Butler v. Goreley
Citations
- 146 U.S. 303
- 13 S. Ct. 84
- 36 L. Ed. 981
- 1892 U.S. LEXIS 2198
Syllabus
<p>One T., of Boston, went into insolvency in Massachusetts, in June, 1883, and a deed of assignment was made to his assignee in July, 1883. In June, 1863, T. was on board an American vessel, which was captured and burned by the Georgia, a tender of the Confederate cruiser Alabama, and .thereby lost his personal effects and sustained other losses. Under the act of Congress of June 5, 1882, c..195'(22 Stat. 98), T:,-in January, 1883, filed a claim, in the Court of Commissioners of Alabama Claims, claiming compensation for his losses, and the court gave a judgment in his favor. ■ In Eebruary, 1885, a draft for the amount was issued by the Treasury, payable to the order of T. and was sent to, and received at Boston. T. died at Boston four days later, intestate. In March, 188.5,. T.’s widow was appointed his administratrix by the Probate Court of the District of Columbia. In April, 1885, she gave a power of attorney to one B. to endorse the draft. He did so and collected the amount-, Which he retained. The assignee in insolvency sued B. in a state conrtof Massachusetts, to recover the amount and had judgment. On a writ of error from.this Court, held,</p> <p>(1.) The decision and award of the Court of Commissioners of Alabama Claims was conclusive as to the amount to. be paid on the . claim, but not as to the party entitled to receive it; and the claim was property which passed to the assignee in insolvency, under the assignment to him, although it was made prior to the decís-. ion of the Court of Commissioners;</p> <p>(2.) The claim and its proceeds were assets within the jurisdiction of Massachusetts;</p> <p>(3.) B. was liable to the assignee in insolvency;</p> <p>(4.) § 3177 of the Revised Statutes did not apply to the assignment in insolvency;</p> <p>(5.) The insolvency law of Massachusetts was not unconstitutional;</p> <p>• (6.) It was not necessary, after the repeal of the bankruptcy act of 1867, that the insolvency, statute of Massachusetts should have been reenac
Judges: Blatchford
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
40 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- United States v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.Supreme Court· 1950-01-16· cited 571×
- Seaboard Air Line Railway v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1920-03-16· cited 73×
- National Bank of Commerce v. DownieSupreme Court· 1910-11-28· cited 67×
- Derby v. Worcester CountyFirst Circuit· 1900-04-20· cited 49×
- Missouri Pacific Railroad v. BooneSupreme Court· 1926-04-12· cited 47×
- Carling v. Seymour Lumber Co.Fifth Circuit· 1902-02-11· cited 44×
- Ball v. HalsellSupreme Court· 1896-03-02· cited 43×
- Oswego Falls Corp. v. CommissionerBoard of Tax Appeals· 1932-05-12· cited 39×
- City of New Orleans v. HarrellFifth Circuit· 1943-03-12· cited 31×
- General Electric Co. v. Packard Bamberger & Co.Supreme Court of New Jersey· 1953-12-21· cited 25×
- Hager v. SwayneSupreme Court· 1893-05-01· cited 24×
- LeCrone v. McAdooSupreme Court· 1920-06-01· cited 24×
- West Virginia v. Adams Express Co.Fourth Circuit· 1915-01-13· cited 23×
- Kingan & Co. v. United StatesCourt of Claims· 1930-10-20· cited 19×
- Potts v. Smith Manufacturing Co.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1904-05-11· cited 18×
- Buder v. First Nat. Bank in St. LouisEighth Circuit· 1927-01-04· cited 13×
- Roomberg v. United StatesE.D. Pennsylvania· 1941-09-03· cited 13×
- Bailey v. United StatesFederal Claims· 2007-08-10· cited 13×
- In re Yoke Vitrified Brick Co.D. Kansas· 1910-06-18· cited 13×
- O'Haire v. BurnsSupreme Court of Colorado· 1909-04-15· cited 12×
Cites
13 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Bank of Columbia v. OkelySupreme Court· 1819-02-22· cited 668×
- Cole v. CunninghamSupreme Court· 1890-01-20· cited 339×
- In Re RahrerSupreme Court· 1891-05-25· cited 334×
- Baldwin v. HaleSupreme Court· 1864-01-11· cited 283×
- Goodman v. NiblackSupreme Court· 1881-01-10· cited 153×
- Erwin v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1878-12-18· cited 136×
- Wyman v. HalsteadSupreme Court· 1884-01-07· cited 99×
- Taylor v. BemissSupreme Court· 1884-01-07· cited 80×
- Williams v. HeardSupreme Court· 1891-05-25· cited 71×
- Baldwin v. Bank of NewburySupreme Court· 1864-01-11· cited 49×
- Boyle v. ZacharieSupreme Court· 1832-01-01· cited 40×
- St. Paul & Duluth Railroad v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1885-01-05· cited 34×
- Goreley v. ButlerMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1888-05-04· cited 5×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.