Brown-Forman Co. v. Kentucky
Citations
- 217 U.S. 563
- 30 S. Ct. 578
- 54 L. Ed. 883
- 1910 U.S. LEXIS 1984
Syllabus
<p>This court accepts the construction by the highest court of the State that the tax imposed by the state statute in this ease is not a property tax, but a license tax, imposed on the doing of a business which is subject to the regulating power of the State.</p> <p>The function of taxation is fundamental to the existence of the governmental power of the States, and the restriction against denial of equal protection of the law does not compel an iron rule of equal taxation, prevent variety in methods, or the exercise of a wide discretion in classification.</p> <p>A classification which is not capricious or arbitrary and rests upon reasonable consideration of difference or policy does not deny equal protection of the law, and so held that the classification in the Ken-</p> <p>. tucky act of 1906, imposing a license tax on persons compounding, rectifying, adulterating, or blending distilled spirits, is not a denial of equal protection of the law because it discriminates in favor of the distillers and rectifiers of straight distilled spirits.</p> <p>A State cannot impose an occupation tax on.a business conducted outside of the State, and a license tax imposed on those doing a specified business within-the State is not unconstitutional as denying equal protection of the law or violating the commerce clause because not imposed on those who carry on the same business beyond the jurisdiction of the State and who ship goods into the State.</p> <p>While taxation, discriminating in favor of residents and domestic products,- and against non-residents and foreign products, might be in valid, under the commerce clause, that objection does not apply to uniform taxation on a business which does not discriminate' in favor of residents or domestic products.</p> <p>While a state tax on.goods which discriminates arbitrarily against the products of that State and in favor of other States denies equal protection of the law, as both classes of goods are within the taxing power of the Sta
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- explaining that, under rational basis review, a regulation will defeat an Equal Protection challenge if it is “reasonable, not arbitrary and bears a rational relationship to a (permissible) state objective”
- “If the selection or classification is neither capricious nor arbitrary, and rests upon some reasonable consideration of difference or policy, there is no denial of equal protection of the law.”
- power to tax is fundamental; State power subject only to restrictions of due process and equal protection
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Lurton
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
121 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Nebbia v. New YorkSupreme Court· 1934-03-05· cited 1,848×
- Nordlinger v. HahnSupreme Court· 1992-06-18· cited 1,649×
- Carmichael v. Southern Coal & Coke Co.Supreme Court· 1937-05-24· cited 904×
- Allied Stores of Ohio, Inc. v. BowersSupreme Court· 1959-02-24· cited 747×
- Steward MacHine Co. v. DavisSupreme Court· 1937-05-24· cited 740×
- Henneford v. Silas Mason Co.Supreme Court· 1937-03-29· cited 429×
- Allegheny Pittsburgh Coal Co. v. Commission of Webster Cty.Supreme Court· 1989-01-18· cited 375×
- State Bd. of Tax Commr's of Ind. v. JacksonSupreme Court· 1931-05-25· cited 372×
- Lawrence v. State Tax Comm'n of Miss.Supreme Court· 1932-05-16· cited 336×
- New York Rapid Transit Corp. v. City of New YorkSupreme Court· 1938-03-28· cited 232×
- State Bd. of Equalization of Cal. v. Young's Market Co.Supreme Court· 1936-11-09· cited 226×
- Louis K. Liggett Co. v. LeeSupreme Court· 1933-03-13· cited 195×
- Quaker City Cab Co. v. Commonwealth of PennsylvaniaSupreme Court· 1928-05-28· cited 192×
- Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Co. v. GrosjeanSupreme Court· 1937-05-17· cited 189×
- Ohio Oil Co. v. ConwaySupreme Court· 1930-04-14· cited 158×
- Kellems v. BrownSupreme Court of Connecticut· 1972-07-27· cited 154×
- Neild v. District of ColumbiaD.C. Circuit· 1940-01-15· cited 116×
- Stewart Dry Goods Co. v. LewisSupreme Court· 1935-03-11· cited 115×
- Aero Mayflower Transit Co. v. Georgia Public Service CommissionSupreme Court· 1935-04-29· cited 97×
- People v. AstaMichigan Supreme Court· 1953-10-05· cited 92×
Cites
7 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Gulf, Colorado & Santa Fé Railway Co. v. EllisSupreme Court· 1897-01-18· cited 580×
- Bell's Gap Railroad v. PennsylvaniaSupreme Court· 1890-03-10· cited 449×
- Missouri, Kansas & Texas Railway Co. v. MaySupreme Court· 1904-05-02· cited 237×
- Southwestern Oil Co. v. TexasSupreme Court· 1910-04-04· cited 165×
- Emert v. MissouriSupreme Court· 1895-03-04· cited 149×
- W. W. Cargill Co. v. MinnesotaSupreme Court· 1901-03-05· cited 112×
- Williams v. ArkansasSupreme Court· 1910-04-04· cited 84×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.