Skip to main content

Citations

  • 128 Pa. 205
  • 18 A. 512
  • 1889 Pa. LEXIS 784

Syllabus

<p>(a) An agreement was made between a debtor and his creditors that a fund to be raised by the debtor should be distributed ratably among the creditors, one who declined to release the debtor to receive a smaller percentage than the others who consented to release. To avoid delay in the distribution, certain releasing creditors agreed to accept a chose in action of the debtor on account of their dividends, permitting all others to receive their full dividends in cash.</p> <p>(b) Iu pursuance of this agreement, the non-releasing creditor was paid his dividend in cash, and the debtor executed and delivered to M, one of the releasing creditors, an assignment in the following form: “I hereby assign and set over to M, for the benefit of my creditors, or of such of them whom he may designate who have made rebates in their settlement......the sum of $1,781.59, which sum is now in the hands of Peter Boyd, Esq.” This assignment was never recorded.</p> <p>1. By his participation in this transaction the non-releasing creditor was precluded from subsequently attaching said chose in action in the hands of the person owing the same, and from setting up in support of the attachment that said transfer was made in such a form as to be an assignment for the benefit of creditors and therefore void for want of recording.</p> <p>2. In determining whether a transfer of property by a debtor to one of his creditors, for the benefit of the transferee and other creditors, is an assignment for the benefit of creditors, within the meaning of the act of March 24, 1818, 7 Sm. L. 132, so as to be void if not recorded, regard must be had to the substance rather than to the form of the transaction.</p> <p>3. Having regard to the substance rather than form, the transaction was not an assignment for the benefit of creditors but simply a contract between creditors and their debtor. M, and the other accepting creditors, were purchasers of the chose in action, the consideration being a release of the d

Judges: Green, McCollum, Mitchell, Sterrett, Williams

Read full opinion on CourtListener

Cited by

1 case in this archive cites this case.

Other cases with this name

Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).

This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.