Skip to main content

Alexander's Estate

Citations

  • 206 Pa. 47
  • 55 A. 797
  • 1903 Pa. LEXIS 644

Syllabus

<p>Will — Probate—Issue devisavit vel non — Undue influence.</p> <p>Iu a will contest where the only question was undue influence, it appeared that the testator, who was ninety years old, but whose faculties were unimpaired, divided his estate equally between three sons and a daughter, charging against two of the sons who were the contestants, an indebtedness alleged by the contestants to be in great part due from one of them only. The third son who was a half-brother to the other children was in the habit of attending, under the testator’s direction, to many of the testator’s business affairs and had the custody of his books and papers other than the will. This son aided his father in stating an account against the contestants, and in the books the greater part of the debt was charged against one of the contestants only. A lettey of the testator with which the third son had nothing to do, indicated that testator entertained the idea that there were circumstances which made it proper to charge the debt against both of the contestants, and letters from the contestant not charged in the books, showed a recognition of the fact not only that the testator had entertained the idea of charging him in the will, but also that this idea was not irrational nor without some substantial basis. Testator’s will was drawn by the testator’s regular attorney, was executed before impartial witnesses in the absence of the third son, and remained in the possession of the attorney. Held that the evidence was insufficient to justify the granting of an issue to determine whether undue influence had been exercised upon the testator.</p> <p>Where it is sought to set aside a will on the ground of mistake of a material fact by the testator, the test is not whether the fact was or might be established to the satisfaction of another person, but whether it was a clear mistake on the part of the testator which misled him, or was a conclusion of his own judgment though different from that which a c

Judges: Brown, Dean, Mestrezat, Mitchell, Pee, Potter

Read full opinion on CourtListener

Cited by

5 cases in this archive cite this case.

Other cases with this name

Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).

This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.