Campbell v. Kelly

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• “declin[ing] to pass upon ... question as it [wa]s not necessary to the resolution of the other issues of th[e] case”
• pension plan for legislators does not violate constitutional provision setting salary but prohibiting other \emoluments\
• pension plan for legislators does not violate constitutional provision setting salary but prohibiting other “emoluments”
• “For the average working person, the most valuable property rights ... consist of social security benefits, insurance contracts, union welfare fund benefits and private and governmental pensions.” (Emphasis added).
• pension benefits are not emoluments

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).

Cited by

15 cases in this archive cite this case.

• Wickland v. American Travellers Life Insurance
  West Virginia Supreme Court· 1998-11-04· cited 183×
• Dadisman v. Moore
  West Virginia Supreme Court· 1989-03-17· cited 85×
• Roberts v. Consolidation Coal Co.
  West Virginia Supreme Court· 2000-07-19· cited 44×
• Brown v. Meyer
  Texas Supreme Court· 1990-02-07· cited 41×
• Wagoner v. Gainer
  West Virginia Supreme Court· 1981-06-15· cited 39×
• In Re Dostert
  West Virginia Supreme Court· 1984-11-15· cited 30×
• State Ex Rel. Spire v. Public Employees Retirement Board
  Nebraska Supreme Court· 1987-08-07· cited 30×
• State Ex Rel. Udall v. Public Employees Retirement Board
  New Mexico Supreme Court· 1995-11-22· cited 24×
• DePond v. Gainer
  West Virginia Supreme Court· 1986-07-24· cited 13×
• State Ex Rel. Udall v. Public Employees Retirement Board
  New Mexico Court of Appeals· 1994-09-28· cited 13×
• Chamber of Commerce E. Union Cty. v. Leone
  New Jersey Superior Court App Division· 1976-04-12· cited 10×
• Higginbotham v. Clark
  West Virginia Supreme Court· 1993-07-20· cited 7×
• Meyer v. Brown
  Court of Appeals of Texas· 1989-12-21· cited 4×
• Opinion No.
  Arkansas Attorney General Reports· 1991-02-04
• President Reagan's Ability to Receive Retirement Benefits From the State of California
  Office of Legal Counsel· 1981-06-23

Cites

15 cases in this archive are cited by this case.

• Barrows v. Jackson
  Supreme Court· 1953-06-15· cited 940×
• State Ex Rel. Graney v. Sims
  West Virginia Supreme Court· 1958-12-02· cited 90×
• State Ex Rel. State Building Commission v. Bailey
  West Virginia Supreme Court· 1966-10-11· cited 59×
• State Ex Rel. Fox v. Board of Trustees of the Policemen's Pension or Relief Fund
  West Virginia Supreme Court· 1964-03-17· cited 57×
• Cawley v. Board of Trustees of Firemen's Pension
  West Virginia Supreme Court· 1953-07-07· cited 40×
• State Ex Rel. Lyons v. Guy
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 1961-01-18· cited 32×
• Spencer v. Yerace
  West Virginia Supreme Court· 1971-05-11· cited 30×
• Delardas v. County Court of Monongalia County
  West Virginia Supreme Court· 1972-02-22· cited 30×
• Shearer v. Burnet
  Supreme Court· 1932-03-14· cited 16×
• People Ex Rel. Judges Retirement System v. Wright
  Illinois Supreme Court· 1942-03-19· cited 16×
• Bulgo v. Enomoto
  Hawaii Supreme Court· 1967-07-19· cited 13×
• Nelson v. City of Los Angeles
  California Court of Appeal· 1971-12-08· cited 9×
• State Ex Rel. Patteson v. Sims
  West Virginia Supreme Court· 1951-06-19· cited 4×
• Taylor v. Board of Education
  West Virginia Supreme Court· 1969-03-11· cited 4×
• Taylor v. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF COUNTY OF CABELL
  West Virginia Supreme Court· 1969-03-11· cited 3×

Other cases named Campbell v. Kelly

4 other CourtListener records share this case name.

• Campbell v. Kelly
  Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1973-06-25· cited 4×
• Campbell v. Kelly
  Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 2011-06-07
• Campbell v. Kelly
  New York Supreme Court· 1884-10-15
• Campbell v. Kelly
  Third Circuit· 2004-01-06