Commonwealth v. Minnich
Citations
- 250 Pa. 363
- 95 A. 565
- 1915 Pa. LEXIS 951
Syllabus
<p>Criminal law — Murder—Accessory—Guilt of principal — Proof— Record of conviction — Words and phrases — “Conviction”—Evidence — Proximity to crime — Threats.</p> <p>1. There can. be no conviction of one charged as an accessory except as the guilt of the principal be first established.</p> <p>2. In the separate trial of one charged as an accessory, the same burden rests on the Commonwealth to establish the guilt of the principal as would have rested upon it were the principal himself being tried, and the same measure of proof is required in one case as in the other.</p> <p>3. The record of the conviction of the principal while not conclusive with respect to the fact of the principal’s guilt, is allowed exceptional weight as matter of evidence in that standing alone and unexplained it is sufficient to warrant the conclusion in support of which it was introduced.</p> <p>4. Technical legal terms are to be taken in the absence of countervailing intent in their established common law significance, and this rule applies with especial force where an ancient and established rule of law is under consideration.</p> <p>5. The word “conviction” has a popular as well as technical meaning. As popularly used it implies nothing more than a finding of guilty by a jury, but as technically understood it means the ascertainment of the guilt of the accused and judgment thereon by the court, implying not only a verdict but judgment or sentence thereon.</p> <p>6. “Record of Conviction” is a common law term and as employed in the rule of law relating to proof of the guilt of a principal, upon the trial of an accessory it must be given its legal and technical meaning, and in order to be admissible the record must show not only the verdict of the jury hut the judgment or sentence of the court.</p> <p>7. On the trial of an indictment charging defendant as an accessory to a murder, the record of the conviction of the principal showing simply that a verdict of guilty was rendered but that no j
Judges: Brown, Elkin, Frazer, Mestrezat, Stewart
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
40 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Lewis v. StateCourt of Appeals of Maryland· 1979-08-27· cited 116×
- Commonwealth v. MooreSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1959-12-31· cited 112×
- Commonwealth v. NelsonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1959-07-02· cited 71×
- Commonwealth v. PatskinSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1953-01-05· cited 70×
- Commonwealth v. GonzalesSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1992-05-28· cited 58×
- Commonwealth v. BeckerSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1987-08-10· cited 45×
- Commonwealth v. PalarinoSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1951-01-12· cited 36×
- Commonwealth v. BeattySuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1992-01-21· cited 27×
- Commonwealth v. HolgateSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1916-05-09· cited 25×
- Commonwealth v. FeagleySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1988-02-29· cited 21×
- Commonwealth v. JonesSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1921-03-07· cited 20×
- Martin v. StateSuperior Court of Delaware· 1955-09-01· cited 18×
- Rogele, Inc. v. Workers' Compensation Appeal BoardCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania· 2009-04-02· cited 17×
- Slawik v. FolsomSupreme Court of Delaware· 1979-12-27· cited 16×
- Bubar v. DizdarSupreme Court of Minnesota· 1953-07-17· cited 16×
- Commonwealth v. KaneSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1993-11-23· cited 15×
- State v. BuffaloHawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals· 1983-12-14· cited 14×
- Commonwealth v. RuckerSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1961-03-23· cited 11×
- Shields v. Westmoreland CountySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1916-04-17· cited 11×
- E. Smalis Painting Co. v. CommonwealthCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania· 1982-11-18· cited 11×
Cites
5 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Buck v. CommonwealthSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1884-10-31· cited 49×
- Commonwealth v. McDermottSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1908-04-12· cited 24×
- Philadelphia & Erie Railroad v. Catawissa RailroadSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1866-02-26· cited 16×
- York County v. DalhousenSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1863-05-21· cited 13×
- County of Cumberland v. HolcombSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1860-07-01· cited 9×
Other cases named Commonwealth v. Minnich
6 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- Commonwealth v. MinnichSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1975-09-22· cited 35×
- Commonwealth v. MinnichSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2005-05-09· cited 14×
- Commonwealth v. MinnichSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1995-06-13· cited 10×
- Commonwealth v. MinnichSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1984-02-10· cited 4×
- Commonwealth v. MinnichSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1978-03-03
- Commonwealth v. MinnichLebanon County Court of Common Pleas· 1977-01-05
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.