California Supreme Court· 8/12/2002
Bird v. Saenz
Citations
- 51 P.3d 324
- 123 Cal. Rptr. 2d 465
- 28 Cal. 4th 910
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- noting that La Chusa made the Dillon factors mandatory requirements that bystander claims for emotional distress must satisfy to be accepted as valid
- describing the evolution of California’s law on liability for negligent infliction of emotional distress
- describing the Thing contemporaneous awareness requirement as requiring a bystander to perceive the “impact on the victim” and to “then know it is causing injury,” but not permitting recovery when the “knowledge is acquired moments later”
- “Such an accident, and its injury-causing effects, would not lie beyond the plaintiff’s understanding awareness.”
- “Except in the most obvious cases, a misdiagnosis is beyond the awareness of lay bystanders.”
- “One takes a giant 13 leap . . . by imposing liability for NIED based on nothing more than a bystander’s ‘observation of 14 the results of the defendant’s infliction of harm,’ however ‘direct and contemporaneous.’”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Werdegar
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
18 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Spangler v. BechtelIndiana Supreme Court· 2011-12-13· cited 72×
- Kempton v. City of Los AngelesCalifornia Court of Appeal· 2008-08-13· cited 30×
- Fortman v. Förvaltningsbolaget Insulan ABCalifornia Court of Appeal· 2013-01-10· cited 12×
- RA v. Superior CourtCalifornia Court of Appeal· 2007-08-15· cited 7×
- Bailey v. County of San JoaquinE.D. California· 2009-11-16· cited 7×
- Entergy Mississippi, Inc. v. Mary Bethanne AceyMississippi Supreme Court· 2014-10-23· cited 4×
- Rodney And Tammy Henderson v. The Vanderbilt UniversityCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2017-05-31· cited 4×
- Lisa Coward v. Gagne & Sons Concrete Blocks, Inc.Supreme Judicial Court of Maine· 2020-09-17· cited 4×
- Morton v. Thousand Oaks Surgical HospitalCalifornia Court of Appeal· 2010-08-23· cited 3×
- Doan v. Banner Health, Inc.Alaska Supreme Court· 2019-05-31· cited 1×
- Keys v. Alta Bates SummitCalifornia Court of Appeal· 2015-03-25
- Squeo v. Norwalk Hospital Assn.Supreme Court of Connecticut· 2015-04-28
- Ko v. Maxim Healthcare Services, Inc.California Court of Appeal· 2020-12-23
- Ko v. Maxim Healthcare Services, Inc.California Court of Appeal· 2021-01-14
- Downey v. City of RiversideCalifornia Court of Appeal· 2023-04-26
- Downey v. City of RiversideCalifornia Supreme Court· 2024-07-22
- Marc Chartier, Individually, and as Administrator of the Estate of Lisa Chartier v. Apple Therapy of Londonderry, LLC & a.Supreme Court of New Hampshire· 2023-02-10
- Rhonda Baldwin, as of the Estate of Garrett O. Baldwin v. Central Iowa Hospital Corp., d/b/a Iowa Methodist Medical CenterSupreme Court of Iowa· 2026-05-22
Cites
18 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Rowland v. ChristianCalifornia Supreme Court· 1968-08-08· cited 1,329×
- Dillon v. LeggCalifornia Supreme Court· 1968-06-21· cited 1,026×
- Thing v. La ChusaCalifornia Supreme Court· 1989-04-27· cited 440×
- Justus v. AtchisonCalifornia Supreme Court· 1977-06-08· cited 284×
- Ochoa v. Superior CourtCalifornia Supreme Court· 1985-07-29· cited 226×
- Amaya v. Home Ice, Fuel & Supply Co.California Supreme Court· 1963-03-12· cited 152×
- Archibald v. BravermanCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1969-07-28· cited 97×
- Mobaldi v. Regents of University of CaliforniaCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1976-02-23· cited 61×
- Nazaroff v. Superior CourtCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1978-05-01· cited 57×
- Wright v. City of Los AngelesCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1990-03-30· cited 52×
- Jansen v. Children's Hospital Medical CenterCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1973-03-08· cited 45×
- Golstein v. Superior CourtCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1990-09-20· cited 39×
- Meighan v. ShoreCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1995-05-04· cited 31×
- Breazeal v. Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial HospitalCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1991-10-02· cited 24×
- Wilks v. HomCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1992-01-21· cited 23×
- Fife v. AsteniusCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1991-07-29· cited 19×
- State v. HulseyCourt of Appeals of Oregon· 1970-07-09· cited 9×
- Bird v. SaenzCalifornia Supreme Court· 2002-08-12· cited 2×
Other cases named Bird v. Saenz
2 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.