Notice2024-11168
Self-Regulatory Organizations; Nasdaq PHLX LLC; Suspension of and Order Instituting Proceedings To Determine Whether To Approve or Disapprove Proposed Rule Change To Amend the Exchange's Fees for Top of PHLX Options (TOPO), PHLX Orders, and TOPO Plus Orders
Primary source
Metadata and text below are from the Federal Register, a public-domain U.S. government work. Always verify the official published version before relying on it for any legal matter.
Published
May 22, 2024
Issuing agencies
Securities and Exchange Commission
Full Text
<html>
<head>
<title>Federal Register, Volume 89 Issue 100 (Wednesday, May 22, 2024)</title>
</head>
<body><pre>
[Federal Register Volume 89, Number 100 (Wednesday, May 22, 2024)]
[Notices]
[Pages 45036-45044]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [<a href="http://www.gpo.gov">www.gpo.gov</a>]
[FR Doc No: 2024-11168]
=======================================================================
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
[Release No. 34-100160; File No. SR-Phlx-2024-15]
Self-Regulatory Organizations; Nasdaq PHLX LLC; Suspension of and
Order Instituting Proceedings To Determine Whether To Approve or
Disapprove Proposed Rule Change To Amend the Exchange's Fees for Top of
PHLX Options (TOPO), PHLX Orders, and TOPO Plus Orders
May 16, 2024.
I. Introduction
On March 20, 2024, Nasdaq PHLX LLC (``Phlx'' or ``Exchange'') filed
with the Securities and Exchange Commission (``Commission'' or
``SEC''), pursuant to Section 19(b)(1) of the Securities Exchange Act
of 1934 (``Act''),\1\ and Rule 19b-4 thereunder,\2\ a proposed rule
change (File Number SR-Phlx-2024-15) to increase fees for certain
market data products (``Proposal''). The proposed rule change was
immediately effective upon filing with the Commission pursuant to
Section 19(b)(3)(A) of the Act.\3\ The proposed rule change was
published for comment in the Federal Register on March 28, 2024.\4\
Pursuant to Section 19(b)(3)(C) of the Act,\5\ the Commission is
hereby: (1) temporarily suspending the proposed rule change; and (2)
instituting proceedings to determine whether to approve or disapprove
the proposed rule change.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ 15 U.S.C. 78s(b)(1).
\2\ 17 CFR 240.19b-4.
\3\ 15 U.S.C. 78s(b)(3)(A). A proposed rule change may take
effect upon filing with the Commission if it is designated by the
exchange as ``establishing or changing a due, fee, or other charge
imposed by the self-regulatory organization on any person, whether
or not the person is a member of the self-regulatory organization.''
15 U.S.C. 78s(b)(3)(A)(ii).
\4\ See Securities Exchange Act Release No. 99841 (March 22,
2024), 89 FR 21648 (``Notice''). The Commission has received one
comment letter on the proposed rule change. See Letter from Brookes
Ross, received April 29, 2024 (``Ross Letter''). Comments received
on the Proposal are available at: <a href="https://www.sec.gov/comments/sr-phlx-2024-15/srphlx202415.htm">https://www.sec.gov/comments/sr-phlx-2024-15/srphlx202415.htm</a>.
\5\ 15 U.S.C. 78s(b)(3)(C).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
II. Background and Description of the Proposed Rule Change
The Exchange states that the purpose of the proposed rule change is
to amend the Exchange's proprietary data fees for Top of PHLX Options
(``TOPO''),\6\ PHLX
[[Page 45037]]
Orders,\7\ and TOPO Plus Orders at Options 7, Section 10.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21648 (citing Options 3, Section
23(a)(1) (``Top of PHLX Options (`TOPO') is a direct data feed
product that includes the Exchange's best bid and offer price, with
aggregate size, based on displayable order and quoting interest on
Phlx and last sale information for trades executed on Phlx. The data
contained in the TOPO data feed is identical to the data
simultaneously sent to the processor for the OPRA and subscribers of
the data feed. The data provided for each options series includes
the symbols (series and underlying security), put or call indicator,
expiration date, the strike price of the series, and whether the
option series is available for trading on Phlx and identifies if the
series is available for closing transactions only.'')).
\7\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21648 (citing Options 3, Section
23(a)(1) (``PHLX Orders is a real-time full Limit Order book data
feed that provides pricing information for orders on the PHLX Order
book for displayed order types as well as market participant
capacity. PHLX Orders is currently provided as part of the TOPO Plus
Orders data product. PHLX Orders provides real-time information to
enable users to keep track of the single and complex order book(s).
The data provided for each options series includes the symbols
(series and underlying security), put or call indicator, expiration
date, the strike price of the series, leg information on complex
strategies and whether the option series is available for trading on
Phlx and identifies if the series is available for closing
transactions only. The feed also provides auction and exposure
notifications and order imbalances on opening/reopening (size of
matched contracts and size of the imbalance)'')).
\8\ The proposed changes were initially filed on November 16,
2023, as SR-Phlx-2023-51. On December 5, 2023, SR-Phlx-2023-51 was
withdrawn and replaced with SR-Phlx-2023-57. On January 29, 2024,
SR-Phlx-2023-57 was withdrawn and replaced with SR-Phlx 2024-03. On
March 20, 2024, SR-Phlx-2024-03 was withdrawn and replaced with the
instant filing to provide additional detail regarding the proposal.
See Notice, 89 FR at 21648.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that TOPO is a direct data feed that provides
subscribers with PHLX Best Bid and Offer (``BBO'') \9\ and last sale
information.\10\ The Exchange also states that the data distributed on
TOPO is identical to the data simultaneously sent to the Options Price
Reporting Authority (``OPRA'').\11\ The Exchange states that TOPO feed
also provides administrative information to facilitate trading on the
Exchange such as, for example, the list of symbols trading on a
particular day.\12\ The Exchange states that TOPO reduces the
transmission and processing latencies for top of book information
relative to the OPRA feed by avoiding the latencies generated by the
latter in consolidating data.\13\ The Exchange states that monthly fees
for TOPO are currently $2,000 for Internal Distributors,\14\ $2,500 for
External Distributors,\15\ $1 for a Non-Professional Subscriber,\16\
and $40 for a Professional Subscriber.\17\ The Exchange further states
that none of these fees have changed for over a decade since January
2013.\18\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21648. The Exchange states that Best
Bid and Offer includes aggregate size information based on
displayable order and quoting interest on the Exchange. Id. at n.6.
\10\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21648 (citing PHLX, ``Top of Phlx
Options,'' available at https://www.nasdaqtrader.com/
Micro.aspx?id=TOPO#:~:text=Top%20of%20PHLX%20Options%20(TOPO,in%20the
%20consolidated%20market%20feed).
\11\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21648 (citing Options 3 (Options
Trading Rules), Section 23(a)(1) (Data Feeds and Trade Information)
(``The data contained in the TOPO data feed is identical to the data
simultaneously sent to the processor for the OPRA and subscribers of
the data feed.'')).
\12\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21648 (citing Nasdaq, ``Top of Phlx
Options Interface Specifications, Version 3.4'' Section 4.3
available at <a href="https://www.nasdaqtrader.com/content/technicalsupport/specifications/dataproducts/topofphlx.pdf">https://www.nasdaqtrader.com/content/technicalsupport/specifications/dataproducts/topofphlx.pdf</a> (describing the start of
day options directory message, which lists all symbols eligible for
the auction process)).
\13\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21648.
\14\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21648 (citing Options 7, Section 10
(Proprietary Data Feed Fees) (Top of PHLX Options) (``A
`distributor' of Nasdaq PHLX data is any entity that receives a feed
or data file . . . directly from Nasdaq PHLX or indirectly through
another entity and then distributes it either internally (within
that entity) or externally (outside that entity). All distributors
execute a Nasdaq PHLX distributor agreement.'')).
\15\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21648 (citing Options 7, Section 10
(Proprietary Data Feed Fees) (Top of PHLX Options)).
\16\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21648 (citing Options 7, Section 10
(Proprietary Data Feed Fees) (Top of PHLX Options) (``A Non-
Professional Subscriber is a natural person who is neither: (i)
registered or qualified in any capacity with the Commission, the
Commodities Futures Trading Commission, any state securities agency,
any securities exchange or association, or any commodities or
futures contract market or association; (ii) engaged as an
`investment adviser' as that term is defined in Section 201(11) of
the Investment Advisors Act of 1940 (whether or not registered or
qualified under that Act); nor (iii) employed by a bank or other
organization exempt from registration under federal or state
securities laws to perform functions that would require registration
or qualification if such functions were performed for an
organization not so exempt. A Non-Professional Subscriber may only
use the data provided for personal purposes and not for any
commercial purpose.'')).
\17\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21648 (citing Options 7, Section 10
(Proprietary Data Feed Fees) (Top of PHLX Options) (``A Professional
Subscriber is any Subscriber that is not a Non-Professional
Subscriber. If the Nasdaq Subscriber agreement is signed in the name
of a business or commercial entity, such entity would be considered
a Professional Subscriber.'')).
\18\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649 (citing Securities Exchange Act
Release No. 68576 (January 3, 2013), 78 FR 1886 (January 9, 2013)
(SR-Phlx-2012-145)).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that PHLX Orders is a real-time order book feed
with pricing information for displayed orders on the PHLX order
book.\19\ The Exchange states that the data provided for each options
series includes the symbols (series and underlying security), a put or
call indicator, expiration date, and the strike price of the
series.\20\ The Exchange states that it also provides the real-time
status of simple and complex orders \21\ on the order book, including
new orders and changes to orders resting on the PHLX book for all PHLX-
listed options.\22\ The Exchange states that PHLX Orders feed includes
data on the opening imbalance, Price Improvement XL (PIXL),\23\ and
Complex Order Live Auction (COLA).\24\ The Exchange further states that
a notification message is sent for symbols entering an auction.\25\ The
Exchange states that PHLX Orders also furnishes an historical record of
all simple and complex order message data from the PHLX Orders data
feed and that PHLX Orders information is not sent to OPRA.\26\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649 (citing Options 3 (Options
Trading Rules), Section 23(a)(2) (Data Feeds and Trade
Information)).
\20\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649.
\21\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649 (citing Options 3 (Options
Trading Rules), Section 23(a)(2) (Data Feeds and Trade Information);
Section 14(a)(i) (``Complex Order. For purposes of the electronic
trading of Complex Orders, a Complex Order is an order involving the
simultaneous purchase and/or sale of two or more different options
series in the same underlying security, priced as a net debit or
credit based on the relative prices of the individual components,
for the same account, for the purpose of executing a particular
investment strategy.'')).
\22\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649 (citing Nasdaq, ``PHLX Orders,''
available at <a href="https://www.nasdaqtrader.com/Micro.aspx?id=PHLXOrders">https://www.nasdaqtrader.com/Micro.aspx?id=PHLXOrders</a>).
\23\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649 (citing Options 3 (Options
Trading Rules), Section 23(a)(2); Section 13 (Price Improvement XL)
(``A member may electronically submit for execution an order it
represents as agent on behalf of a Public Customer, broker-dealer,
or any other entity (`PIXL Order') against principal interest or
against any other order (except as provided in sub-paragraph (a)(6)
below) it represents as agent (an `Initiating Order') provided it
submits the PIXL Order for electronic execution into the PIXL
Auction (`Auction') pursuant to this Rule.'')).
\24\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649 (citing Options 3, Section 14(e)
which describes the process for the Complex Order Live Auction
(``COLA'')).
\25\ Notice, 89 FR at 21649 (citing Nasdaq, ``PHLX Orders
Interface Specification,'' (Version 1.92) available at <a href="https://www.nasdaqtrader.com/content/technicalsupport/specifications/dataproducts/topoplusorders.pdf">https://www.nasdaqtrader.com/content/technicalsupport/specifications/dataproducts/topoplusorders.pdf</a> (describing auction notification
message)).
\26\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649 (citing Limited Liability
Company Agreement of Options Price Reporting Authority, LLC Article
V, Section 5.2(c)(i) (January 1, 2010), available at <a href="https://assets.website-files.com/5ba40927ac854d8c97bc92d7/5d0bd57d87d3ccca102102d7_OPRA%20Plan%20with%20Updated%20Exhibit%20A%20-%2006-19-2019.pdf">https://assets.website-files.com/5ba40927ac854d8c97bc92d7/5d0bd57d87d3ccca102102d7_OPRA%20Plan%20with%20Updated%20Exhibit%20A%20-%2006-19-2019.pdf</a>
(describing last sale and best bid and offer information
disseminated by OPRA)).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that PHLX Orders is an alternative to PHLX
Depth of Market and is an optimized technical channel designed to lower
technology costs, reduce processing time, and facilitate the ingestion
of data while still providing customers insight beyond the top of book
by viewing active buy and sell orders.\27\ The Exchange further states
that PHLX Orders excludes quotations by market makers and other
authorized entities that is included in PHLX Depth of Market.\28\
Regarding the
[[Page 45038]]
utility of an orders-only data feed, the Exchange states that it
provides customers with the opportunity to reduce bandwidth (and
therefore data processing costs) by several orders of magnitude
relative to the full depth of book feed, while retaining a view of
market participant orders (setting aside symbols where participants
have not placed orders).\29\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\27\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649.
\28\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649 (citing Options 3 (Options
Trading Rules), Section 23(a)(3) (Data Feeds and Trade Information)
(``PHLX Depth of Market is a data product that provides: (i) order
and quotation information for individual quotes and orders on the
order book . . .'') (emphasis added); Section 4(b) (Entry and
display of Quotes) (identifying the market participants authorized
to submit quotes to the Exchange)).
\29\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that the December 2023 bandwidth report shows
that the PHLX Depth of Market feed transmitted a maximum of 14.3
billion messages per day during the month of December, while the PHLX
Orders feed transmitted a maximum of 53.6 million messages over the
same period (41.5 million messages for simple orders, and 12.1 million
messages for complex orders).\30\ The Exchange states that it's full
depth of book feed requires the customer to process over 200 times more
messages than the orders feed over the course of a day; replacing a
depth of book feed with an orders feed allows a customer to reduce the
maximum number of daily messages it receives by 99.6%.\31\ The Exchange
states that, to cite another example, the 1 millisecond bandwidth peak
for PHLX Depth of Market was 13.96 million messages; the comparable
number of messages for orders was 1.45 million (891 thousand for simple
and 561 thousand for complex orders).\32\ The Exchange states that
replacing depth of book with orders can therefore reduce the number of
messages processed at peak at the 1 millisecond bandwidth by nearly
90%.\33\ The Exchange further states that approximately 56% of
customers who take any data feed at all from the PHLX exchange take an
orders feed (either Orders only or TOPO Plus Orders) without depth of
book, another 38% of customers take both orders and depth feeds, and
the remaining 6% take either top of book or depth of book alone.\34\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649 (citing Nasdaq, ``December 2023
Bandwidth Report,'' available at <a href="https://view.officeapps.live.com/op/view.aspx?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nasdaqtrader.com%2Fcontent%2Ftechnicalsupport%2Fspecifications%2Fdataproducts%2Fbandwidthreport.xls&wdOrigin=BROWSELINK">https://view.officeapps.live.com/op/view.aspx?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nasdaqtrader.com%2Fcontent%2Ftechnicalsupport%2Fspecifications%2Fdataproducts%2Fbandwidthreport.xls&wdOrigin=BROWSELINK</a>).
\31\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649.
\32\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649.
\33\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649.
\34\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that in general, firms that only need
information on actively trading options takes an order feed in lieu of
depth.\35\ The Exchange explains that there are a great number of use
cases that fit this broad description, but, for purposes of
illustration, the Exchange is aware of at least two such types of
customers.\36\ The Exchange states that the first is the market
participant that does not engage in order routing--and that these are
broker dealers that use third parties to route orders, either because
the originating broker-dealer is not a member of the exchange or to
save costs.\37\ The Exchanges states that without the need for
additional information to inform routing decisions, such customers
often focus on active trading alone, and therefore purchase the orders
feed.\38\ The Exchange states that a second category of customers are
those that use options data to analyze trends in other markets.\39\ The
Exchange explains that one example of this type of customer is the
equity trader that analyzes equity-based options to gauge market
sentiment in the underlying equity.\40\ The Exchange states that for
such customers, there is relatively little utility in the full depth
feed, given that market sentiment is best gauged using options that are
being actively traded, rather than those that are dormant.\41\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\35\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649.
\36\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649.
\37\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649.
\38\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649.
\39\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649.
\40\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649.
\41\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that there are some customers that purchase
both orders and depth and that vendors are one example of this type of
customer, purchasing market data solely for resale, not for trading on
behalf of themselves or others.\42\ The Exchange explains that another
example is the firm that uses orders for analysis and depth for order
routing.\43\ The Exchange states that the orders feed can be useful for
assessing sentiment in equity markets, while depth is often used in
order routing decisions.\44\ The Exchange states that firms that engage
in both functions can lower overall processing requirements by using
orders for analytics and depth for routing.\45\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\42\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649.
\43\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649.
\44\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649.
\45\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21649.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that purchase of PHLX Orders is optional and
that customers can obtain all of the data contained in PHLX Orders from
PHLX Depth of Market feed, and may purchase the latter if they do not
realize the cost savings offered by PHLX Orders.\46\ The Exchange
states that PHLX Orders is a derivative product designed as a lower-
cost alternative to a depth of book feed.\47\ The Exchange further
states that it is not a complement to any other product offered by the
Exchange or any of its competitors.\48\ The Exchange explains that
customers are free to purchase PHLX Orders or not, and can reject the
feed for any reason, including the fee charged.\49\ The Exchange states
that the current monthly fees for PHLX Orders are $3,000 for Internal
Distributors, $3,500 for External Distributors, $1 for a Non-
Professional Subscriber, and $40 for a Professional Subscriber.\50\ The
Exchange further states that none of these fees have changes for over a
decade since January 2013.\51\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\46\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\47\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\48\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\49\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\50\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\51\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650 (citing Securities Exchange Act
Release No. 68576 (January 3, 2013), 78 FR 1886 (January 9, 2013)
(SR-Phlx-2012-145)).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that TOPO Plus is a direct market data product
that offers subscribers both TOPO and PHLX Orders for a consolidated
fee that is less than the combined fee of the two products.\52\ The
Exchange states that the monthly fees for TOPO Plus Orders are
currently $4,500 for Internal Distributors, $5,000 for External
Distributors, $1 for a Non-Professional Subscriber, and $40 for a
Professional Subscriber.\53\ The Exchange states that Internal
Distributor fees for TOPO Plus Orders were modified in January 2018,
over five years ago,\54\ but the other TOPO Plus Orders fees have not
changed since January 2013.\55\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\52\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650 (citing PHLX, TOPO Plus PHLX
Orders, available at <a href="https://www.nasdaqtrader.com/Micro.aspx?id=TOPOPlusOrders">https://www.nasdaqtrader.com/Micro.aspx?id=TOPOPlusOrders</a>).
\53\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\54\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650 (citing Securities Exchange Act
Release No. 82495 (January 12, 2018), 83 FR 2839 (January 19, 2018)
(SR-Phlx-2018-08)).
\55\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650 (citing Securities Exchange Act
Release No. 68576 (January 3, 2013), 78 FR 1886 (January 9, 2013)
(SR-Phlx-2012-145)).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that different types of market participants
purchase TOPO, PHLX Orders and TOPO Plus Orders, including market
makers, vendors, banks, proprietary traders, agency brokers (brokers
that route trades on behalf of other market participants), hedge funds,
index providers and other firms.\56\ The Exchange states that in
characterizing market participants, it must be clear that firms use
data feeds for multiple tasks.\57\ The Exchange states that a market
maker, for example, may use market data for order routing,
[[Page 45039]]
or for risk analysis used in quoting in their assigned option
series.\58\ The Exchange states that banks may use market data for
prime brokerage services, proprietary trading, or risk management.\59\
The Exchange states that market data vendors do not directly use the
data at all, but rather disseminate data to market participants that
use the data for a multiplicity of purposes.\60\ The Exchange states
that other firms purchase options data to assess the value of equity
securities.\61\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\56\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\57\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\58\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\59\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\60\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\61\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650. The Exchange states that it
does not include ``High Frequency Trading Firm'' as a distinct
category because many market participant may engage in low latency
trading strategies to some degree, but the Exchange does not have
sufficient information to be able to characterize any particular
firm as a high frequency trader. Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange explains that, characterizing firms based on what the
Exchange understands to be their primary market activity, and
understanding that firms play multiple roles, the Exchange estimates
that approximately half of the customers that take top of book data in
any form, in combination with other products or alone, are market
makers, and the remaining half are market data vendors, banks,
proprietary traders, agency brokers, hedge funds, index providers, and
others.\62\ The Exchange explains that roughly the same distribution
applies to customers that purchase PHLX Orders, whether alone or in
combination with other products.\63\ The Exchange states that although
the distributions are roughly similar, different customers are
purchasing different products in different combinations.\64\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\62\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\63\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\64\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that firms generally purchase PHLX Orders
rather than depth of book data to lower technology costs and reduce
processing time, while still providing customers insight into open
executable orders that could impact the BBO.\65\ The Exchange states
that a more specific explanation of how TOPO, PHLX Orders and TOPO Plus
Orders is used will vary based on use case, with many firms employing
multiple use cases.\66\ The Exchange states that market makers, banks,
hedge funds, and proprietary traders often use top of book and orders
feeds for trading, order routing and analysis.\67\ The Exchange states
that banks may use market data for prime brokerage services,
proprietary trading, or risk management.\68\ The Exchange states that
clients of market data vendors will utilize the data for many different
purposes.\69\ The Exchange explains that it does not have sufficient
visibility into customers' businesses and proprietary processes to be
able to determine precise data usage by customer category.\70\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\65\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\66\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\67\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\68\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\69\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\70\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that: for TOPO, it proposes to increase the
monthly charge for Internal Distributors from $2,000 to $2,500, and the
monthly charge for External Distributors from $2,500 to $3,000; For
PHLX Orders, it proposes to increase the monthly charge for Internal
Distributors from $3,000 to $3,500, and the monthly charge for External
Distributors from $3,500 to $4,000; and for TOPO Plus Orders, it
proposes to increase the monthly charge for Internal Distributors from
$4,500 to $5,500, and the monthly charge for External Distributors from
$5,000 to $6,000.\71\ The Exchange states that no changes are proposed
for Non-Professional and Professional Subscriber fees for TOPO, Phlx
Orders, or TOPO Plus.\72\ The Exchange further states that the proposed
changes are designed to update data fees to reflect their current
value, rather than their value when these fees were set 5 or 10 years
ago.\73\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\71\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\72\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\73\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
III. Suspension of the Proposed Rule Change
Pursuant to Section 19(b)(3)(C) of the Act,\74\ at any time within
60 days of the date of filing of an immediately effective proposed rule
change pursuant to Section 19(b)(1) of the Act,\75\ the Commission
summarily may temporarily suspend the change in the rules of a self-
regulatory organization (``SRO'') if it appears to the Commission that
such action is necessary or appropriate in the public interest, for the
protection of investors, or otherwise in furtherance of the purposes of
the Act. A temporary suspension of the proposed rule changes is
necessary and appropriate to allow for additional analysis of the
proposed rule change's consistency with the Act and the rules
thereunder.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\74\ 15 U.S.C. 78s(b)(3)(C).
\75\ 15 U.S.C. 78s(b)(1).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A. Exchange Statements in Support of the Proposal
In support of the Proposal, the Exchange states that it believes
that its proposal is consistent with Section 6(b) of the Act,\76\ in
general, and furthers the objectives of Sections 6(b)(4) and 6(b)(5) of
the Act,\77\ in particular, in that it provides for the equitable
allocation of reasonable dues, fees and other charges among members and
issuers and other persons using any facility, and is not designed to
permit unfair discrimination between customers, issuers, brokers, or
dealers.\78\ The Exchange explains that this belief is based on several
factors: First, the Exchange states that exchange fees are constrained
because market participants can choose among seventeen different venues
for options trading, and therefore no single venue can charge excessive
fees without losing customers and market share.\79\ Second, the
Exchange states that fees for TOPO are constrained because the
identical top of book data is sent to OPRA, and certain market
participants may choose to rely exclusively on OPRA rather than
purchasing the proprietary data product.\80\ Third, the Exchange states
that the purchase of PHLX Orders is optional, that it is designed as a
lower-cost alternative to depth of book--and, as such, is not a
complement to any other product offered by the Exchange or any of its
competitors, and that customers may purchase PHLX Orders or not, and
can reject the feed for any reason--including the fee charged.\81\
Fourth, the Exchange states that the proposed fees are comparable to,
and in some cases less than, those of similarly situated exchanges.\82\
Fifth, the Exchange states that the current fees do not properly
reflect the value of the underlying product, as fees for the products
in question have been static in nominal terms, and therefore falling in
real terms (due to inflation), while the amount of information
transmitted in those fees have more than doubled in just the past five
years, reflecting a substantial increase in customer value due to the
significantly higher levels of liquidity currently available on the
Exchange.\83\ Sixth, the Exchange states that higher fees for the
external distribution of TOPO, PHLX Orders, and TOPO Plus Orders are
based on the
[[Page 45040]]
additional value vendors receive from distributing data to their own
customers and typically charging for the service.\84\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\76\ 15 U.S.C. 78f(b).
\77\ 15 U.S.C. 78f(b)(4) and (5).
\78\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\79\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\80\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\81\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\82\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650.
\83\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21650-51.
\84\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that customers face many choices in where to
trade options. The Exchange explains that until recently, sixteen
exchanges have offered options trading services, and they are now being
joined by a 17th member.\85\ The Exchange states that not a single
options exchange trades more than 11 percent of the options market by
volume.\86\ The Exchange states that PHLX, the second largest options
exchange by volume, only has 9 percent of the options market.\87\ The
Exchange states that only one of the 17 options exchanges have a market
share over 10 percent.\88\ The Exchange states that this broad
dispersion of market share demonstrates that market participants can
and do exercise choice in options trading venues.\89\ The Exchange also
states that as the number of exchanges continues to grow, competition
will become fiercer and customer choice will continue to expand.\90\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\85\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651 (citing OPRA Plan, list of OPRA
Participant Exchanges, available at <a href="https://www.opraplan.com/faqs">https://www.opraplan.com/faqs</a>,
and Securities Exchange Act Release No. 98388 (September 14, 2023),
88 FR 64963 (September 20, 2023) (File No. 4-443) (``Joint Industry
Plan; Notice of Filing and Immediate Effectiveness of Amendment to
the Plan for the Purpose of Developing and Implementing Procedures
Designed To Facilitate the Listing and Trading of Standardized
Options To Add MEMX LLC as a Plan Sponsor'')). The Exchange states
that all options exchanges are members of the OPRA Plan. Id.
\86\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651 (citing Nasdaq, Options Market
Statistics (Last updated November 3, 2023), available at <a href="https://www.nasdaqtrader.com/Trader.aspx?id=OptionsVolumeSummary">https://www.nasdaqtrader.com/Trader.aspx?id=OptionsVolumeSummary</a>). The
Exchange states that on November 3, 2023, the total percentage of
options market volume by exchange was as follows: ARCA: 11%; PHLX:
9%; CBOE: 9%; BOX: 8%; ISE: 7%; EDGX: 7%; AMEX: 7%; MIAX: 7%; MPRL:
7%; NOM: 6%; BATS: 6%; C2: 5%; EMLD: 4%; MRX: 3%; GEMX: 3%; BXOP:
3%; MEMX: 0%. Id.
\87\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651.
\88\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651.
\89\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651.
\90\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that most option contracts on the TOPO, TOPO
Plus, and Orders data feeds are traded on multiple exchanges.\91\ The
Exchange states that a sample of trading on March 7, 2024, from The
Options Clearing Corporation shows that 5,836 symbols were traded on
PHLX's options exchange, of which only 53 symbols were listed on the
PHLX options exchange only, and another 33 symbols were listed on
multiple Nasdaq-affiliated options exchanges.\92\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\91\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651.
\92\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that, in order to remain competitive with other
options exchanges, PHLX, like some options exchanges, offers several
proprietary options products that are only traded on Nasdaq-affiliated
exchanges.\93\ The Exchange states that these include products based on
the Nasdaq 100[supreg] Index, such as NDX (Nasdaq 100 Index on PHLX,
Nasdaq GEMX, LLC (``GEMX'') and Nasdaq ISE, LLC (``ISE'')), XND (Nasdaq
100 Micro Index on PHLX and ISE), and NQX (Nasdaq 100 Micro Index on
ISE), as well as volatility products such as VOLQ (Nasdaq-100[supreg]
Volatility Index), foreign currency options, and other products.\94\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\93\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651.
\94\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651. The Exchange states that the
NASDAQ-100 is an index which includes 100 of the world's largest
non-financial companies listed on the wider NASDAQ Stock market,
based on their market capitalization. See Notice, 89 FR at 21651.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that some Nasdaq option proprietary products
are subject to direct, substitution-based competition from other
options exchanges and that all Nasdaq option proprietary products are
subject to the competition among exchanges for membership and market
share.\95\ The Exchange states that examples of substitution-based
competition include the VOLQ, which can be substituted with the Cboe
Volatility Index[supreg] (``VIX'').\96\ The Exchange states that NDX
(listed in PHLX, GEMX and ISE), XND (listed on PHLX and ISE) and NQX
(listed on ISE) all offer different ways of gaining exposure to the
Nasdaq 100[supreg] Index, are therefore each serves as a direct
substitute for the others.\97\ The Exchange also states that the Nasdaq
100[supreg] Index products also have alternatives among other
exchanges.\98\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\95\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651.
\96\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651 (citing Securities Exchange Act
Release No. 95170 (June 29, 2022), 87 FR 40295 (July 6, 2022) (SR-
Phlx-2022-27) (explaining that the Nasdaq-100[supreg] Volatility
Index (``VOLQ'') is subject to ``significant substitution-based
competitive forces; market participants can substitute options on
VOLQ for products offered by other exchanges, for example, the
options on the Cboe Volatility Index[supreg] (``VIX'').'')).
\97\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651 (citing Securities Exchange Act
Release No. 99141 (December 12, 2023), 88 FR 87466 (December 18,
2023) (SR-Phlx-2023-55) (``[M]arket participants are offered
different ways to gain exposure to the Nasdaq 100 Index, whether
through the Exchange's proprietary products like options overlying
NDX, NDPX, or XND, or separately through multi-listed options
overlying Invesco QQQ Trust (``QQQ''); Securities Exchange Act
Release No. 99171 (December 14, 2023), 88 FR 88206 (December 20,
2023) (SR-ISE-2023-36) (explaining that NDX, XND and NQX provide
``market participants with a variety of choices in selecting the
product they desire to utilize in order to gain exposure to the
Nasdaq 100 Index.'')).
\98\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651 (citing Securities Exchange Act
Release No. 99141 n.7 (December 12, 2023), 88 FR 87466 (December 18,
2023) (SR-Phlx-2023-55) (explaining that the fees for NDX and NDXP
are in line with fees assessed by Cboe on its MXEA and MXEF options
products)).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that exchange proprietary products are also
subject to competition among exchanges for membership and market
share.\99\ The Exchange states that there are many factors that may
cause a market participant to decide to become a member of a particular
exchange; among these are product offerings.\100\ The Exchange states
that introducing new and innovative products to the marketplace
designed to meet customer demands may attract market participants to
become a member of a particular options venue by allowing market
participants greater trading opportunities and new avenues to manage
risks.\101\ The Exchange states that an exchange's proprietary product
offering may attract order flow to a particular exchange to trade a
particular options product and generally make that exchange a more
desirable venue to transaction options, thereby attracting membership
to that exchange.\102\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\99\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651 (citing Securities Exchange Act
Release No. 95170 (June 29, 2022), 87 FR 40295 (July 6, 2022) (SR-
Phlx-2022-27) (discussing the role of proprietary data products in
the competition among exchanges)).
\100\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651.
\101\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651.
\102\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that, in light of the number of trading venues
available to customers, the Exchange must price its products, including
TOPO, PHLX Orders, and TOPO Plus Orders (as well as other products),
competitively, otherwise customers would move to other venues.\103\ The
Exchange states that, ``[i]f competitive forces are operative, the
self-interest of the exchanges themselves will work powerfully to
constrain unreasonable or unfair behavior'' and, accordingly, ``the
existence of significant competition provides a substantial basis for
finding that the terms of an exchange's fee proposal are equitable,
fair, reasonable, and not unreasonably or unfairly discriminatory.''
\104\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\103\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651.
\104\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651 (citing Securities Exchange Act
Release No. 59039 (December 2, 2008), 73 FR 74,770 (December 9,
2008) (SR-NYSEArca-2006-21)).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that the top of book data in TOPO is sent to
OPRA; under OPRA rules, proprietary options information is available to
customers that have equivalent access to OPRA information, and
therefore is supplementary to the OPRA feed.\105\
[[Page 45041]]
The Exchange states that, specifically, Section 5.2(c)(iii) of the OPRA
Plan provides that ``[a] Member [of the OPRA Plan] may disseminate its
Proprietary Information,'' provided that ``such dissemination is
limited to other Members and to persons who also have equivalent access
to consolidated Options Information disseminated by OPRA for the same
classes or series of options that are included in the Proprietary
Information. . . .'' \106\ The Exchange states that ``Consolidated
Options Information'' refers to ``consolidated Last Sale Reports
combined with either consolidated Quotation Information or the BBO
furnished by OPRA'' and that access is deemed to be ``equivalent'' ``if
both if both kinds of information are equally accessible on the same
terminal or work station. . . .'' \107\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\105\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651 (citing Limited Liability
Company Agreement of Options Price Reporting Authority, LLC Sec.
5.2(c)(iii) (January 1, 2010), available at <a href="https://assets.website-files.com/5ba40927ac854d8c97bc92d7/5d0bd57d87d3ccca102102d7_OPRA%20Plan%20with%20Updated%20Exhibit%20A%20-%2006-19-2019.pdf">https://assets.website-files.com/5ba40927ac854d8c97bc92d7/5d0bd57d87d3ccca102102d7_OPRA%20Plan%20with%20Updated%20Exhibit%20A%20-%2006-19-2019.pdf</a> (``OPRA Plan'')).
\106\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21651 (citing Section 5.2(c)(iii) of
the OPRA Plan).
\107\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21652 (citing Section 5.2(c)(iii) of
the OPRA Plan).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that any customer that purchases proprietary
options data from the Exchange, including TOPO and TOPO Plus Orders,
must also have equivalent access to the OPRA Plan.\108\ The Exchange
states that the best bid and offer and last sale information available
from TOPO and TOPO Plus Orders fees is identical to the information
simultaneously sent to OPRA by the Exchange and that OPRA provides NBBO
and last sale information on options transactions.\109\ The Exchange
states that TOPO and TOPO Plus Orders provide additional administrative
information unique to trading on the Exchange, and also reduce the
transmission and processing latencies generated through the process of
consolidating data into the OPRA feed.\110\ The Exchange states that
because top of book and last sale information is available on OPRA as
well as TOPO, and customers who purchase TOPO have equivalent access to
the OPRA feed, certain customers may choose to rely on the OPRA feed in
lieu of purchasing PHLX data, thereby limiting the ability of the
Exchange from charging excessive fees for its TOPO and TOPO Plus Orders
feeds.\111\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\108\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21652.
\109\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21652. The Exchange states that the
TOPO feed includes administrative information (but not data) that is
not provided on the OPRA feed, such as symbol directory messages.
See Notice, 89 FR at 21652 (citing Nasdaq, ``Top of Phlx Options
Interface Specifications, Version 3.4'' Section 4.3 available at
<a href="https://www.nasdaqtrader.com/content/technicalsupport/specifications/dataproducts/topofphlx.pdf">https://www.nasdaqtrader.com/content/technicalsupport/specifications/dataproducts/topofphlx.pdf</a> (describing the start of
day options directory message, which lists all symbols eligible for
the auction process)).
\110\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21652. The Exchange states that bid
and offer and last sale information provided with the TOPO Plus
Orders product is identical to the data sent to OPRA, although the
``orders'' component of TOPO Plus Orders is not. Id.
\111\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21652.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that purchase of PHLX Orders is optional and
that customers can obtain all of the data contained in PHLX Orders from
PHLX Depth of Market feed, and may purchase the latter if they do not
realize the cost savings offered by PHLX Orders.\112\ The Exchange
states that PHLX Orders is not a complement to any other product
offered by the Exchange or any of its competitors; customers are free
to purchase PHLX Orders or not, and can reject the feed for any reason,
including the fee charged.\113\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\112\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21652.
\113\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21652.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that the proposed fees are comparable to, and
in some cases less than, those of other similarly situated exchange
fees.\114\ The Exchange states that options market statistics show that
PHLX has a market share of approximately 9%, and that ARCA, with an 11%
market share, and CBOE, with a 9% market share, are its closest
competitors.\115\ The Exchange states that to obtain top of book and
depth of book information for internal distribution (including both
simple and complex options) from ARCA, a customer would be required to
pay an Access Fee of $3,000 per month, a Non-Display fee of at least
$5,000 per month for simple options, and a Non-Display fee of $1,000
for Complex Options, for a total of $9,000 per month.\116\ The Exchange
states that to obtain the same information from PHLX under the new
proposal, a customer would pay the Internal Distributor fee of $2,500
for TOPO, and an Internal Distributor fee of $4,000 for PHLX Depth
Data, for a total of $6,500 per month.\117\ The Exchange states that to
obtain comparable information for Cboe Options, a customer would be
required to pay a combined fee of $9,000 per month.\118\ The Exchange
states that a PHLX customer would pay the Internal Distributor fee of
$2,500 for TOPO, and an Internal Distributor fee of $4,000 for PHLX
Depth Data, for a total of $6,500 per month.\119\ The Exchange states
that as such, the proposed fees are comparable to fees charged by
industry peers, and therefore presumptively reasonable.\120\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\114\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21652.
\115\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21652 (citing Nasdaq, Options Market
Statistics (Last updated November 3, 2023), available at <a href="https://www.nasdaqtrader.com/Trader.aspx?id=OptionsVolumeSummary">https://www.nasdaqtrader.com/Trader.aspx?id=OptionsVolumeSummary</a>).
\116\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21652 (citing NYSE Arca Options
Proprietary Market Data Fees (as of July 3, 2023), available at
<a href="https://www.nyse.com/publicdocs/nyse/data/NYSE_Arca_Options_Proprietary_Data_Fee_Schedule.pdf">https://www.nyse.com/publicdocs/nyse/data/NYSE_Arca_Options_Proprietary_Data_Fee_Schedule.pdf</a>).
\117\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21652 (citing Options 7, Section 10
(Proprietary Data Feed Fees) (PHLX Depth Data)). The Exchange states
that ARCA does not charge separately for top of book and depth of
book. Id. The Exchange states that although PHLX is not proposing to
change fees for depth of book information, PHLX depth of book
information is included here to maintain comparability. Id.
\118\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21652 (citing Cboe Data Services
(CDS), Market Data Product Price List (updated July 1, 2023),
available at <a href="https://cdn.cboe.com/resources/membership/US_Market_Data_Product_Price_List.pdf">https://cdn.cboe.com/resources/membership/US_Market_Data_Product_Price_List.pdf</a>).
\119\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21652 (citing Options 7, Section 10
(Proprietary Data Feed Fees) (PHLX Depth Data)). The Exchange states
that ARCA does not charge separately for top of book and depth of
book. Although PHLX is not proposing to change fees for depth of
book information, PHLX depth of book information is included here to
ensure comparability. Id.
\120\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21652.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that the Internal Distributor fee for TOPO Plus
Orders was increased in 2018, while none of the other fees have changed
for over a decade, since January 2013, and that this means that fees
for TOPO, PHLX Orders, and TOPO Plus Orders have fallen in real terms
due to inflation.\121\ The Exchange explains that, using data generated
by the Department of Commerce to estimate inflation in the market for
portfolio management and investment services, inflation has increased
prices by 63.9% since January 2013, when most of the fees at issue were
set, and 15.7% since January 2018, when internal distributor fees for
TOPO Plus Orders were last modified.\122\ The Exchange states that, at
the same time, the average daily message count of PHLX has more than
doubled in just five years, from approximately 3.0 billion messages per
day in 2018 to approximately 8.2 billion messages in 2023.\123\ The
Exchange states that PHLX
[[Page 45042]]
grew in conjunction with options trading overall, which in the
aggregate grew at a faster pace than PHLX alone--specifically stating
that between January 2018 and December 2023, options volume on PHLX
grew by 31%, while options volume on all exchanges nearly doubled, from
467 million options to 912 million instruments.\124\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\121\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21652 (citing Securities Exchange Act
Release No. 82495 (January 12, 2018), 83 FR 2839 (January 19, 2018)
(SR-Phlx-2018-08) and Securities Exchange Act Release No. 68576
(January 3, 2013), 78 FR 1886 (January 9, 2013) (SR-Phlx-2012-145)).
\122\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21652 (citing Bureau of Economic
Analysis, U.S. Department of Commerce, ``Personal Consumption
Expenditures Price Index,'' available at <a href="https://www.bea.gov/data/personal-consumption-expenditures-price-index">https://www.bea.gov/data/personal-consumption-expenditures-price-index</a>).
\123\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21652 (citing PHLX Data (Average
Daily Message Count was 2,979,919,551.32 in 2018, and
8,243,516,029.17 thus far in 2023)). The Exchange states that the
significant increases in data traffic have also required
technological upgrades to manage the larger traffic volume and to
respond to overall technological change in the industry. See Notice,
89 FR at 21652 (citing See, e.g., Securities Exchange Act Release
No. 82495 (January 12, 2018), 83 FR 2839 (January 19, 2018) (SR-
Phlx-2018-08) (discussing a number of functional enhancements to
both TOPO and PHLX Orders)).
\124\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21652 (citing Options Clearing
Corporation, ``Volume and Open Interest,'' available at <a href="https://www.theocc.com/market-data/market-data-reports/volume-and-open-interest/volume-by-exchange">https://www.theocc.com/market-data/market-data-reports/volume-and-open-interest/volume-by-exchange</a>).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that growth in options trading means better
value for the consumer, that the greater variety of options contracts
traded means that customers have more choice, and that the greater
number of buyers and sellers in the market means that there is more
liquidity, resulting in tighter spreads and better consumer value on
each trade.\125\ The Exchange further states that greater choice and
tighter spreads mean that the consumer obtains more value from options
markets overall, which should be reflected in fees for exchange
services, including market data.\126\ The Exchange concludes that the
proposal is therefore reasonable in light of the substantial increase
in customer value generate by the higher levels of liquidity now
available on the Exchange, coupled with the fall in real prices due to
inflation.\127\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\125\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21652.
\126\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21652.
\127\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21652-53.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that External Distributors receive additional
value not available to Internal Distributors by disseminating
information externally and typically charging for the service and that
this additional value supports higher fees for external distribution
for TOPO, PHLX Orders, and TOPO Plus Orders.\128\ The Exchange states
that higher fees for external distribution of data are common
throughout the industry, and nearly universal among exchanges and that
the difference in value between internal and external distribution is
also reflected in the current fee schedule.\129\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\128\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21653.
\129\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21653.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange states that, in summary, the proposal represents an
equitable allocation of reasonable dues, fees and other charges
because: (i) customers have a choice in trading venue, and will
exercise that choice and trade at another venue if exchange fees are
not set competitively; (ii) the top of book data sent in the TOPO feed
are also sent to OPRA, and customers have the option of relying on OPRA
data; (iii) the purchase of PHLX Orders is entirely optional as it is a
low-cost alternative to the PHLX Depth of Market product; (iv) the
proposed fees are comparable to those of other exchanges; (v) exchange
fees have fallen in real terms while the amount of liquidity available
on the exchange has increased, and (vi) external vendors receive
additional value from distributing data to their own customers and
typically charging for the service, and therefore charging higher fees
for external distribution is fair and reasonable.\130\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\130\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21653.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Exchange also states that the Proposal is not unfairly
discriminatory.\131\ The Exchange states that the three market data
feeds at issue here--TOPO, PHLX Orders, and TOPO Plus Orders--are used
by a variety of market participants for a variety of purposes, and
states that users include regulators, market makers, competing
exchanges, media, retail, academics, portfolio managers.\132\ The
Exchange states that market data feeds will be available to members of
all of these groups on a non-discriminatory basis.\133\ The Exchange
also does not believe that the proposed rule change will impose any
burden on competition not necessary or appropriate in furtherance of
the purposes of the Act.\134\ The Exchange states that nothing in the
Proposal burdens inter-market competition (the competition among self-
regulatory organizations) because approval of the Proposal does not
impose any burden on the ability of other options exchanges to
compete.\135\ The Exchange states that PHLX fees are comparable to, and
in some cases less than, those of other exchanges.\136\ The Exchange
finally states that nothing in the Proposal burdens intra-market
competition (the competition among consumers of exchange data) because
PHLX market data is available to any customer under the same fee
schedule as any other customer, and any market participant that wishes
to purchase PHLX market data can do so on a non-discriminatory
basis.\137\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\131\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21653.
\132\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21653.
\133\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21653.
\134\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21653.
\135\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21653.
\136\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21653.
\137\ See Notice, 89 FR at 21653.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
B. Suspension
When exchanges file their proposed rule changes with the
Commission, including fee filings like the Exchange's present proposal,
they are required to provide a statement supporting the proposal's
basis under the Act and the rules and regulations thereunder applicable
to the exchange.\138\ The instructions to Form 19b-4, on which
exchanges file their proposed rule changes, specify that such statement
``should be sufficiently detailed and specific to support a finding
that the proposed rule change is consistent with [those]
requirements.'' \139\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\138\ See 17 CFR 240.19b-4 (Item 3 entitled ``Self-Regulatory
Organization's Statement of the Purpose of, and Statutory Basis for,
the Proposed Rule Change''). To date, the Commission has received
one comment letter on proposed rule change, which does not appear to
be relevant to the instant filing. See Ross Letter.
\139\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 6 of the Act, including Sections 6(b)(4), (5), and (8),
require the rules of an exchange to: (1) provide for the equitable
allocation of reasonable fees among members, issuers, and other persons
using the exchange's facilities; \140\ (2) perfect the mechanism of a
free and open market and a national market system, protect investors
and the public interest, and not be designed to permit unfair
discrimination between customers, issuers, brokers, or dealers; \141\
and (3) not impose any burden on competition not necessary or
appropriate in furtherance of the purposes of the Act.\142\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\140\ 15 U.S.C. 78f(b)(4).
\141\ 15 U.S.C. 78f(b)(5).
\142\ 15 U.S.C. 78f(b)(8).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In temporarily suspending the Exchange's proposed rule change, the
Commission intends to further consider whether the Proposal to increase
market data fees is consistent with the statutory requirements
applicable to a national securities exchange under the Act. In
particular, the Commission will consider whether the proposed rule
change satisfies the standards under the Act and the rules thereunder
requiring, among other things, that an exchange's rules provide for the
equitable allocation of reasonable fees among members, issuers, and
other persons using its facilities; not permit unfair discrimination
between customers, issuers, brokers or dealers; and do not impose any
burden on competition not necessary or appropriate in furtherance of
the purposes of the Act.\143\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\143\ See 15 U.S.C. 78f(b)(4), (5), and (8), respectively.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Therefore, the Commission finds that it is appropriate in the
public interest, for the protection of investors, and otherwise in
furtherance of the purposes of the Act, to temporarily suspend the
proposed rule change.\144\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\144\ For purposes of temporarily suspending the proposed rule
change, the Commission has considered the proposed rule's impact on
efficiency, competition, and capital formation. See 15 U.S.C.
78c(f).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 45043]]
IV. Proceedings To Determine Whether To Approve or Disapprove the
Proposed Rule Changes
In addition to temporarily suspending the Proposal, the Commission
also hereby institutes proceedings pursuant to Sections 19(b)(3)(C)
\145\ and 19(b)(2)(B) of the Act \146\ to determine whether the
Exchange's proposed rule change should be approved or disapproved.
Institution of proceedings does not indicate that the Commission has
reached any conclusions with respect to any of the issues involved.
Rather, the Commission seeks and encourages interested persons to
provide additional comment on the proposed rule change to inform the
Commission's analysis of whether to approve or disapprove the proposed
rule change.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\145\ 15 U.S.C. 78s(b)(3)(C). Once the Commission temporarily
suspends a proposed rule change, Section 19(b)(3)(C) of the Act
requires that the Commission institute proceedings under Section
19(b)(2)(B) to determine whether a proposed rule change should be
approved or disapproved.
\146\ 15 U.S.C. 78s(b)(2)(B).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pursuant to Section 19(b)(2)(B) of the Act,\147\ the Commission is
providing notice of the grounds for possible disapproval under
consideration:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\147\ Id. Section 19(b)(2)(B) of the Act also provides that
proceedings to determine whether to disapprove a proposed rule
change must be concluded within 180 days of the date of publication
of notice of the filing of the proposed rule change. See id. The
time for conclusion of the proceedings may be extended for up to 60
days if the Commission finds good cause for such extension and
publishes its reasons for so finding, or if the exchange consents to
the longer period. See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
<bullet> Whether the Exchange has demonstrated how the proposed
fees are consistent with Section 6(b)(4) of the Act, which requires
that the rules of a national securities exchange ``provide for the
equitable allocation of reasonable dues, fees, and other charges among
its members and issuers and other persons using its facilities''; \148\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\148\ 15 U.S.C. 78f(b)(4).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
<bullet> Whether the Exchange has demonstrated how the proposed
fees are consistent with Section 6(b)(5) of the Act, which requires,
among other things, that the rules of a national securities exchange
not be ``designed to permit unfair discrimination between customers,
issuers, brokers, or dealers''; \149\ and
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\149\ 15 U.S.C. 78f(b)(5).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
<bullet> Whether the Exchange has demonstrated how the proposed
fees are consistent with Section 6(b)(8) of the Act, which requires
that the rules of a national securities exchange ``not impose any
burden on competition not necessary or appropriate in furtherance of
the purposes of [the Act].'' \150\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\150\ 15 U.S.C. 78f(b)(8).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As discussed in Section III above, the Exchange made various
arguments in support of the Proposal. There are questions as to whether
the Exchange has provided sufficient information to demonstrate that
the proposed fees are consistent with the Act and the rules thereunder.
The Commission will specifically consider, among other things, whether
the Exchange has provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate that the
proposed market data fees are reasonable and equitably allocated, are
not unfairly discriminatory, and do not impose any burden on
competition that is not necessary or appropriate in furtherance of the
purposes of the Act.
Under the Commission's Rules of Practice, the ``burden to
demonstrate that a proposed rule change is consistent with the [Act]
and the rules and regulations issued thereunder . . . is on the [SRO]
that proposed the rule change.'' \151\ The description of a proposed
rule change, its purpose and operation, its effect, and a legal
analysis of its consistency with applicable requirements must all be
sufficiently detailed and specific to support an affirmative Commission
finding,\152\ and any failure of an SRO to provide this information may
result in the Commission not having a sufficient basis to make an
affirmative finding that a proposed rule change is consistent with the
Act and the applicable rules and regulations.\153\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\151\ 17 CFR 201.700(b)(3).
\152\ See id.
\153\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Commission is instituting proceedings to allow for additional
consideration and comment on the issues raised herein, including as to
whether the proposed fees are consistent with the Act, and
specifically, with its requirements that exchange fees be reasonable
and equitably allocated, not be unfairly discriminatory, and not impose
any burden on competition that is not necessary or appropriate in
furtherance of the purposes of the Act.\154\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\154\ See 15 U.S.C. 78f(b)(4), (5), and (8).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
V. Commission's Solicitation of Comments
The Commission requests written views, data, and arguments with
respect to the concerns identified above as well as any other relevant
concerns. Such comments should be submitted by June 12, 2024. Rebuttal
comments should be submitted by June 26, 2024. Although there do not
appear to be any issues relevant to approval or disapproval that would
be facilitated by an oral presentation of views, data, and arguments,
the Commission will consider, pursuant to Rule 19b-4, any request for
an opportunity to make an oral presentation.\155\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\155\ 15 U.S.C. 78s(b)(2). Section 19(b)(2) of the Act grants
the Commission flexibility to determine what type of proceeding--
either oral or notice and opportunity for written comments--is
appropriate for consideration of a particular proposal by an SRO.
See Securities Acts Amendments of 1975, Report of the Senate
Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs to Accompany S. 249,
S. Rep. No. 75, 94th Cong., 1st Sess. 30 (1975).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Commission asks that commenters address the sufficiency and
merit of the Exchange's statements in support of the Proposal, in
addition to any other comments they may wish to submit about the
proposed rule changes.
Interested persons are invited to submit written data, views and
arguments concerning the foregoing, including whether the proposed rule
change is consistent with the Act. Comments may be submitted by any of
the following methods:
Electronic Comments
<bullet> Use the Commission's internet comment form (<a href="https://www.sec.gov/rules/sro.shtml">https://www.sec.gov/rules/sro.shtml</a>); or
<bullet> Send an email to <a href="/cdn-cgi/l/email-protection#e193948d84cc828e8c8c848f9592a1928482cf868e97"><span class="__cf_email__" data-cfemail="95e7e0f9f0b8f6faf8f8f0fbe1e6d5e6f0f6bbf2fae3">[email protected]</span></a>. Please include
file number SR-Phlx-2024-15 on the subject line.
Paper Comments
<bullet> Send paper comments in triplicate to Secretary, Securities
and Exchange Commission, 100 F Street NE, Washington, DC 20549-1090.
All submissions should refer to file number SR-Phlx-2024-15. This file
number should be included on the subject line if email is used. To help
the Commission process and review your comments more efficiently,
please use only one method. The Commission will post all comments on
the Commission's internet website (<a href="https://www.sec.gov/rules/sro.shtml">https://www.sec.gov/rules/sro.shtml</a>). Copies of the submission, all subsequent amendments, all
written statements with respect to the proposed rule change that are
filed with the Commission, and all written communications relating to
the proposed rule change between the Commission and any person, other
than those that may be withheld from the public in accordance with the
provisions of 5 U.S.C. 552, will be available for website viewing and
printing in the Commission's Public Reference Room, 100 F Street NE,
Washington, DC 20549, on official
[[Page 45044]]
business days between the hours of 10 a.m. and 3 p.m. Copies of the
filing also will be available for inspection and copying at the
principal office of the Exchange. Do not include personal identifiable
information in submissions; you should submit only information that you
wish to make available publicly. We may redact in part or withhold
entirely from publication submitted material that is obscene or subject
to copyright protection. All submissions should refer to file number
SR-Phlx-2024-15 and should be submitted on or before June 12, 2024.
Rebuttal comments should be submitted by June 26, 2024.
VI. Conclusion
It is therefore ordered, pursuant to Section 19(b)(3)(C) of the
Act,\156\ that File No. SR-Phlx-2024-15, be and hereby is, temporarily
suspended. In addition, the Commission is instituting proceedings to
determine whether the proposed rule change should be approved or
disapproved.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\156\ 15 U.S.C. 78s(b)(3)(C).
For the Commission, by the Division of Trading and Markets,
pursuant to delegated authority.\157\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\157\ 17 CFR 200.30-3(a)(57).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sherry R. Haywood,
Assistant Secretary.
[FR Doc. 2024-11168 Filed 5-21-24; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 8011-01-P
</pre><script data-cfasync="false" src="/cdn-cgi/scripts/5c5dd728/cloudflare-static/email-decode.min.js"></script></body>
</html>Indexed from Federal Register on May 22, 2024.
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.