Catholic High School Association Of The Archdiocese Of New York v. Culvert

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• “Were the Board allowed to apply an ‘in part’ test in addressing an asserted religious motive, an order based on such a finding would violate the First Amendment.”
• ”[T]he First Amendment prohibits the [New York] State [Labor Relations] Board from inquiring into an asserted religious motive {for discharging a lay employee from a Catholic parochial school] to determine whether it is pretextual.”
• Board may not inquire into whether a religiously-based reason, given for a discharge, is truly part of church dogma; Board may only determine whether the reason is part of a “dual motive” for the discharge
• Board may not inquire into whether a religiously-based reason, given for a discharge, is truly part of church dogma; Board may only determine whether the reason is part of a \dual motive\ for the discharge

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).