Auffmordt v. Hedden
Citations
- 137 U.S. 310
- 11 S. Ct. 103
- 34 L. Ed. 674
- 1890 U.S. LEXIS 2090
Syllabus
<p>On a reappraisement by a merchant appraiser and a general appraiser, under § 2930 of the Revised .Statutes, the valuation of goods entered in March, 1886, was raised, and the importer paid thereon additional duties, for which he sued the collector, after protest and appeal. At the trial, the plaintiff put in evidence chapter 3, part 8, articles 447 to 506, and chapter 5, part 8, articles 1399 to 1410, and 1415 to 141-7, of the general regulations under the customs and navigation laws published by the .Treasury Department in 1884; and extracts from the instructions issued for-the guidance of officers of the customs and others concerned, by the Secretary of the Treasury, under date of July 1, 1885, being instructions of June 9, 1885, and June 10, 1885. The importer had asked'for the reappraisement, and the collector selected the merchant appraiser. He took the prescribed oath in regard to the goods in question. The defendant had a verdict in respect of the additional duties, under the direction of the court, and the importer had a judgment in respect of another matter: On a writ of error: Held,</p> <p>(1) The instructions of the Treasury Department gave the importer all the rights to which he was entitled, and were not repugnant to that provision of §§ 2902 and 2930 which required the use of “ all reasonable ways and means,” in appraising, and the proper rights of the importer were accorded to him in this case;</p> <p>(2) The question of the dutiable value of the merchandise was not to be tried before the appraisers as if it were an issue in a suit in a judicial tribunal;</p> <p>(3) In a suit to recover back duties paid under protest, the valuation of merchandise made by the appraisers is, in the absence of fraud, conclusive on the importer, and the question as to the actual value of the merchandise cannot be tried;</p> <p>(4) The merchant appraiser was not an officer, within the meaning of article 2, section 2 of the Constitution, so as to.require him to be appoin
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- finding that a merchant appraiser is not an \officer\ for purposes of the Appointments Clause where his position is without tenure, duration, continuing emolument, or continuous duties
- finding that a merchant appraiser is not an “officer” for purposes of the Appointments Clause where his position is without tenure, duration, continuing emolument, or continuous duties
- fnding no vesting of appointment authority in part because “[t]he statute does not use the word `appoint,' but uses the word `select' ”
- holding merchant appraiser was not an officer because he “ha[d] no general functions, nor any employment which has any duration as to time, or which extends over any case further than as he is selected to act in that particular case”
- finding no vesting of ap- pointment authority in part because “[t]he statute does not use the word ‘appoint,’ but uses the word ‘select’ ”
- person whose “position is without tenure, duration, continuing emolument, or continuous duties, [and who] acts only ... temporarily” is an agent not an officer under Appointments Clause
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Blatchford
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
81 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Buckley v. ValeoSupreme Court· 1976-02-27· cited 4,982×
- Norwegian Nitrogen Products Co. v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1933-02-06· cited 734×
- Metcalf & Eddy v. MitchellSupreme Court· 1926-01-11· cited 565×
- Ex Parte Bakelite Corp'n.Supreme Court· 1929-05-20· cited 285×
- United States of America, Ex Rel. Kevin G. Kelly v. The Boeing CompanyNinth Circuit· 1993-11-05· cited 219×
- United States of America, Ex Rel. Taxpayers Against Fraud and Chester L. Walsh v. General Electric CompanySixth Circuit· 1995-01-18· cited 130×
- United States v. Arthrex, Inc.Supreme Court· 2021-06-21· cited 129×
- United States v. WeissUnited States Court of Military Appeals· 1992-12-21· cited 120×
- Muser v. MagoneSupreme Court· 1894-12-03· cited 68×
- United States ex rel. Stone v. Rockwell International Corp.Tenth Circuit· 2002-03-04· cited 62×
- Riley v. St Luke's Epis HospFifth Circuit· 2001-05-25· cited 42×
- Riley v. St. Luke's Episcopal HospitalFifth Circuit· 1999-11-16· cited 36×
- Chambers v. United StatesCourt of Claims· 1971-10-15· cited 36×
- United States v. McCroryFifth Circuit· 1899-01-03· cited 31×
- Felder v. United StatesSecond Circuit· 1925-12-07· cited 29×
- Martin v. United StatesEighth Circuit· 1909-03-13· cited 29×
- United States Ex Rel. Stillwell v. Hughes Helicopters, Inc.C.D. California· 1989-06-01· cited 28×
- National Broadcasting Co. v. Federal Communications CommissionD.C. Circuit· 1943-01-18· cited 26×
- Wolff v. United StatesCustoms and Patent Appeals· 1911-01-11· cited 21×
- United States v. DonzigerSecond Circuit· 2022-06-22· cited 18×
Cites
12 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Cohens v. VirginiaSupreme Court· 1821-03-18· cited 2,076×
- Taylor v. SecorSupreme Court· 1876-04-17· cited 589×
- Cheatham v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1876-03-27· cited 169×
- Hall v. WisconsinSupreme Court· 1880-11-15· cited 127×
- Arnson v. MurphySupreme Court· 1883-11-19· cited 78×
- The LauraSupreme Court· 1885-04-07· cited 65×
- Wilson's v. DeenSupreme Court· 1887-04-25· cited 64×
- Greely's Administrator v. BurgessSupreme Court· 1856-04-25· cited 47×
- Arnson v. MurphySupreme Court· 1885-12-07· cited 24×
- Oelbermann v. MerrittSupreme Court· 1887-11-21· cited 20×
- Badger v. CusimanoSupreme Court· 1889-03-05· cited 15×
- Mustin v. CadwaladerSupreme Court· 1887-11-21· cited 5×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.