Carpenter v. Bailey
Citations
- 94 Cal. 406
- 29 P. 1101
- 1892 Cal. LEXIS 700
Syllabus
<p>Contest of Will —Devise to Children of Copartner—Fraud — Undue Influence —Report of Bad Treatment by Relatives of Testator. — Where a will, devising the bulk of the estate of the testator to the children of his copartner, who were upon intimate and friendly relations with the testator, who had declared his intention to make some of them the objects of his bounty, is contested by relatives living in another state, who were not provided for by the will, evidence that the father of the children stated to a witness that the testator had said he had been badly treated by his relatives, and would not give them any part of his property, without proof of the communication of the statement to the testator, does not prove that he fraudulently started or circulated the report, or suggested it to the disordered fancy of the testator, or show undue influence exercised by him over the mind of the testator, it appearing that some of the testator’s witnesses testified to similar assertions by the testator which antedated the interview with the father of the devisees.</p> <p>Id. — Support of Family by Partnership__The support of the family of the copartner by the partnership of which the testator was a member, with his presumed knowledge and consent, would not constitute fraud, and if he were actually defrauded thereby, would not tend to induce a will in favor of the children of the copartner.</p> <p>Id.—Suppression of Letters from Testator’s Relatives.—Where the suppression, by the copartner, of the letters of the testator from his relatives is not one of the charges specifically averred, and there is no proof that he received or suppressed them, beyond a suspicion that he might have done so, under the evidence of one of the testator’s brothers as to the sending of certain letters, which were not returned from the dead-letter office or found among the testator’s effects, such evidence does not prove fraud exercised by the copartner in the procuring of a will in favor of his chil
Judges: Temple
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
25 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Wilson v. McConnachieCalifornia Supreme Court· 1897-06-16· cited 67×
- In re Estate of RedfieldCalifornia Supreme Court· 1897-05-04· cited 51×
- People v. LaneCalifornia Supreme Court· 1894-03-03· cited 45×
- People v. HillCalifornia Supreme Court· 1897-04-23· cited 41×
- People v. McCarthyCalifornia Supreme Court· 1896-12-09· cited 40×
- People v. ArrighiniCalifornia Supreme Court· 1898-09-15· cited 36×
- Robinson v. Exempt Fire Co.California Supreme Court· 1894-06-09· cited 33×
- The Atkins Corporation v. TournyCalifornia Supreme Court· 1936-04-30· cited 27×
- Holland v. ZollneCalifornia Supreme Court· 1894-06-07· cited 27×
- Marceau v. Travelers' Ins. Co.California Supreme Court· 1894-02-15· cited 24×
- Estate of SelbCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1948-02-28· cited 23×
- Estate of GreeneArizona Supreme Court· 1932-05-31· cited 23×
- Liverpool, London & Globe Insurance Co. v. Southern Pacific Co.California Supreme Court· 1899-07-22· cited 20×
- Alegria v. AlegriaCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1948-09-20· cited 17×
- In re Estate of WaxCalifornia Supreme Court· 1895-03-11· cited 16×
- In Re Estate of StuhlfauthAppellate Court of Illinois· 1980-09-17· cited 13×
- Painter v. PainterCalifornia Supreme Court· 1894-05-25· cited 9×
- Svendsen v. Herget National BankAppellate Court of Illinois· 1980-11-26· cited 8×
- Mounsey v. BowerIndiana Court of Appeals· 1922-06-30· cited 8×
- Gecht v. AndersonCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1958-11-21· cited 3×
Cites
3 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
Other cases named Carpenter v. Bailey
3 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.