California Supreme Court· 8/27/1992
Bily v. Arthur Young & Co.
Citations
- 834 P.2d 745
- 3 Cal. 4th 370
- 11 Cal. Rptr. 2d 51
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- rejecting the foreseeability approach which had been adopted by lower courts and noting that the foreseeability approach has not attracted a substantial following and has encountered substantial criticism from commentators
- “An auditor is a watchdog, not a bloodhound. As a matter of commercial reality, audits are performed in a client-controlled environment.”
- duty of care owed only to “limited class of plaintiffs to whom the supplier itself has directed its activity”
- essentially adopting the principles of limited liability set forth in Restatement (Second
- “California courts have consistently required some manifestation on the part of a professional ... that he or she is acting to benefit a third party ... in a specific and circumscribed transaction.”
- “[A]n instruction based on the elements of negligent 20 misrepresentation necessarily and properly focuses the jury’s attention on the truth or falsity of the 21 . . . representations and plaintiff’s actual and justifiable reliance on them.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Lucas, Kennard
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
245 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- In Re Burlington Coat Factory Securities Litigation. P. Gregory Buchanan, Jacob Turner and Ronald AbramoffThird Circuit· 1997-06-10· cited 4,496×
- Ernst & Young, L.L.P. v. Pacific Mutual Life Insurance Co.Texas Supreme Court· 2001-06-21· cited 560×
- Quelimane Co. v. Stewart Title Guaranty Co.California Supreme Court· 1998-09-23· cited 514×
- Alliance Mortgage Co. v. RothwellCalifornia Supreme Court· 1995-08-28· cited 407×
- Charles Schwab Corp. v. Bank of America Corp.Second Circuit· 2018-02-23· cited 359×
- Small v. Fritz Companies, Inc.California Supreme Court· 2003-04-07· cited 297×
- Paulsen v. CNF INC.Ninth Circuit· 2009-03-20· cited 293×
- Mirkin v. WassermanCalifornia Supreme Court· 1993-09-09· cited 252×
- Conroy v. Regents of University of CaliforniaCalifornia Supreme Court· 2009-04-06· cited 245×
- Kesner v. Superior Court of Alameda CountyCalifornia Supreme Court· 2016-12-01· cited 233×
- Anschutz Corp. v. Merrill Lynch & Co.Second Circuit· 2012-08-14· cited 225×
- Grant Thornton LLP v. Prospect High Income FundTexas Supreme Court· 2010-07-02· cited 214×
- Artiglio v. Corning Inc.California Supreme Court· 1998-07-09· cited 200×
- Connerly v. State Personnel BoardCalifornia Supreme Court· 2006-03-02· cited 197×
- Parsons v. Crown Disposal Co.California Supreme Court· 1997-05-08· cited 175×
- O'NEIL v. Crane Co.California Supreme Court· 2012-01-12· cited 151×
- Spinks v. Equity Residential Briarwood ApartmentsCalifornia Court of Appeal· 2009-03-04· cited 148×
- Cornette v. Department of TransportationCalifornia Supreme Court· 2001-07-12· cited 147×
- Onita Pacific Corp. v. Trustees of BronsonOregon Supreme Court· 1992-12-31· cited 144×
- In Re Marriage CasesCalifornia Supreme Court· 2008-05-15· cited 139×
Cites
74 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Barefoot v. EstelleSupreme Court· 1983-07-06· cited 4,617×
- Ernst & Ernst v. HochfelderSupreme Court· 1976-05-19· cited 3,533×
- Blue Chip Stamps v. Manor Drug StoresSupreme Court· 1975-10-06· cited 2,261×
- Herman & MacLean v. HuddlestonSupreme Court· 1983-01-24· cited 1,450×
- Rowland v. ChristianCalifornia Supreme Court· 1968-08-08· cited 1,329×
- Tarasoff v. Regents of University of CaliforniaCalifornia Supreme Court· 1976-07-01· cited 1,035×
- Dillon v. LeggCalifornia Supreme Court· 1968-06-21· cited 1,026×
- Biakanja v. IrvingCalifornia Supreme Court· 1958-01-17· cited 586×
- Harris v. Capital Growth Investors XIVCalifornia Supreme Court· 1991-02-28· cited 457×
- Goodman v. KennedyCalifornia Supreme Court· 1976-11-29· cited 448×
- Thing v. La ChusaCalifornia Supreme Court· 1989-04-27· cited 440×
- Molien v. Kaiser Foundation HospitalsCalifornia Supreme Court· 1980-08-25· cited 419×
- United States v. Arthur Young & Co.Supreme Court· 1984-03-21· cited 411×
- Escola v. Coca Cola Bottling Co.California Supreme Court· 1944-07-05· cited 411×
- Haberman v. Washington Public Power Supply SystemWashington Supreme Court· 1988-02-17· cited 400×
- Christensen v. Superior CourtCalifornia Supreme Court· 1991-12-02· cited 375×
- Thompson v. County of AlamedaCalifornia Supreme Court· 1980-07-14· cited 357×
- Nally v. Grace Community ChurchCalifornia Supreme Court· 1988-11-23· cited 356×
- J'Aire Corp. v. GregoryCalifornia Supreme Court· 1979-08-13· cited 287×
- White v. GuarenteNew York Court of Appeals· 1977-12-21· cited 280×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.