Skip to main content

Breedlove v. State

Citations

  • 26 Tex. Ct. App. 445
  • 9 S.W. 768
  • 1888 Tex. Crim. App. LEXIS 208

Syllabus

<p>1. Murder—Manslaughter—Charge op the Court.—If, in an attempt to kill a certain person the slayer, through mistake, kills another person, the homicide thus committed can not be of a higher grade than murder of the second degree. If, however, the slayer had killed the* person he intended to, kill, and such killing, under the circumstances surrounding it, would be manslaughter, then the killing of a third person by mistake, believing him to be the person intended, would be manslaughter. The facts of this case show that, had the defendant killed the person intended, such killing would have been murder of the first degree. The evidence, therefore, does not raise the issue of manslaughter, and in omitting to instruct the jury upon that issue the trial court did not err.</p> <p>A Same—Practice—Evidence—Fact Case.—The proof being that the deceas-d and one King were sitting in juxtaposition when the fatal shot was tired from ambush, and the theory of the State being that the defendant fired the said shot from a gun secured by him from the house of one Frances Graybill, on the evening of the homicide, the defense ■objected that the State should have been compelled to produce or account for the testimony of King and said Frances as the best evidence in the ease—King being present when deceased received the wound and Prances Graybill being at home, as shown by the proof, when the defendant arrived at the house shortly before the killing. But held that, the proof failing to show that King could testify to any material fact, and showing that Frances Graybill was absent from her house after the arrival of the defendant long enough for him to have taken the gun' without her knowledge, the objection is without merit. See the statement of the case for evidence held, though circumstantial, to be sufficient to support a conviction for murder in the second degree.</p>

Judges: Willson

Read full opinion on CourtListener

Other cases with this name

Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).

This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.