Brown v. First Nat. Bank
Citations
- 132 F. 450
- 66 C.C.A. 293
- 1904 U.S. App. LEXIS 4339
Syllabus
<p>1. Practice — Splitting Cause of Action Bars.</p> <p>One who avails himself, by action or by defense to an action, of a part of an indivisible claim or cause of action, thereby estops himself from again maintaining an action or defense founded upon it One may not split his cause of action.</p> <p>2. Res Adjudicata — Failure to Interpose Defenses.</p> <p>Judgment in an action in which the defendant fails to interpose purely defensive matters renders such matters res adjudicata, and estops him from obtaining any relief on account of them.</p> <p>8. Same — Failure to Interpose Facts Constituting Affirmative Action.</p> <p>The failure by a defendant to interpose before judgment facts which constitute both a defense to the action and an affirmative cause of action against the plaintiff does not estop him from enforcing the latter.</p> <p>4. Same — Defendant has Option to Use Such Facts as Defense or Affirmative Cause.</p> <p>A defendant who has a claim which constitutes a defense to the action, against him and an affirmative cause of action against the plaintiff has the option to use it for defense or for attack, but he cannot do both. If he avails himself of any part of it in defense of the action against him, he is thereby conclusively estopped from subsequently maintaining an action against the plaintiff upon any portion of it, and he loses the excess.</p> <p>B. Collateral Security-Wrongful Surrender by Pledgee.</p> <p>The wrongful surrender by a pledgee, either intentionally or through culpable negligence, of collateral security, furnishes the pledgor with a cause of action against him in tort or upon contract, at his option, for the value of the securities thus surrendered.</p> <p>6. Same — Defense by Sureties — Wrongful Surrender by Pledgee.</p> <p>The wrongful surrender of collateral securities by a creditor, without the knowledge of sureties, for the payment of the debt, discharges them from liability therefor, either entirely or pro tanto, according to the va
Judges: Amidon, Devanter, Sanborn
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
22 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Harrison v. Remington Paper Co.Eighth Circuit· 1905-08-22· cited 92×
- American Bonding Co. of Baltimore v. Pueblo Inv. Co.Eighth Circuit· 1906-11-07· cited 72×
- Pierce v. National Bank of CommerceEighth Circuit· 1920-11-06· cited 59×
- Big Cola Corporation v. World Bottling Co.Sixth Circuit· 1943-04-08· cited 30×
- Geracy, Inc. v. HooverD.C. Circuit· 1942-12-14· cited 26×
- Taylor v. Continental Supply Co.Eighth Circuit· 1926-11-22· cited 25×
- Watkins v. American Nat. BankEighth Circuit· 1904-11-11· cited 17×
- Miller v. Belvy Oil Co.Eighth Circuit· 1917-11-12· cited 16×
- Derderian v. UNION MARKET NATIONAL BANKMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1950-12-05· cited 11×
- John Miller Co. v. Harvey Mercantile Co.North Dakota Supreme Court· 1920-05-18· cited 10×
- State ex rel. Alaska Pacific Navigation Co. v. Superior CourtWashington Supreme Court· 1920-12-15· cited 9×
- In re RothN.D. Ohio· 1920-06-08· cited 8×
- First Acceptance Corp. v. KennedyN.D. Iowa· 1951-02-26· cited 6×
- Young v. Baker, Fentress & Co.Seventh Circuit· 1934-12-11· cited 4×
- Du Bois Nat. Bank v. Hartford Accident & Indemnity Co.Third Circuit· 1947-04-21· cited 4×
- Wagner v. KohnSecond Circuit· 1915-07-06· cited 4×
- Varden v. First Christian ChurchE.D. Kentucky· 1936-01-09· cited 3×
- McCray v. Sapulpa Petroleum Co.Eighth Circuit· 1927-09-16· cited 2×
- Coos Bay Lumber Co. v. CollierNinth Circuit· 1939-06-07· cited 2×
- Stevenson v. RuthThird Circuit· 1935-03-05· cited 1×
Cites
22 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Faulk v. KellumsIllinois Supreme Court· 1870-06-15· cited 28×
- Coates v. PrestonIllinois Supreme Court· 1882-11-20· cited 27×
- Himrod v. BaughIllinois Supreme Court· 1877-06-15· cited 22×
- Byers v. First National BankIllinois Supreme Court· 1877-06-15· cited 18×
- Cook v. MoseleyNew York Supreme Court· 1835-01-15· cited 16×
- Mimnaugh v. PartlinMichigan Supreme Court· 1887-10-27· cited 16×
- Davidson v. BondIllinois Supreme Court· 1850-11-15· cited 15×
- Lucas v. Le CompteIllinois Supreme Court· 1866-11-15· cited 14×
- Hilliard v. WalkerIllinois Supreme Court· 1850-06-15· cited 10×
- Briggs v. AdamsIllinois Supreme Court· 1863-04-15· cited 10×
- Geiser Threshing Machine Co. v. FarmerSupreme Court of Minnesota· 1881-01-31· cited 9×
- Brown v. First Nat. Bank of NewtonSeventh Circuit· 1902-01-07· cited 9×
- Hayes v. CooperAppellate Court of Illinois· 1884-04-18· cited 7×
- Goit v. JoyceIllinois Supreme Court· 1871-09-15· cited 6×
- Davison v. HillAppellate Court of Illinois· 1877-10-15· cited 6×
- Garland v. PeeneyAppellate Court of Illinois· 1878-04-15· cited 6×
- Barth v. BurtNew York Supreme Court· 1865-02-01· cited 4×
- Rosenberg v. BarrettAppellate Court of Illinois· 1878-10-15· cited 4×
- Cairo & St. Louis Railroad v. EasterlyIllinois Supreme Court· 1878-06-15· cited 3×
- Goodale v. CooperAppellate Court of Illinois· 1880-04-02· cited 3×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.