Bates v. Fremont, E. & M. V. R.
Citations
- 4 S.D. 394
- 57 N.W. 72
- 1893 S.D. LEXIS 88
Syllabus
<p>1. Section 5501, Comp. Laws, makes proof of the killing of stock by a railroad company prima facie evidence of the negligence of the company, and an averment, in the complaint in such an action, that the stock were so killed-within the terms of the statute, is a sufficient averment of negligence on the part of the company.</p> <p>2. Upon the trial, if the evidence leave the facts undisputed, and they are such that different conclusions or inferences could not reasonably be drawn from them, it becomes the duty of the court to declare their legal effect; but if the facts are in dispute, or, if undisputed, they are such that different impartial minds might fairly draw different conclusions from them, they should be submitted to the j ury.</p> <p>3. ■ Evidence of defendant’s witnesses that the whistle was blown and the bell rung at the usual distance from the crossing, and that of plaintiff’s witnesses that they heard no whistle or bell, though sufficiently near to hear, and watching and listening for the same, creates a conflict as to the fact of the bell being rung or the whistle blown, which question, if material, should be submitted to the jury.</p> <p>4. Where the plaintiff was driving a number of loose horses and mules along the highway in the afternoon; and towards-a railroad crossing, the track for some distance being obscured By an intervening embankment, knowing that a train was due to pass during the afternoon, but not at what hour, the fact that he did not ride ahead, and hold his stock back until he could and did go to the track and ascertain whether or not a train was coming, is a fact tending to show contributory negligence, and as such should go to the jury with all the circumstances of the case, but it does not establish contributory negligence as matter of law.</p> <p>Corson, J., dissenting.</p> <p>(Syllabus by the Court.</p>
Judges: Bennett, Corson, Kellam
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
12 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Schmeling v. JorgensenSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1957-08-02· cited 45×
- Harrison v. Chicago, M. & St. P. Ry. Co.South Dakota Supreme Court· 1894-10-17· cited 19×
- McCormick Harvesting Machine Co. v. FaulknerSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1895-08-24· cited 19×
- Reid v. KelloggSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1896-06-03· cited 16×
- Merchants Nat. Bank v. StebbinsSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1901-12-31· cited 6×
- Dimock State Bank v. BoehnenSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1922-10-27· cited 6×
- Crary v. Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul Railway Co.South Dakota Supreme Court· 1904-06-11· cited 4×
- Hormann v. SherinSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1894-10-05· cited 2×
- Dischner v. Piqua Mut. Aid & Accident Ass'nSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1901-05-04· cited 2×
- Weller v. HilderbrandtSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1904-12-21· cited 2×
- Brunick v. Ann Arbor RailroadMichigan Supreme Court· 1903-02-03· cited 1×
- Aultman Engine & Thresher Co. v. BoydSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1907-05-29
Cites
17 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Cincinnati, Hamilton & Indianapolis Railroad v. ButlerIndiana Supreme Court· 1885-09-16· cited 70×
- Henze v. St. Louis, Kansas City & Northern Railway Co.Supreme Court of Missouri· 1880-04-15· cited 67×
- Haas v. Grand Rapids & Indiana RailroadMichigan Supreme Court· 1882-01-11· cited 49×
- Louisville, New Albany & Chicago Railway Co. v. StommelIndiana Supreme Court· 1890-11-14· cited 42×
- Abbett v. Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul Railway Co.Supreme Court of Minnesota· 1883-06-14· cited 42×
- Fletcher v. Fitchburg RailroadMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1889-05-09· cited 28×
- Greenwood v. Phil. W. & B. R.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1889-03-18· cited 27×
- Turner v. Hannibal & St. Joseph RailroadSupreme Court of Missouri· 1881-10-15· cited 24×
- Marty v. Chicago, St. Paul, Minneapolis & Omaha Railway Co.Supreme Court of Minnesota· 1888-01-02· cited 21×
- Cincinnati, Indianapolis, St. Louis & Chicago Railway Co. v. GramesIndiana Court of Appeals· 1893-06-21· cited 17×
- Engle v. Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul Railway Co.Supreme Court of Iowa· 1888-03-09· cited 17×
- Kellogg v. New York Central & Hudson River RailroadNew York Court of Appeals· 1879-11-25· cited 15×
- Tyler v. New York & New England RailroadMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1884-05-10· cited 13×
- McCrory v. Chicago, M. & St. P. Ry. Co.U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Minnesota· 1887-06-13· cited 10×
- Swan v. WhaleySupreme Court of Iowa· 1887-12-08· cited 9×
- Hindman v. Oregon Railway & Navigation Co.Oregon Supreme Court· 1889-05-20· cited 7×
- Totten v. New York, Lake Erie & Western RailroadNew York Supreme Court· 1890-06-20· cited 2×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.