company, Cf & I Steel CorporationEighth Circuit· 1995-01-19· cited 56×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.