Apache Corp. v. MDU Resources Group, Inc.

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• requiring that the benefit be obtained “at the direct expense of the [complainant]”
• requiring that the benefit be obtained “at the direct expense of the [complainant]”
• requiring that the benefit be obtained “at the direct expense of the [complainant]”
• “we conclude the trial court did not err in concluding Apache was not a third-party beneficiary”

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).

Cited by

28 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

• Ritter, Laber & Associates, Inc. v. Koch Oil, Inc.
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 2004-06-03· cited 51×
• BTA Oil Producers v. MDU Resources Group, Inc.
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 2002-04-16· cited 48×
• In Re TFT-LCD (Flat Panel) Antitrust Litigation
  N.D. California· 2009-03-03· cited 41×
• McColl Farms, LLC v. Pflaum
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 2013-09-25· cited 38×
• Lochthowe v. C.F. Peterson Estate
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 2005-02-16· cited 29×
• In re Automotive Parts Antitrust Litigation
  E.D. Michigan· 2014-07-03· cited 24×
• Spagnolia v. Monasky
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 2003-04-22· cited 22×
• Rapp v. Green Tree Servicing, LLC
  D. Minnesota· 2014-08-05· cited 20×
• Peoples State Bank of Truman, Inc. v. Molstad Excavating, Inc.
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 2006-08-24· cited 18×
• Qwest Communications Corp. v. Free Conferencing Corp.
  Eighth Circuit· 2016-09-15· cited 18×
• Northstar Founders, LLC v. Hayden Capital USA, LLC
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 2014-10-31· cited 17×
• Schroeder v. Buchholz
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 2001-02-15· cited 16×
• Davidson v. State Ex Rel. North Dakota State Board of Higher Education
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 2010-04-08· cited 16×
• Syversen v. Hess
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 2003-07-16· cited 12×
• In re Lidoderm Antitrust Litigation
  N.D. California· 2015-05-05· cited 12×
• In re Automotive Parts Antitrust Litigation
  E.D. Michigan· 2014-09-25· cited 9×
• Knorr v. Norberg
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 2015-12-07· cited 8×
• Aggrow Oils, L.L.C. v. National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, Pa Anderson International Corporation
  Eighth Circuit· 2005-08-23· cited 7×
• GEM Razorback, LLC v. Zenergy, Inc.
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 2017-02-21· cited 5×
• Continental Resources v. Armstrong
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 2021-09-30· cited 4×

Cites

11 cases in this archive are cited by this case.

• Drinkall v. Movius State Bank
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 1901-10-26· cited 48×
• Zuger v. North Dakota Insurance Guaranty Ass'n
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 1992-12-22· cited 40×
• Hellman v. Thiele
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 1987-09-29· cited 39×
• Midland Diesel Service & Engine Co. v. Sivertson
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 1981-06-25· cited 38×
• State v. Evans
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 1999-04-27· cited 35×
• Schlichenmayer v. Luithle
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 1974-06-27· cited 30×
• Johnson v. Estate of Zent
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 1990-07-31· cited 27×
• Albrecht v. Walter
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 1997-12-10· cited 21×
• Opp v. Matzke
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 1997-02-27· cited 19×
• First Federal Savings & Loan Ass'n of Bismarck v. Compass Investments, Inc.
  North Dakota Supreme Court· 1983-12-22· cited 11×
• Unnamed case
  Eighth Circuit· 1993-03-15· cited 1×