Clarke v. Rogers
Citations
- 228 U.S. 534
- 33 S. Ct. 587
- 57 L. Ed. 953
- 1913 U.S. LEXIS 2395
Syllabus
<p>The same person, considered in different capacities, may act as the giver and receiver of a fraudulent preference; and so held in a case where a trustee of several trusts, with knowledge of his insolvency, transferred property to one of the trusts to which he was indebted. See Bush v. Moore, 133 Massachusetts, 192.</p> <p>The obligation resting on a defaulting testamentary trustee to restore the value of the assets embezzled is of a contractual character and the debt is provable although it is fraudulent and excepted from the discharge.</p> <p>Under the laws of Massachusetts there may be a contractual obligation of one trust to another for payments improperly made from assets of the latter for the benefit of the former. Bremer v.. Williams, 210 Massachusetts, 256.</p> <p>Section 17 of the Bankruptcy Act enumerates debts provable under § 63a which are not discharged, and among them are included those that arise by the conversion of trust' funds.</p> <p>Equality between creditors is necessarily the ultimate aim of the Bankruptcy act; and even if the dividend be very small, the court will not construe the act so as to allow one creditor to be preferred above the others.</p> <p>There may be unity of the person and difference in capacities, but such unity imputes knowledge of the purpose for which the different capacities were exercised.</p>
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- stating that “the fundamental purpose of the Bankruptcy Law ... is, equality between creditors”
- stating that “the fundamental purpose of the Bankruptcy Law ... is, equality between creditors”
- stating “[elquality between creditors is necessarily the ultimate aim of the bankrupt law”
- ''Equality between creditors is necessarily the ultimate aim of the bankrupt[cy] law, and to obtain it we must regard the essential nature of transactions [.]”
- “Equality between creditors is necessarily the ultimate aim of the bankruptcy] law, and to obtain it we must regard the essential nature of transactions[.]”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Holmes, McKenna
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
47 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Cunningham v. BrownSupreme Court· 1924-04-28· cited 383×
- In Re: Combustion Engineering, Inc. First State Insurance Company Hartford Accident and Indemnity CompanyFirst Circuit· 2004-12-02· cited 357×
- American United Mutual Life Insurance v. City of Avon ParkSupreme Court· 1940-12-23· cited 143×
- Baron & Budd, P.C. v. Unsecured Asbestos CommitteeD. New Jersey· 2005-02-25· cited 61×
- Morris Plan Industrial Bank of New York v. SchornSecond Circuit· 1943-04-23· cited 34×
- Zack Stamp, Director of Insurance for the State of Illinois, as Liquidator of Reserve Insurance Company v. Insurance Company of North AmericaSeventh Circuit· 1990-07-23· cited 29×
- Hartford Accident & Indemnity Co. v. FlanaganS.D. Ohio· 1939-06-27· cited 26×
- Robertson v. MillerSecond Circuit· 1922-12-28· cited 20×
- Matteawan Manufacturing Co. v. Chemical Bank & Trust Co.Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1935-05-03· cited 17×
- Quirk v. SmithMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1929-10-02· cited 16×
- Eby v. AshleyFourth Circuit· 1924-09-29· cited 13×
- Walter E. Heller & Company v. BarnesCourt of Appeals of Texas· 1967-02-22· cited 13×
- Kamberg v. Springfield National BankMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1935-12-30· cited 13×
- Watchmaker v. BarnesFirst Circuit· 1919-06-18· cited 13×
- Mason v. Paradise Irrigation DistrictSupreme Court· 1946-02-11· cited 12×
- Rubenstein v. LottowMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1916-03-03· cited 12×
- Lowell v. BrownD. Massachusetts· 1922-03-17· cited 12×
- United States v. SullivanW.D. New York· 1937-05-28· cited 11×
- In Re Paramount Publix CorporationS.D. New York· 1934-08-02· cited 10×
- Specker Motor Sales Co. v. EisenW.D. Michigan· 2003-06-20· cited 10×
Cites
3 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
Other cases named Clarke v. Rogers
3 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.