Baran v. Reading Iron Co.
Citations
- 202 Pa. 274
- 51 A. 979
- 1902 Pa. LEXIS 506
Syllabus
<p>Negligence — Evidence—Subsequent precautions.</p> <p>Evidence of precautions taken or repairs made after an accident is not admissible as tending in itself to prove prior negligence.</p> <p>It seems that in most of the cases in which this kind of testimony was sanctioned, the testimony introduced was not of sufficient importance tore-quire a reversal, or there was some ground for its introduction other than that it tended to show antecedent negligence.</p> <p>In an action against an iron company to recover damages for death caused by the explosion of a boiler, testimony was introduced at the trial to show that the boiler which exploded was not properly supported, and that it was imprudently allowed to cool while connected with other boilers which were in full operation. Offers were then made to prove that after the accident a boiler used to replace the one that exploded was supported in a different manner, and that an employee in charge of the boilers in the mill received instructions from the defendant company thereafter to disconnect boilers from the steam main when the fires were drawn. Held that the offers were properly rejected</p> <p>Negligence — Evidence—Burden of proof — Explosion of boiler.</p> <p>In an action to recover damages for death caused by the explosion of a boiler where it appeared that the deceased was not connected with the defendant’s works, a verdict and judgment for the defendant will be sustained, where the testimony not only failed to show negligence, but it affirmatively showed that ordinary care had been exercised, and rebutted any presumption that might be said to arise from the mere fact of the explosion.</p>
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding the doctrine applicable to bar the admission of evidence, including testimony concerning the implementation of post-accident changes in procedure
- holding the doctrine applicable to bar the admission of evidence, including testimony concerning the implementation of post-accident changes in procedure
- explaining that in some cases, an accident might prompt “a prudent and well-meaning defendant [to] guard[] against the recurrence of an accident [it] had no reason to anticipate”
- announcing adoption of the subsequent repairs doctrine in Pennsylvania
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Dean, Fell, McCollum, Mestrezat, Pottek
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
23 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Incollingo v. EWINGSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1971-01-25· cited 315×
- Ortho Pharmaceutical Corp. v. ChapmanIndiana Court of Appeals· 1979-05-02· cited 134×
- Ortho Pharmaceutical Corp. v. ChapmanIndiana Court of Appeals· 1979-03-29· cited 93×
- Blumberg v. M. & T. IncorporatedCalifornia Supreme Court· 1949-08-31· cited 87×
- Duchess v. Langston Corp.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2001-04-19· cited 49×
- Joseph Kelly and Cynthia Kelly v. Crown Equipment CompanyThird Circuit· 1992-08-25· cited 47×
- Hyndman v. Pennsylvania RailroadSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1959-05-08· cited 42×
- Matsko v. HARLEY DAVIDSON MOT. CO., INC.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1984-02-24· cited 32×
- Seeherman v. Wilkes-Barre Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1916-07-01· cited 23×
- Spinozzi v. Lavino CompanyThird Circuit· 1957-04-30· cited 13×
- Matteson v. New York Central & Hudson River RailroadSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1907-06-03· cited 10×
- Leghart v. Montour RailroadSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1959-04-20· cited 9×
- Brown v. Towanda BoroughSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1904-03-14· cited 7×
- Metzler v. Philadelphia & Reading Railway Co.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1905-07-13· cited 5×
- Spinozzi v. E. J. Lavino & Co.Third Circuit· 1957-03-21· cited 5×
- Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Co. v. Kennebec Water DistrictSupreme Judicial Court of Maine· 1943-12-03· cited 2×
- Elias v. Lancaster CitySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1902-10-13· cited 1×
- Cunningham v. Pennsylvania RailroadSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1909-07-14· cited 1×
- Buchanan v. FlinnSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1912-07-18· cited 1×
- Brecht v. City of PhiladelphiaPhiladelphia County Court of Common Pleas· 1952-06-26
Cites
14 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Sappenfield v. Main Street & Agricultural Park RailroadCalifornia Supreme Court· 1891-09-05· cited 98×
- Zahniser v. Pennsylvania Torpedo Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1899-03-20· cited 76×
- Hodges v. PercivalIllinois Supreme Court· 1890-01-21· cited 56×
- Gulf, Colorado & Santa Fe Railway Co. v. ComptonCourt of Appeals of Texas· 1890-01-28· cited 51×
- Alcorn v. Chicago & Alton RailroadSupreme Court of Missouri· 1891-10-15· cited 46×
- Howe v. MedarisIllinois Supreme Court· 1899-12-21· cited 44×
- Louisville & Nashville Railroad v. MaloneSupreme Court of Alabama· 1895-11-15· cited 37×
- Gavigan v. Atlantic Refining Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1896-07-21· cited 31×
- Pennsylvania Railroad v. HendersonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1866-05-15· cited 22×
- Whelton v. West End Street Railway Co.Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1899-03-01· cited 9×
- Railroad v. WyattTennessee Supreme Court· 1900-04-18· cited 9×
- Beard v. GuildSupreme Court of Iowa· 1899-02-01· cited 8×
- McKee v. BidwellSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1873-11-10· cited 7×
- Noble v. St. Joseph & Benton Harbor Street Railway Co.Michigan Supreme Court· 1893-12-22· cited 4×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.