Butler v. Ashworth
Citations
- 110 Cal. 614
- 43 P. 4
- 1895 Cal. LEXIS 1107
Syllabus
<p>Torts—Damage by Broken Sewer—Satisfaction of Judgment against City — Extinguishment of Judgment against Superintendent op Streets.—Where judgment was obtained against the city and county ol San Francisco, in an action to recover for damages caused by a broken sewer, owing to the negligence of the city properly to repair the same, and subsequent to the recovery of such judgment, and before satisfaction thereof, another judgment was obtained against the superintendent of streets and his deputies, for the same injury, upon a complaint charging them with the making of repairs in such a negligent manner as directly to conduce to the injury complained of, after which there was a satisfaction of the judgment against the city, the judgment against the superintendent of streets and his deputies is thereby extinguished, excepting as to the costs of action, and the defendants in that action are entitled to an order restraining and enjoining the plaintiff from issuing or enforcing execution thereunder, and that the judgment against them be ordered satisfied of record.</p> <p>Id.—Joint Tort-feasors—Only One Satisfaction Allowable.—There can be but one satisfaction accorded for the same wrong; and if several persons are guilty in common of a tort, though the injured one may at his election sue them individually or together, he cannot, by suing each wrongdoer alone, secure more than one compensation for the same injury; and if he sue one alone, and is paid damages for the wrong, his remedy is at an end, and he is barred from further recovery against the others.</p> <p>Id .—Nature of Acts Causing Single Injury.—Where the injury caused is single, it is immaterial whether it was caused by the joint or several acts of the tort-feasor, and the plaintiff can be but once compensated for the injury suffered.</p> <p>Id.—Contribution to Injury—Several Acts of Tort-feasors—Costs of Separate Suit.—Where several acts of tort-feasors contribute to the same injury, there can be but one satisf
Judges: Fleet
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
17 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Ash v. MortensenCalifornia Supreme Court· 1944-08-11· cited 100×
- Anheuser-Busch, Inc. v. StarleyCalifornia Supreme Court· 1946-06-18· cited 75×
- Hoch v. Allied-Signal, Inc.California Court of Appeal· 1994-04-12· cited 69×
- York v. InTrust Bank, N.A.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1998-06-05· cited 65×
- Laurenzi v. VranizanCalifornia Supreme Court· 1945-01-30· cited 60×
- Miller v. F. Beck & Co.Supreme Court of Iowa· 1899-05-24· cited 42×
- Royal Indemnity Co. v. OlmsteadNinth Circuit· 1951-12-17· cited 35×
- Milicevich v. Sacramento Medical CenterCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1984-05-16· cited 34×
- Martin v. CunninghamWashington Supreme Court· 1916-12-05· cited 32×
- Jackson v. YarbrayCalifornia Court of Appeal· 2009-11-10· cited 31×
- Jacobsen v. WoernerSupreme Court of Kansas· 1939-04-08· cited 26×
- Brawley v. J.C. Interiors, Inc.California Court of Appeal· 2008-04-08· cited 25×
- May v. MillerCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1991-02-25· cited 24×
- Reinach v. City & County of San FranciscoCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1958-11-05· cited 9×
- Black v. BringhurstCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1935-06-21· cited 6×
- Minehan v. SilveriaCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1936-01-17· cited 5×
- Polk v. Illinois Central RailroadCourt of Appeals of Kentucky· 1917-05-25· cited 5×
Cites
2 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
Other cases named Butler v. Ashworth
2 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.