D.C. Circuit· 7/5/1991
Carl Willner v. Richard L. Thornburgh
Citations
- 928 F.2d 1185
- 289 U.S. App. D.C. 93
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- finding distinction because applicants can preclude imposition of drug test by not applying for particular position and because denial of future employment not as intrusive as loss of existing job
- distinguishing between drug testing as prerequisite for job applicant and \[t]he choice presented to current employees-undergo random drug testing or lose your job\
- distinguishing between drug testing as prerequisite for job applicant and “[t]he choice presented to current employees — undergo random drug testing or lose your job”
- discussing as mitigating factors whether the person had “notice of an impending intrusion” and had a “large, measure of control over whether he or she will be subject to” the search
- \The protections of the Fourth Amendment are graduated in proportation to the privacy interests affected. Decreasing levels of intrusiveness require decreasing levels of justification\
- “In our ... decisions concerning random drug testing of incumbents, the balance we struck turned to a large extent on the nature of the employee’s position.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Henderson, Randolph, Silberman
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
30 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Loder v. City of GlendaleCalifornia Supreme Court· 1997-01-06· cited 87×
- O'Keefe v. Passaic Valley Water CommissionSupreme Court of New Jersey· 1993-05-27· cited 64×
- Maria Piroglu v. T.R. Coleman, Individually and as Fire Chief, District of ColumbiaD.C. Circuit· 1994-06-17· cited 58×
- Robinson v. City of SeattleCourt of Appeals of Washington· 2000-10-02· cited 53×
- Dimeo v. GriffinSeventh Circuit· 1991-08-12· cited 48×
- Guiney v. Police Commissioner of BostonMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1991-12-09· cited 36×
- Arthur W. Stigile and Ellen Balis v. William J. Clinton, PresidentD.C. Circuit· 1997-08-21· cited 31×
- University of Colorado Ex Rel. University of Colorado v. DerdeynSupreme Court of Colorado· 1993-11-01· cited 21×
- Aeronautical Repair Station Ass'n v. Federal Aviation AdministrationD.C. Circuit· 2007-07-17· cited 18×
- National Federation of Federal Employees-IAM v. VilsackD.C. Circuit· 2012-06-08· cited 18×
- Doe v. U.S. Department of JusticeDistrict of Columbia· 1992-04-13· cited 15×
- Carter v. RubinDistrict of Columbia· 1998-01-28· cited 15×
- Cary v. CarmichaelE.D. Virginia· 1995-11-20· cited 12×
- Lewis v. Gov't of the D.C.D.C. Circuit· 2017-10-18· cited 9×
- National Treasury Employees Union v. U.S. Department of TreasuryDistrict of Columbia· 1993-12-01· cited 8×
- Chandler v. MillerEleventh Circuit· 1996-01-22· cited 6×
- Rutherford v. Albuquerque, City OfTenth Circuit· 1996-02-23· cited 6×
- National Treasury Employees Union v. HallettE.D. New York· 1991-10-28· cited 6×
- O'KEEFE v. Passaic Valley WaterNew Jersey Superior Court App Division· 1992-02-07· cited 5×
- National Treasury Employees Union v. United States Customs ServiceDistrict of Columbia· 1993-07-01· cited 3×
Cites
32 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Katz v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1967-12-18· cited 13,304×
- Delaware v. ProuseSupreme Court· 1979-03-27· cited 5,549×
- Camara v. Municipal Court of City and County of San FranciscoSupreme Court· 1967-06-05· cited 3,591×
- United States v. JacobsenSupreme Court· 1984-04-02· cited 3,218×
- Skinner v. Railway Labor Executives' Assn.Supreme Court· 1989-03-21· cited 2,560×
- New Jersey v. T. L. O.Supreme Court· 1985-01-15· cited 2,391×
- Griffin v. WisconsinSupreme Court· 1987-06-26· cited 2,149×
- Davis v. MississippiSupreme Court· 1969-04-23· cited 1,385×
- Burdeau v. McDowellSupreme Court· 1921-06-01· cited 1,253×
- National Treasury Employees Union v. Von RaabSupreme Court· 1989-03-21· cited 1,188×
- O'CONNOR v. OrtegaSupreme Court· 1987-03-31· cited 1,069×
- California v. GreenwoodSupreme Court· 1988-05-16· cited 1,059×
- Wygant v. Jackson Board of EducationSupreme Court· 1986-06-30· cited 802×
- Walter v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1980-06-20· cited 793×
- Hayes v. FloridaSupreme Court· 1985-03-20· cited 603×
- Wyman v. JamesSupreme Court· 1971-01-12· cited 427×
- Mark B. Harmon v. Richard L. Thornburgh, Attorney General of the United StatesD.C. Circuit· 1989-09-01· cited 215×
- National Treasury Employees Union v. RaabFifth Circuit· 1987-04-22· cited 143×
- National Treasury Employees Union v. Clayton Yeutter, Secretary, United States Department of AgricultureD.C. Circuit· 1990-11-16· cited 130×
- United States v. Miguel Angel TabordaSecond Circuit· 1980-11-24· cited 117×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.