Brown v. Sullivan
Citations
- 71 Tex. 470
- 10 S.W. 288
- 1888 Tex. LEXIS 1168
Syllabus
<p>1. Contributory Negligence.—Following the weight of authority, it is held that a defendant relying upon contributory negligence as a defense must allege and prove it.</p> <p>2. Same—Exception.—The above is modified when, by the plaintiff’s own testimony, a suspicion is raised that his own negligence may have contributed to the injury.</p> <p>3. Same—Charge.—See facts where it was not error to instruct the jury to find for the plaintiff if the defendant, by his agent, could, by ordinary care, have avoided the consequences of the negligence of the plaintiff; or by direct act of his agents, caused the act which produced the injury complained of.</p> <p>4. Mental Suffering as Element of Damages.—It is settled in this State that mental suffering is an element of actual damages where serious bodily injury is inflicted; and where such injury threatens permanent disabilitv, and continues for a long time, the jury are authorized to consider the suffering of both body and mind in assessing the damages, without direct proof of such suffering.</p> <p>5. Negligence a Fact for the Jury.—Texas & Pacific Railway Company v. Murphy, 46 Texas, 356, followed.</p> <p>6. Negligence.—Danger resulting from negligence is not one of the ordinary risks of operating dangerous machinery.</p> <p>7. Variance.—In action for personal injury the evidence showed the act to have been at a different place from where alleged. Held that</p> <p>(1) The action is transitory; the allegation was immaterial, and it was not necessary that it he proved.</p> <p>(2) The counsel of defendant, upon the testimony developing' the different locality, if he had been misled by the allegation, should have made known his surprise, and would have been entitled to withdraw his announcement and to a continuance.</p> <p>8. Fellow Servant.—A married woman cooking on a work train, occupying a car, boarding work hands in employ of a railway company, the company paying the board to the husband, and deducting same from their wa
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- ‘Where serious bodily injury is inflicted involving fractures, dislocations, etc., and results in protracted disability and confinement to bed, we know that some degree of physical and mental suffering is the necessary result.”
- “Where serious bodily injury is inflicted involving fractures, dislocations, etc., and results in protracted disability and confinement to bed, we know that some degree of physical and mental suffering is the necessary result.”
- “Where serious bodily injury, is inflicted involving fractures, dislocations, etc., and results in protracted disability and confinement to bed, we know that some degree of physical and mental suffering is the necessary result.”
- “Where serious bodily injury is inflicted involving fractures, dislocations, etc., and results in protracted disability and confinement to bed, we know that some degree of physical and mental suffering is the necessary result.”
- “Where serious bodily injury is inflicted involving fractures, dislocations, etc., and results in protracted disability and confinement to bed, we know that some degree of physical and mental suffering is the necessary result.”
- “Where serious bodily injury is inflicted involving fractures, dislocations, etc., and [which] results in protracted disability and confinement to bed, we know that some degree of physical and mental suffering is the necessary result.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Gaines
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
34 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- City of Tyler v. LikesTexas Supreme Court· 1998-02-13· cited 531×
- Fifth Club, Inc. v. RamirezTexas Supreme Court· 2006-06-30· cited 211×
- Weidner v. SanchezTex. App. Ct., 14th Dist. (Houston)· 2000-03-23· cited 177×
- Tinkle v. St. Louis & San Francisco RailroadSupreme Court of Missouri· 1908-05-19· cited 45×
- Cactus Drilling Company v. WilliamsCourt of Appeals of Texas· 1975-06-30· cited 29×
- Kingham Messenger & Delivery Service, Inc. v. DanielsCourt of Appeals of Texas· 1968-11-20· cited 20×
- Casas v. ParadezTex. App. Ct., 4th Dist. (San Antonio)· 2008-06-25· cited 17×
- Evans v. DillinghamU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Texas· 1890-06-02· cited 14×
- Saint Louis, Arkansas & Texas Railway Co. v. EvansTexas Supreme Court· 1890-11-07· cited 11×
- Texarkana & Ft. Smith Railway Co. v. Rosebrook-Josey Grain Co.Court of Appeals of Texas· 1908-11-26· cited 10×
- Turner v. DugginCourt of Appeals of Texas· 2017-03-31· cited 10×
- CENTOCOR, INC. v. HamiltonTex. App. Ct., 13th Dist.· 2010-03-04· cited 7×
- Johnson v. Methodist HospitalTex. App. Ct., 1st Dist. (Houston)· 2006-12-14· cited 7×
- Missouri Pac. Ry. Co. v. Texas Pac. Ry. Co.U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Eastern Louisiana· 1890-02-04· cited 7×
- Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. ReeceTex. App. Ct., 10th Dist. (Waco)· 2000-10-18· cited 6×
- Etchison v. LuskMissouri Court of Appeals· 1917-01-08· cited 6×
- Saldana v. Galveston, H. & S. A. Ry. Co.U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Western Texas· 1890-10-15· cited 5×
- McFarlane v. Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul Railway Co.Washington Supreme Court· 1924-04-03· cited 4×
- Morehouse v. Texas Trunk R'y Co.Court of Appeals of Texas· 1891-12-09· cited 1×
- Fifth Club, Inc. and David A. West v. Roberto RamirezTexas Supreme Court· 2006-06-30
Cites
2 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
Other cases named Brown v. Sullivan
15 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- Brown v. SullivanNew York Court of Common Pleas· 1892-11-07· cited 10×
- Brown v. SullivanNebraska Supreme Court· 1976-04-01· cited 8×
- Brown v. SullivanW.D. New York· 1989-10-30· cited 4×
- Brown v. SullivanIndiana Court of Appeals· 1891-12-11· cited 4×
- Brown v. SullivanC.D. Illinois· 1990-05-14· cited 1×
- Brown v. SullivanSecond Circuit· 1989-03-15
- Brown v. SullivanEleventh Circuit· 1989-10-11
- Brown v. SullivanFifth Circuit· 1991-01-09
- Brown v. SullivanEleventh Circuit· 1991-10-16
- Brown v. SullivanEleventh Circuit· 1992-09-09
- Brown v. SullivanAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1916-11-15
- Brown v. SullivanMississippi Supreme Court· 1972-01-31
- Brown v. SullivanE.D. Wisconsin· 1991-08-16
- Brown v. SullivanSupreme Court· 1990-06-04
- Brown v. SullivanSupreme Court· 1990-06-04
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.