Citizens' Bank v. Parker
Citations
- 192 U.S. 73
- 24 S. Ct. 181
- 48 L. Ed. 346
- 1904 U.S. LEXIS 1034
Syllabus
<p>When a contract is asserted and tbe Constitution of the United States invoked to protect it, all of the elements which are claimed to constitute it are open to examination and review by this court; and also all that which is claimed to have taken it away, and the writ of error will not be dismissed.</p> <p>The rule requiring a strict construction of statutes exempting property from taxation should not be infringed but where ambiguity exists it is the duty of the court to determine whether doubt exists and to solve it and not to immediately surrender to it.</p> <p>Where it is res judicata that the original charter of a bank by which its capital is exempt from any tax constituted a contract within the impairment clause of the Constitution, and that such exemption is not affected by subsequent charters and constitutions, and there is no doubt that the State intended to offer inducements to enlist capital in the early development of the State, and no license- tax was demanded for fifty-eight years although that method of taxation was in force during the whole period, the exemption from any tax may be construecLas including a license tax on occupation as well as taxes on property.</p>
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- noting that the use of “any” signals that the word it modifies should receive broad definition
- noting that the use of “any” signals that the word it modifies should receive broad definition
- noting that the “proper office” of the rule of strict construction “is to help solve ambiguities”
- “The word any excludes selection or distinction.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: McKenna, Brewer, Harlan
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
30 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- United States v. Ryan KibbleFourth Circuit· 2021-04-01· cited 575×
- City of Edmonds v. Oxford House, Inc.Supreme Court· 1995-05-15· cited 227×
- Bowie v. GonzalezFirst Circuit· 1941-01-10· cited 112×
- Susquehanna Coal Co. v. Mayor and Council of South AmboySupreme Court· 1913-05-26· cited 53×
- Jesus Zuniga Romero v. William BarrFourth Circuit· 2019-08-29· cited 46×
- Chicago Home for Girls v. CarrIllinois Supreme Court· 1921-12-22· cited 38×
- Biffer v. City of ChicagoIllinois Supreme Court· 1917-04-19· cited 34×
- Warner v. KingIllinois Supreme Court· 1915-02-17· cited 26×
- District of Columbia Office of Tax & Revenue v. Bae System Enterprise System Inc.District of Columbia Court of Appeals· 2012-11-29· cited 21×
- Motor Cargo, Inc. v. Board of Township TrusteesSummit County Court of Common Pleas· 1953-09-09· cited 21×
- People v. Illinois Central RailroadIllinois Supreme Court· 1916-04-20· cited 20×
- In Re the Tax Appeal of Central Union ChurchHawaii Supreme Court· 1981-03-04· cited 19×
- City of Ann Arbor v. University Cellar, Inc.Michigan Supreme Court· 1977-10-06· cited 18×
- Fleming v. American Stores Co.E.D. Pennsylvania· 1941-12-30· cited 17×
- Northwestern University v. HanbergIllinois Supreme Court· 1908-12-15· cited 16×
- Re Taxes, Haw'n Pineapple Co., Ltd.Hawaii Supreme Court· 1961-07-25· cited 13×
- The People v. Rosehill Cemetery Co.Illinois Supreme Court· 1939-06-15· cited 12×
- BHA Group Holding, Inc. v. PendergastMissouri Court of Appeals· 2005-10-11· cited 10×
- Javier Chavez Gonzalez v. Merrick GarlandFourth Circuit· 2021-10-20· cited 10×
- Crummies Creek Coal Corp. v. NapierCourt of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976)· 1932-12-16· cited 8×
Cites
15 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- New Orleans v. Citizens' BankSupreme Court· 1897-05-24· cited 227×
- Farrington v. TennesseeSupreme Court· 1878-01-14· cited 206×
- Bank of Commerce v. Tennessee Ex Rel. MemphisSupreme Court· 1896-03-02· cited 172×
- Illinois Central Railroad v. DecaturSupreme Court· 1893-01-09· cited 156×
- Yazoo & Mississippi Valley Railroad v. ThomasSupreme Court· 1889-11-18· cited 102×
- Gordon v. Appeal Tax CourtSupreme Court· 1845-01-22· cited 85×
- Dubuque & Pacific Railroad v. LitchfieldSupreme Court· 1860-04-18· cited 66×
- Phoenix Fire & Marine Insurance v. TennesseeSupreme Court· 1896-03-02· cited 60×
- Chicago, Burlington, & Kansas City Railroad v. GuffeySupreme Court· 1887-03-07· cited 38×
- People Ex Rel. Schurz v. CookSupreme Court· 1893-04-03· cited 36×
- City of New Orleans v. Ernst & Co.Supreme Court of Louisiana· 1883-05-15· cited 22×
- Citizens' Bank v. BounySupreme Court of Louisiana· 1880-02-15· cited 9×
- State ex rel. Ernst & Co. v. Board of StateSupreme Court of Louisiana· 1884-03-15· cited 5×
- State v. Southern BankSupreme Court of Louisiana· 1871-03-15· cited 3×
- Parish of Morehouse v. BrighamSupreme Court of Louisiana· 1889-06-15· cited 3×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.