Appriva Shareholder Litigation Co. v. Ev3, Inc.

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• holding that challenge to plaintiff’s standing must be brought under Rule 12(b)(1), not Rule 12(b)(6)
• recognizing that for purposes of a Rule 12(b)(1) motion, the Court may consider matters outside of the complaint
• holding that a trial court that has converted a motion to dismiss to one for summary judgment must give the parties at least ten days’ notice
• recognizing that when deciding a Rule 12(b)(1) motion, the Court need not accept a plaintiff’s factual allegations as true and is free to consider facts not alleged in the complaint
• finding that is was reversible error for the Court to fail to provide notice to parties before converting 12(b)(6) motion to one for summary judgment
• noting that state and federal courts are divided as to whether the issue of standing is properly challenged under Rule 12(b)(1) or 12(b)(6)

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).

Cited by

160 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

• Norton v. K-Sea Transportation Partners L.P.
  Supreme Court of Delaware· 2013-05-28· cited 124×
• At&T CORP. v. Lillis
  Supreme Court of Delaware· 2008-05-22· cited 80×
• ConAgra Foods, Inc. v. Lexington Insurance
  Supreme Court of Delaware· 2011-04-28· cited 43×
• Maloney-Refaie v. Bridge at School, Inc.
  Court of Chancery of Delaware· 2008-07-09· cited 37×
• Scott Pontone v. Milso Industries Corporation
  Court of Chancery of Delaware· 2014-08-22· cited 35×
• RBC Capital Markets, LLC v. Education Loan Trust IV
  Supreme Court of Delaware· 2014-03-05· cited 35×
• Furman v. Delaware Department of Transportation
  Supreme Court of Delaware· 2011-10-19· cited 34×
• Seneca Investments LLC v. Tierney
  Court of Chancery of Delaware· 2008-09-23· cited 34×
• Aveta Inc. v. Cavallieri
  Court of Chancery of Delaware· 2010-09-20· cited 29×
• Robino-Bay Court Plaza, LLC v. West Willow-Bay Court, LLC.
  Supreme Court of Delaware· 2007-12-21· cited 22×
• Matulich v. Aegis Communications Group, Inc.
  Supreme Court of Delaware· 2008-01-15· cited 22×
• Ramirez v. Murdick
  Supreme Court of Delaware· 2008-04-29· cited 20×
• Martinez v. E.I. Dupont de Nemours & Co.
  Superior Court of Delaware· 2012-12-05· cited 19×
• In re Activision Blizzard, Inc.
  Court of Chancery of Delaware· 2014-02-21· cited 13×
• Delaware State Sportsmen's Association v. Garvin
  Superior Court of Delaware· 2018-10-11· cited 9×
• Fenster v. Dechabert
  Superior Court of The Virgin Islands· 2016-08-08· cited 3×
• Menezes v. WL Ross & Co.
  Supreme Court of South Carolina· 2013-05-22· cited 2×
• Rodney Stanley v. Virgin Islands Bureau of Corrections
  Superior Court of The Virgin Islands· 2020-04-01· cited 1×
• Family Court of the State of Delaware v. Tucker
  Superior Court of Delaware· 2014-09-25
• Prokupek v. Consumer Capital Partners LLC
  Court of Chancery of Delaware· 2014-12-30

Cites

25 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

• Kehr Packages, Inc. v. Fidelcor, Inc.
  Third Circuit· 1991-03-06· cited 1,043×
• Rose v. Bartle
  Third Circuit· 1989-03-20· cited 728×
• VLIW TECHNOLOGY, LLC v. Hewlett-Packard Co.
  Supreme Court of Delaware· 2003-12-19· cited 527×
• Richard Augustine v. United States
  Ninth Circuit· 1983-04-26· cited 471×
• Norma J. Nesbit v. Gears Unlimited, Inc
  Third Circuit· 2003-10-21· cited 250×
• Vanderbilt Income & Growth Associates, L.L.C. v. Arvida/JMB Managers, Inc.
  Supreme Court of Delaware· 1996-12-12· cited 180×
• Debora D. Gordon v. National Youth Work Alliance
  D.C. Circuit· 1982-04-02· cited 145×
• Trustmark Insurance Company v. ESLU, Inc.
  Eleventh Circuit· 2002-08-02· cited 127×
• Young v. City of Ketchum
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2002-03-26· cited 83×
• Stuart Kingston, Inc. v. Robinson
  Supreme Court of Delaware· 1991-08-12· cited 82×
• Raymond Sekula and L. Kathleen Sekula v. Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation Resolution Trust Corporation, Raymond F. Sekula and L. Kathleen Sekula
  Third Circuit· 1994-11-09· cited 70×
• Doe v. the Governor
  Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1980-10-30· cited 63×
• Klair v. Reese
  Supreme Court of Delaware· 1987-09-16· cited 53×
• Mann v. Oppenheimer & Co.
  Supreme Court of Delaware· 1986-10-30· cited 47×
• Tasini v. New York Times Co., Inc.
  S.D. New York· 2002-01-25· cited 41×
• Clevenger v. FIRST OPTION HEALTH PLAN OF NEW JER.
  D. New Jersey· 2002-03-22· cited 34×
• Taylor v. Maile
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2005-12-23· cited 32×
• Schulz v. State
  Indiana Court of Appeals· 2000-07-14· cited 30×
• Jones v. Regency Toyota, Inc.
  Mississippi Supreme Court· 2001-05-10· cited 29×
• Hoffman v. Cohen
  Supreme Court of Delaware· 1988-03-04· cited 24×