Berka v. Woodward
Citations
- 125 Cal. 119
- 57 P. 777
- 1899 Cal. LEXIS 811
Syllabus
<p>Municipal Corporations—Illegal Contract by Member of Council—Implied Contract Prohibited.—The provisions of <i city charter and of the Political Code forbidding a member of the city council to be directly or indirectly interested in any contract made by the council, and of the Penal Code providing a penalty therefor, apply both to express and implied contracts; and a member of such council who has expressly contracted with it for the sale of lumber and materials to the city, cannot recover their value upon an implied contract.</p> <p>Id—Recovery upon Implied Contract, When Permissible.—It is only where contracts of public officers with their counties or municipalities have not been expressly forbidden by law, and are not malum in se, but are merely considered contrary to public policy, that the officer is allowed to recover upon an implied contract, upon a quantum meruit or quantum valelat. But no recovery of any kind can be had where the contract is either malum in se, or expressly prohibited.</p> <p>Id.—Effect of Penalty—Illegal Contbact—Where a statute pronounces a penalty for an act, a contract founded upon such act is void, even though the statute does not pronounce it void nor expressly prohibit it.</p> <p>Id.—Allowance of Claim by Council—Duty of Tbeasureb—Mandamus.—The allowance of a claim by the city council for the value of lumber and materials sold to the city by a member of the council does not give the claim a validity not otherwise possessed. It is the duty of the treasurer to pay only legal demands against his funds; and he cannot be compelled by mandamus to pay such claim.</p>
Judges: Henshaw
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
60 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Lewis & Queen v. N. M. Ball SonsCalifornia Supreme Court· 1957-03-19· cited 225×
- Rogers v. Superior CourtCalifornia Supreme Court· 1955-12-29· cited 195×
- Thomson v. CallCalifornia Supreme Court· 1985-05-23· cited 124×
- Caminetti v. Pac. Mut. Life Ins. Co. of Cal.California Supreme Court· 1943-06-25· cited 115×
- Dekam v. City of StreatorIllinois Supreme Court· 1925-02-17· cited 73×
- Citizens State Bank v. GentryCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1937-04-19· cited 46×
- Norbeck & Nicholson Co. v. StateSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1913-07-11· cited 46×
- People Ex Rel. State of Cal. v. DrinkhouseCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1970-02-26· cited 44×
- Wilson v. StearnsCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1954-02-25· cited 41×
- National Union Indemnity Co. v. Bruce Bros.Arizona Supreme Court· 1934-12-07· cited 39×
- Vitek, Inc. v. Alvarado Ice Palace, Inc.California Court of Appeal· 1973-10-11· cited 38×
- Miller v. City of MartinezCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1938-09-01· cited 35×
- City of Oakland v. California Construction Co.California Supreme Court· 1940-06-27· cited 34×
- Medina v. Safe-Guard Products, International, Inc.California Court of Appeal· 2008-06-19· cited 34×
- Kyne v. KyneCalifornia Supreme Court· 1940-10-28· cited 26×
- Tallman v. LewisSupreme Court of Arkansas· 1916-05-01· cited 26×
- Kagy v. Independent DistrictSupreme Court of Iowa· 1902-04-09· cited 24×
- South Tahoe Gas Co. v. Hofmann Land Improvement Co.California Court of Appeal· 1972-05-19· cited 22×
- City of Los Angeles v. WattersonCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1935-07-08· cited 21×
- Carter v. Bradley County Road Improvement Districts 1 & 2Supreme Court of Arkansas· 1923-10-16· cited 20×
Cites
12 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Mayor of Macon v. HuffSupreme Court of Georgia· 1878-01-19· cited 53×
- Santa Clara Valley Mill and Lumber Co. v. HayesCalifornia Supreme Court· 1888-06-04· cited 51×
- Morrill v. NightingaleCalifornia Supreme Court· 1892-02-20· cited 42×
- Swanger v. MayberryCalifornia Supreme Court· 1881-07-15· cited 33×
- Santa Cruz Rock Pavement Co. v. BroderickCalifornia Supreme Court· 1896-08-07· cited 30×
- Pickett v. School District No. OneWisconsin Supreme Court· 1870-01-15· cited 28×
- Gardner v. TatumCalifornia Supreme Court· 1889-11-30· cited 25×
- Currie v. School-District No. 26Supreme Court of Minnesota· 1886-04-19· cited 20×
- Visalia Gas & Electric Light Co. v. SimsCalifornia Supreme Court· 1894-10-03· cited 18×
- Spearman v. TexarkanaSupreme Court of Arkansas· 1894-01-13· cited 18×
- Call Publishing Co. v. City of LincolnNebraska Supreme Court· 1890-03-19· cited 9×
- City of Concordia v. HagamanCourt of Appeals of Kansas· 1895-07-06· cited 9×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.