Utah Supreme Court· 8/17/2004
Black v. Allstate Insurance Co.
Citations
- 2004 UT 66
- 100 P.3d 1163
- 506 Utah Adv. Rep. 13
- 2004 Utah LEXIS 158
- 2004 WL 1824116
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- recognizing that even if an insurance company participates in negotiations, no fiduciary duties arise until the insured has “relinquished any right to negotiate on his own behalf’
- stating that before an insured is sued by a third party, the insurer’s breach of duty in handling the claim involves a cause of action in contract rather than tort
- noting that, with respect to a first-party situation, “[w]ithout more, a breach of those implied or express duties can give rise only to a cause of action in contract, not one in tort” (alteration in original) (quoting Beck, 100 P.3d at 800)
- “[B]reaeh of this [fiduciary] duty to defend may potentially expose the insurer to consequential and punitive damages awards in excess of policy limits.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Durrant, Durham, Wilkins, Parrish, Nehring, Durrant'S
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
14 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Loudin v. National Liability & Fire InsuranceWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2011-09-22· cited 31×
- STEVENSEN 3RD EAST, LC v. WattsCourt of Appeals of Utah· 2009-05-21· cited 18×
- UMIA Insurance v. SaltzUtah Supreme Court· 2022-06-09· cited 15×
- Clearone Communications, Inc. v. National Union Fire InsuranceTenth Circuit· 2007-07-25· cited 14×
- Northgate Village Development, LC v. Orem CityCourt of Appeals of Utah· 2014-04-17· cited 12×
- Rupp v. Transcontinental InsuranceD. Utah· 2008-11-17· cited 9×
- Baxter v. Saunders Outdoor Advertising, Inc.Court of Appeals of Utah· 2007-10-18· cited 8×
- Lund v. Truck Insurance ExchangeCourt of Appeals of Utah· 2021-06-24· cited 5×
- Colony Insurance Co. v. Human Ensemble, LLCCourt of Appeals of Utah· 2013-03-14· cited 5×
- De Adder v. Intermountain Healthcare, Inc.Court of Appeals of Utah· 2013-07-11· cited 4×
- Morden v. XL Specialty InsuranceD. Utah· 2016-04-05· cited 3×
- Farm Bureau v. WestonCourt of Appeals of Utah· 2023-11-09· cited 3×
- Headwaters Resources, Inc. v. Illinois Union InsuranceD. Utah· 2012-12-20· cited 1×
- Fire Ins Exchange v. OltmannsUtah Supreme Court· 2017-11-21
Cites
6 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Beck v. Farmers Insurance ExchangeUtah Supreme Court· 1985-06-12· cited 246×
- Blue Cross and Blue Shield v. StateUtah Supreme Court· 1989-07-19· cited 110×
- Ammerman Ex Rel. Ammerman v. Farmers Insurance ExchangeUtah Supreme Court· 1967-07-25· cited 55×
- Pixton v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co.Court of Appeals of Utah· 1991-04-08· cited 40×
- Sperry v. SperryUtah Supreme Court· 1999-10-29· cited 18×
- Bearden v. CroftUtah Supreme Court· 2001-08-21· cited 14×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.