Skip to main content

Commonwealth v. Pennsylvania Railroad

Citations

  • 72 Pa. Super. 353
  • 1919 Pa. Super. LEXIS 313

Syllabus

<p>Criminal procedure — Indictment for maintaining a nuisance— Motion in arrest of judgment.</p> <p>A motion in arrest of judgment is not the recognized way by which to assail the sufficiency of the evidence of the Commonwealth to support a conviction. The established and proper method of raising that question is by submitting a point for a binding direction from the trial judge in favor of the defendant. If that be refused and such refusal, on appeal, is found to be erroneous, the judgment will be reversed and the defendant discharged.</p> <p>Practice, Q. 8. — Power of court to enter judgment n. o. v. — Act of April 22,1905, P. L. 286.</p> <p>The court of quarter sessions doeg not have the power, in the trial of an indictment, to do what .the court of common pleas may with propriety do in the disposition of a civil case. In the trial in the quarter sessions, the Commonwealth must carry the same burden in every case and it may not ask the court, upon the consideration of the whole of the evidence, to direct a verdict in its favor and, under the same reasoning, the court cannot enter judgment in favor of the defendant, in spite of the verdict of the jury.</p> <p>Criminal law — Indictment for maintaining a nuisance — Navigable streams — Water supply commission.</p> <p>The Act of June 25,1913, P. L. 555, giving control of the streams of the Commonwealth to the Water Supply Commission, does not prevent a prosecution for the maintenance of a public nuisance in' a navigable stream, nor does the consent of the Water Supply Commission or the certificate from the secretary of war authorizing certain constructions in a navigable stream justify acts, which under the law of the Commonwealth might otherwise be indictable. The latter permit merely expresses the assent of the federal government so far as it concerns public rights of navigation.</p> <p>Criminal procedure — Motion in arrest of judgment — New trials.</p> <p>Where a motion for a new trial was formally disposed of by t

Judges: Head, Henderson, Keller, Orlady, Porter, Trexler, Williams

Read full opinion on CourtListener

Cited by

9 cases in this archive cite this case.

Cites

5 cases in this archive are cited by this case.

Other cases named Commonwealth v. Pennsylvania Railroad

5 other CourtListener records share this case name.

Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).

This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.