Caraccilo v. Village of Seneca Falls, NY

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• stating that the issue is ultimately a matter of law but that underlying factual issues preclude summary judgment
• stating that the issue is ultimately a matter of law but that underlying factual issues preclude summary judgment
• finding the failure to retain the plaintiff after her term \simply expired\ could be an adverse employment action to support the plaintiff's First Amendment claim
• “[T]he fact that plaintiffs speech to these officials may have related in some way to her job is not dispositive of whether it was made pursuant to her job duties or that it was unprotected[.]”
• “[T]he fact that plaintiffs speech to these officials may have related in some way to her job is not dispositive of whether it was made pursuant to her job duties or that it was unprotected[.]” (emphasis in original)
• “[T]he fact that plaintiffs speech to these officials may have related in some way to her job is not dispositive of whether it was made pursu ant to her job duties or that it was unprotected!.]”

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).