Supreme Court of Iowa· 5/9/2014
Asher v. Ob-Gyn Specialists, P.C.
Citations
- 846 N.W.2d 492
- 2014 WL 1884394
- 2014 Iowa Sup. LEXIS 49
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- concluding that physician’s scope of liability for birth injury was established as a matter of law and affirming judgment on jury verdict awarding damages to both parents and child
- affirming jury verdict awarding damages to parents for their baby’s brachial plexis injury and broken clavicle caused by physician’s negligence during delivery
- stating the court erred in instructing jury on causation under the “abandoned” Restatement (Second) standards rather than the scope-of-liability 5 Restatement (Third
- discussing the applicability of the Restatement (Third) of Torts in medical negligence cases
- overruled on other grounds by Alcala v. Marriott Int’l, Inc., 880 N.W.2d 699 (Iowa 2016) (“The . . . injury was established as a matter of law to be within [the defendant’s] scope of liability.”
- stating standard of review is abuse of discretion
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Appel, Mansfield, Take, Zager
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
31 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Brenda J. Alcala v. Marriott International, Inc. and Courtyard Management Corporation D/B/A Quad Cities Courtyard by MarriottSupreme Court of Iowa· 2016-06-10· cited 338×
- State of Iowa v. Kevin Deshay AmbroseSupreme Court of Iowa· 2015-01-02· cited 163×
- Terri Aleta Rivera v. Woodward Resource Center and State of IowaSupreme Court of Iowa· 2015-06-30· cited 70×
- State of Iowa v. Mario Guerrero CorderoSupreme Court of Iowa· 2015-03-20· cited 55×
- Pamela Plowman and Jeremy Plowman v. Fort Madison Community Hospital, Pil Kang, John Paiva, Davis Radiology, P.C., Leah Steffensmeier, the Women's Center, and Fort Madison Physicians and SurgeonsSupreme Court of Iowa· 2017-06-02· cited 46×
- Theresa Huck v. Wyeth, Inc. D/B/A Wyeth Schwarz Pharma, Inc. and Pliva, Inc.Supreme Court of Iowa· 2014-07-11· cited 37×
- Tamco Pork II, LLC and Farm Bureau Insurance Company, as Subrogee of Tamco Pork II, LLC v. Heartland Co-Op and Pro Build, LLCCourt of Appeals of Iowa· 2015-07-22· cited 4×
- Douglas C. Lane, Individually and as of the Estate of Robert L. Lane v. Emeritus Corporation D/B/A Silver PinesCourt of Appeals of Iowa· 2014-07-30
- Sandra L. Benson and William D. Benson v. 13 Associates, L.L.C.Court of Appeals of Iowa· 2015-02-11
- Dorothea Polk v. Department of Administrative Services and Iowa Workforce DevelopmentCourt of Appeals of Iowa· 2015-04-22
- Donna Canavan v. Joe W. Conlan, Michael Sauser, and Cs & R, LLC D/B/A Cornerstone HomesCourt of Appeals of Iowa· 2015-07-09
- Unnamed caseCourt of Appeals of Iowa· 2015-09-23
- Keith Provin v. Nicholas John TomlonovicCourt of Appeals of Iowa· 2016-01-13
- Debra Jo Robeson v. Vieth Construction CorporationCourt of Appeals of Iowa· 2016-04-06
- State of Iowa v. Nathaniel Quentin KnightCourt of Appeals of Iowa· 2016-06-15
- Nicole Brooks, and Brendan Brooks, Addison Brooks, and Aiden Brooks, by Their Mother and Next Friend, Nicole Brooks v. State of IowaCourt of Appeals of Iowa· 2017-06-07
- John Deppe and Deppe JJ, LLC F/K/A Doerscher-Deppe, LLC v. Douglas H. Deppe and Kim Doerscher-DeppeCourt of Appeals of Iowa· 2017-07-06
- Amended August 8, 2017 Pamela Plowman and Jeremy Plowman v. Fort Madison Community Hospital, Pil Kang, John Paiva, Davis Radiology, P.C., Leah Steffensmeier, the Women's Center, and Fort Madison Physicians and SurgeonsSupreme Court of Iowa· 2017-06-02
- Amended September 10, 2015 Terri Aleta Rivera v. Woodward Resource Center and State of IowaSupreme Court of Iowa· 2015-06-30
- Amended June 1, 2015 State of Iowa v. Mario Guerrero CorderoSupreme Court of Iowa· 2015-03-20
Cites
28 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Thompson v. KaczinskiSupreme Court of Iowa· 2009-11-13· cited 198×
- State Of Iowa Vs. Robert L. HanesSupreme Court of Iowa· 2010-11-12· cited 192×
- Top of Iowa Cooperative v. Sime Farms, Inc.Supreme Court of Iowa· 2000-03-22· cited 130×
- Iowa State Highway Commission v. SmithSupreme Court of Iowa· 1957-05-07· cited 86×
- Summy v. City of Des MoinesSupreme Court of Iowa· 2006-01-13· cited 81×
- John Pavone and Signature Management Group, L.L.C. v. Gerald M. Kirke and Wild Rose Entertainment, L.L.C.Supreme Court of Iowa· 2011-07-01· cited 77×
- Matsuyama v. BirnbaumMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 2008-07-23· cited 76×
- Soreide v. Vilas & CompanySupreme Court of Iowa· 1956-07-26· cited 71×
- Hoekstra v. Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co.Supreme Court of Iowa· 1986-02-19· cited 64×
- Cedar Falls v. CEDAR FALLS SCHOOL DIST.Supreme Court of Iowa· 2000-09-07· cited 62×
- Gerst v. MarshallSupreme Court of Iowa· 1996-06-19· cited 61×
- State v. GanszSupreme Court of Iowa· 1985-11-13· cited 53×
- Anderson v. Webster City Community School DistrictSupreme Court of Iowa· 2000-12-20· cited 42×
- State Of Iowa Vs. Stanley Alan TribbleSupreme Court of Iowa· 2010-10-29· cited 41×
- Nichols v. Westfield Industries, Ltd.Supreme Court of Iowa· 1985-11-13· cited 39×
- Herbst v. StateSupreme Court of Iowa· 2000-09-07· cited 38×
- Hansen v. Central Iowa Hospital Corp.Supreme Court of Iowa· 2004-09-01· cited 35×
- Doe v. CENTRAL IOWA HEALTH SYSTEMSupreme Court of Iowa· 2009-05-15· cited 35×
- Stickleman v. SynhorstSupreme Court of Iowa· 1952-04-01· cited 35×
- Dennis H. Hagenow and Rosalee A. Hagenow v. Betty L. SchmidtSupreme Court of Iowa· 2014-02-07· cited 32×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.