Commissioner v. Duberstein
Citations
- 363 U.S. 278
- 80 S. Ct. 1190
- 4 L. Ed. 2d 1218
- 1960 U.S. LEXIS 2030
- 5 A.F.T.R.2d (RIA) 1626
About this case
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
1960 United States Supreme Court case
English Wikisource has original text related to this article:
**Commissioner Of Internal Revenue v. Duberstein **
Commissioner v. Duberstein, 363 U.S. 278 (1960), was a United States Supreme Court case from 1960 dealing with the exclusion of "the value of property acquired by gift " from the gross income of an income taxpayer.[1]
It is notable (and thus appears frequently in law school casebooks) for the following holdings:
- When determining whether something is a gift for U.S. federal income tax purposes, the critical consideration is the transferor's intention. This is a question of fact that must be determined on a "case-by-case basis". The body that levies the tax must conduct an objective inquiry that looks to "the mainsprings of human conduct to the totality of the fact of each case." On review, the trier of fact must consider all of the evidence in front of it and determine whether the transferor's intention was either disinterested or involved:
- Gifts result from "detached and disinterested generosity" and are often given out of "affection, respect, admiration, charity or like impulses".
- Contrast payments given as an "involved and intensely interested" act.
Facts
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commissioner_v._Duberstein&action=edit§ion=1 "Edit section: Facts")
]
The Court was presented with two sets of facts.
No. 376, Commissioner v. Duberstein
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commissioner_v._Duberstein&action=edit§ion=2 "Edit section: No. 376, Commissioner v. Duberstein")
]
Berman was president of Mohawk Metal Corporation. Duberstein was president of the Duberstein Iron & Metal Company. They would often talk on the phone and give each other names of potential customers. After receiving some particularly helpful information, Berman decided to give Duberstein a gift of a Cadillac . Although Duberstein said he did not need the car as he already had a Cadillac and an Oldsmobile , he eventually accepted it. Mohawk Metal Corporation later deducted the value of the car as a business expense, but Duberstein did not include the value of the Cadillac in his gross income when he filed his tax return, deeming it a gift. The Commissioner asserted a deficiency for the car's value against Duberstein. The Tax court affirmed.
No. 546, Stanton v. United States
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commissioner_v._Duberstein&action=edit§ion=3 "Edit section: No. 546, Stanton v. United States")
]
Stanton worked for the Trinity Church in New York City as the comptroller of the Church corporation and president of the corporation. He resigned from both positions to go into business for himself. As a "gratuity" the corporation's directors awarded Stanton $20,000 in appreciation of the services rendered. While some directors testified that Stanton had been well liked by all in the Vestry and the $20,000 was a gift to show that good will, there was also some evidence given that Stanton was being forced to resign. The trial judge made a simple finding that the payments were a "gift".
The Issues
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commissioner_v._Duberstein&action=edit§ion=4 "Edit section: The Issues")
]
Was the car that Duberstein received a gift for taxation purposes?
Was the money that Stanton received a gift for taxation purposes?
Holdings
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commissioner_v._Duberstein&action=edit§ion=5 "Edit section: Holdings")
]
Justice William J. Brennan, Jr. , for the majority, upheld the Tax court's ruling with regard to Duberstein: Duberstein's car was not a gift, because the motives were certainly not "disinterested"—it was given to compensate for past customer references or to encourage future references. Duberstein at 291–92.
The court split as to Stanton. A plurality remanded Stanton's situation back to the trial court, to determine whether the Vestry intended to give the money as a gift or as compensation. Id. at 292.
Reasoning
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commissioner_v._Duberstein&action=edit§ion=6 "Edit section: Reasoning")
]
The Court first rejected the premise that a "gift" for taxation purposes was the same as "gift" in common law terms. Duberstein at 285. The Court also rejected the premise that there is a bright line as to what constitutes a gift for taxation purposes. Id at 287.
Instead, when determining whether something is a gift for taxation purposes, the critical consideration is the transferor's intention. Duberstein at 285-286 (citing _Bogardus v. Commissioner _, 302 U.S. 34 (1937)). This is a question of fact that must be determined on a "case-by-case basis". Duberstein at 290. The body that levies the tax must conduct an objective inquiry that looks to "the mainsprings of human conduct to the totality of the fact of each case." Duberstein at 289. The trier of fact must consider all of the evidence in front of it and determine whether the transferor's intention was either disinterested or involved:
- Gifts result from "detached and disinterested generosity." Duberstein at 285 (quoting Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. LoBue, 351 U.S. 243 (1956)). Gifts are often given out of "affection, respect, admiration, charity or like impulses." Duberstein at 285 (quoting _Robertson v. United States _, 343 U.S. 711, 714 (1952).
- Contrast payments given as an "involved and intensely interested" act. See _Olk v. United States _, 536 F.2d 876 (9th Cir. 1976).
Justice Whittaker's concurrence
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commissioner_v._Duberstein&action=edit§ion=7 "Edit section: Justice Whittaker's concurrence")
]
Justice Whittaker wrote separately to opine that sometimes, whether something is a gift is a mixed question of fact and law, not strictly a fact question as the majority wrote. Id. at 293.
Justice Douglas's dissent
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commissioner_v._Duberstein&action=edit§ion=8 "Edit section: Justice Douglas's dissent")
]
Justice Douglas dissented. He believed that both were gifts. Id.
Justice Black's concurrence and dissent
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commissioner_v._Duberstein&action=edit§ion=9 "Edit section: Justice Black's concurrence and dissent")
]
While siding with the majority on Duberstein, Justice Black believed that Stanton's money was a gift. Id. at 294.
Justice Frankfurter's concurrence and dissent
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commissioner_v._Duberstein&action=edit§ion=10 "Edit section: Justice Frankfurter's concurrence and dissent")
]
While siding with the majority on Duberstein, Justice Frankfurter believed that Stanton's money was definitely not a gift because it was given to him as a result of his hard work. Id. at 297–98. He explained that when "[T]hings of value [are] given to employees by their employers upon the termination of employment" or when an employer gives "payments entangled in a business relation and occasioned by the performance of some service," a " strong implication is that the payment is of a business nature" and, therefore, not a gift. Id. at 295–296.
See also
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commissioner_v._Duberstein&action=edit§ion=11 "Edit section: See also")
]
_Bogardus v. Commissioner _, 302 U.S. 34 (1937)
References
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commissioner_v._Duberstein&action=edit§ion=12 "Edit section: References")
]
- ↑ Commissioner v. Duberstein, 363 U.S. 278 (1960).
External links
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commissioner_v._Duberstein&action=edit§ion=13 "Edit section: External links")
]
- Text of Commissioner v. Duberstein, 363 U.S. 278 (1960) is available from: Cornell CourtListener Findlaw Google Scholar Internet Archive (docket files) Justia Library of Congress Oyez (oral argument audio)
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commissioner_v._Duberstein&oldid=1351964397 "
[United States Supreme Court cases of the Warren Court](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:United_States_Supreme_Court_cases_of_the_Warre
…
Editorial context from Wikipedia (CC-BY-SA 4.0).
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that clear-error review applied to a decision that a particular transfer was a statutory “gift”
- holding that the transferor’s or donor’s intent is the sole determinant of whether a transaction is a gift
- holding that the transferor's or donor's intent is the sole determinant of whether a transaction is a gift
- holding that fact-finding tribunal must determine existence of a “gift” for tax purposes based on its “experience with the mainsprings of human conduct”
- noting that “unelaborated finding of ultimate fact here cannot stand as a fulfillment of [Rule 52(a) ]”
- stating that transferor's intention is most crucial consideration in determining whether payment is gift
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Brennan, Black, Harlan, Frankfurter, Whittaker, Bogardus, Douglas
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
977 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Ornelas v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1996-06-10· cited 7,197×
- MARKMAN Et Al. v. WESTVIEW INSTRUMENTS, INC., Et Al.Supreme Court· 1996-04-29· cited 3,226×
- Pullman-Standard v. SwintSupreme Court· 1982-04-27· cited 2,420×
- United States v. HinksonNinth Circuit· 2009-11-05· cited 2,227×
- Zenith Radio Corp. v. Hazeltine Research, Inc.Supreme Court· 1969-05-19· cited 2,097×
- United States v. Winston Bryant McConneyNinth Circuit· 1984-02-10· cited 1,819×
- Neely v. CommissionerU.S. Tax Court· 1985-12-17· cited 1,531×
- Frank Lyon Co. v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1978-04-18· cited 810×
- Bolen Webb and Cornelia Webb v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueFifth Circuit· 1968-04-23· cited 635×
- Johnny Weimerskirch v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueNinth Circuit· 1979-05-02· cited 493×
- Whipple v. CommissionerSupreme Court· 1963-06-17· cited 469×
- Bankr. L. Rep. P 71,787 in Re John E. Tully, Debtor. Henry J. Boroff, Trustee in Bankruptcy of John E. Tully v. John E. TullyFirst Circuit· 1987-05-04· cited 449×
- Margit Sigray Bessenyey v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueSecond Circuit· 1967-06-01· cited 365×
- Michael L. Rockwell, and Regina Rockwell v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueNinth Circuit· 1975-06-13· cited 365×
- United States v. GeneresSupreme Court· 1972-03-27· cited 341×
- United States v. Mississippi Valley Generating Co.Supreme Court· 1961-03-20· cited 339×
- U. S. Bank N. A. v. Village at Lakeridge, LLCSupreme Court· 2018-03-05· cited 327×
- Grodt & McKay Realty, Inc. v. CommissionerU.S. Tax Court· 1981-12-07· cited 298×
- Commissioner v. DanielsonThird Circuit· 1967-05-02· cited 296×
- Seymour Silverman v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueSecond Circuit· 1976-06-21· cited 290×
Cites
20 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Welch v. HelveringSupreme Court· 1933-11-06· cited 9,823×
- United States v. United States Gypsum Co.Supreme Court· 1948-03-08· cited 9,383×
- Graver Tank & Mfg. Co. v. Linde Air Products Co.Supreme Court· 1950-10-09· cited 1,620×
- Commissioner v. HeiningerSupreme Court· 1943-12-20· cited 1,117×
- Old Colony Trust Co. v. CommissionerSupreme Court· 1929-06-03· cited 885×
- Dobson v. CommissionerSupreme Court· 1944-01-03· cited 676×
- United States v. Yellow Cab Co.Supreme Court· 1949-12-05· cited 524×
- Commissioner v. LoBueSupreme Court· 1956-05-28· cited 445×
- Bogardus v. CommissionerSupreme Court· 1937-11-08· cited 423×
- Robertson v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1952-06-02· cited 168×
- Baker v. Texas & Pacific Railway Co.Supreme Court· 1959-04-06· cited 149×
- Grace Bros. v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueNinth Circuit· 1949-02-18· cited 119×
- Roberts v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueNinth Circuit· 1949-06-27· cited 86×
- Matton Oil Transfer Corporation v. DynamicSecond Circuit· 1941-12-01· cited 36×
- Lockard v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueFirst Circuit· 1948-02-05· cited 29×
- Washburn v. CommissionerU.S. Tax Court· 1945-12-28· cited 26×
- McDermott v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueD.C. Circuit· 1945-06-18· cited 21×
- Mose Duberstein and Sylvia Duberstein, Husband and Wife v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueSixth Circuit· 1959-04-08· cited 14×
- Nelson v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueSixth Circuit· 1953-04-11· cited 13×
- Alden D. Stanton and Louise M. Stanton v. United StatesSecond Circuit· 1959-07-06· cited 10×
Other cases named Commissioner v. Duberstein
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.